Join the conversation on Discord!
May 28, 2024

S6E9 - The Future of Humanity: Rationalists

Wanna chat about the episode? Or just hang out?   --- Have not you read The Sequences?   Chris & Kayla do their first ever CoJW topic revisit and discuss an online community dedicated to Rationalism.   --- *Search Categories*...

Wanna chat about the episode? Or just hang out?

Come join us on discord!

 

---

Have not you read The Sequences?

 

Chris & Kayla do their first ever CoJW topic revisit and discuss an online community dedicated to Rationalism.

 

---

*Search Categories*

Anthropological; Science / Pseudoscience; Common interest / Fandom; Internet Culture

 

---

*Topic Spoiler*

LessWrong

 

---

*Further Reading*

https://www.lesswrong.com/

https://www.reddit.com/r/LessWrong/

https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/LessWrong

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LessWrong

The Sequences

just some Harry Potter fanfic

https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/DyG8tzmj3NnGRE8Gt/explaining-the-rationalist-movement-to-the-uninitiated

https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/LgavAYtzFQZKg95WC/extreme-rationality-it-s-not-that-great (the community is remarkably self-aware)

Yudkowsky on cults!

Yudkowsky on cults again!

the podcast eats its tail (CoJW's previous LessWrong episode)

https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Roko's_basilisk

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8060440

https://www.reddit.com/r/askphilosophy/comments/19cmro3/should_i_read_lesswrong_wiki_or_not/

https://www.reddit.com/r/askphilosophy/comments/2ddfs6/comment/cjp22pf/

Slate Star Codex (LessWrong2.0)

somethingawful has a bitch-thread about LessWrong

https://www.reddit.com/r/SneerClub/ (LessWrong hater's group)

https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Bayesian

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Functional_Decision_Theory

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newcomb%27s_paradox

Time platforms Yudkowsky's doomerism

Receipts for how bad Yudkowsky's predictions have been

 

 

 

 

---

*Patreon Credits*

Michaela Evans, Heather Aunspach, Alyssa Ottum, David Whiteside, Jade A, amy sarah marshall, Martina Dobson, Eillie Anzilotti, Lewis Brown, Kelly Smith Upton, Wild Hunt Alex, Niklas Brock

<<>>

Jenny Lamb, Matthew Walden, Rebecca Kirsch, Pam Westergard, Ryan Quinn, Paul Sweeney, Erin Bratu, Liz T, Lianne Cole, Samantha Bayliff, Katie Larimer, Fio H, Jessica Senk, Proper Gander, Nancy Carlson, Carly Westergard-Dobson, banana, Megan Blackburn, Instantly Joy, Athena of CaveSystem, John Grelish, Rose Kerchinske, Annika Ramen, Alicia Smith, Kevin, Velm, Dan Malmud, tiny, Dom, Tribe Label - Panda - Austin, Noelle Hoover, Tesa Hamilton, Nicole Carter, Paige, Brian Lancaster, tiny

Transcript
1
00:00:00,640 --> 00:00:56,500
Kayla: On November 14, 1977, RLA Prabhupda, the founder of the International Society for Ka Consciousness, aka the Hare Krishnas, rested in his quarters. He was staying at one of his organizations temples in the city of Vrindavan, India, a holy site for their faith as supreme Lord Krishna had spent his childhood in this city. There are over 5000 temples dedicated to Krishna in Vrindavan. But right at this moment, Prabhupadas might be the most important, because at this moment, ac Bhaktivedanta swami Prabhupada lay dying. Prabhupda was joined by dozens, if not hundreds of his followers who sang and chanted the Maha mantra in Kirtan, playing instruments and praising Krishna. Their leader had been ill for six months, and everyone knew the moment of truth was drawing near. And just like that, it was upon them. At 82 years old, Srila Prabhupda took his last shuddering breath.

2
00:00:57,120 --> 00:02:00,130
Kayla: You and I would say that he died, but his followers instead say that he disappeared, his soul breaking free of this karmic cycle and reuniting with the oneness of Krishna. The kirtan did not stop upon prabhupdas death. The chanting and singing continued on, lasting for the next 24 hours. He was buried two days later, resting eternally now in the temple grounds. The founder, Acharya of ISkcon, was gone, leaving behind a gaping power vacuum. The question now was, who would step in to fill it? Music drop now we're doing the show. Here's my little story.

3
00:02:00,430 --> 00:02:02,750
Chris: All right, so he was a vacuum at this point.

4
00:02:02,790 --> 00:02:07,750
Kayla: You said like a Dyson when Hare Krishna dies.

5
00:02:07,830 --> 00:02:08,526
Chris: Was that funny?

6
00:02:08,598 --> 00:02:12,910
Kayla: They become a vacuum. No, it wasn't, actually.

7
00:02:12,950 --> 00:02:13,494
Chris: That was stupid.

8
00:02:13,542 --> 00:02:18,750
Kayla: Terrible. No, we're talking about a power vacuum, which is a different kind of vacuum.

9
00:02:18,910 --> 00:02:22,528
Chris: We should call our vacuum a power vacuum. That'd be pretty cool.

10
00:02:22,584 --> 00:02:25,936
Kayla: I bet if you googled power vacuum, it would just give you really powerful vacuums.

11
00:02:26,048 --> 00:02:26,980
Chris: Yeah, maybe.

12
00:02:27,560 --> 00:02:32,328
Kayla: This is Kayla. I am a television writer going back to work on Monday. Yay. Woohoo.

13
00:02:32,424 --> 00:02:34,608
Chris: Good job with doing the strike thing.

14
00:02:34,664 --> 00:02:34,944
Kayla: Thanks.

15
00:02:34,992 --> 00:02:35,696
Chris: How you did that.

16
00:02:35,768 --> 00:02:36,540
Kayla: Did it.

17
00:02:37,000 --> 00:02:57,510
Chris: You know what? You did a lot of it. I did a little bit in the grand scheme of things. Yes, it's a little bit, but even a little bit in the grand scheme of things is a lot. That's. You can quote that, I'll put it on a shirt, but you have to pay me. So my name is Chris. I'm a quote master and sometimes also game developer.

18
00:02:57,850 --> 00:03:01,050
Kayla: And this is culture. Just weird. The podcast.

19
00:03:01,170 --> 00:03:01,610
Chris: Yes.

20
00:03:01,690 --> 00:03:03,754
Kayla: And also the vibe.

21
00:03:03,842 --> 00:03:06,426
Chris: The podcast. The vibe. The discord.

22
00:03:06,538 --> 00:03:07,298
Kayla: The discord.

23
00:03:07,394 --> 00:03:26,142
Chris: This is our third time in a row that we've been live broadcasting this absolute hellish mess onto our discord server for our discord friends to hear. So go ahead and join. I know I say this every episode, but call to action. Head to our socials. There's links there. Join us in the discord. It's very weird. It's a fun time.

24
00:03:26,286 --> 00:03:28,326
Kayla: I stream music on Fridays.

25
00:03:28,518 --> 00:03:33,150
Chris: Kayla's very proud of that. Kayla's very proud of her musical tastes.

26
00:03:33,230 --> 00:03:33,970
Kayla: I am.

27
00:03:34,510 --> 00:03:38,278
Chris: People listen to my music, and it's so good.

28
00:03:38,334 --> 00:03:40,078
Kayla: Not music that I make, just music that I pick.

29
00:03:40,174 --> 00:03:44,414
Chris: Yeah, nobody makes music. It's about taste. Okay.

30
00:03:44,542 --> 00:03:53,830
Kayla: I will say with our discord, there is also a special patron corner for our Patreon patrons. And just giving a little shout out to one of our newest Patreon patrons.

31
00:03:53,910 --> 00:04:07,446
Chris: This month, Brian Lancaster. Thank you so much for supporting us on Patreon. We love our patrons, and, I don't know. Thank you. We need to get a standard thank you, because every time I'm just like, thank you and also thank you.

32
00:04:07,518 --> 00:04:19,829
Kayla: Thanks and thanks. See you in the discord. Do you have any other business, other banter, anything you need to get off your chest before we dive into this? The kind of lengthy second half of the story of the Hare Krishnas.

33
00:04:20,490 --> 00:04:33,642
Chris: You want me to rant? Okay, I'm not gonna rant. I don't really have a rant. I will say, though, that we have a whiteboard going in the discord right now, and it's just pictures of poop and stuff.

34
00:04:33,706 --> 00:04:34,858
Kayla: Well, little drawings.

35
00:04:34,914 --> 00:04:40,710
Chris: Little drawings of poop. Little whiteboard drawings. Yeah. You know, if that doesn't entice you, I don't know what will.

36
00:04:41,250 --> 00:04:48,906
Kayla: Let's get into this. This is welcome back to all of our listeners who were here for part one of the hare Krishna story.

37
00:04:48,938 --> 00:04:54,442
Chris: Okay, let's cut to the chase. Who got murdered? Who got murdered? This is a two week cliffhanger. Let's go.

38
00:04:54,506 --> 00:05:19,948
Kayla: We'll get to that. What we often see in new religious movements or other organized groups that might appear on this show is that the death of the leader spells disaster for the life of the group. I'm pausing myself here because you said, who got murdered? I did not get into this in this episode. But there are people who think that Srila Prabhupda was murdered. I don't think. I think so.

39
00:05:20,004 --> 00:05:21,036
Chris: This is off show.

40
00:05:21,188 --> 00:05:28,452
Kayla: No, we can put it in the show. I don't know. We'll see. How it goes. I don't think. I think that, but just know that there are people who believe that he was poisoned.

41
00:05:28,596 --> 00:05:32,628
Chris: Wow. Okay, so it's, like, unsubstantiated, but rumor type thing?

42
00:05:32,684 --> 00:05:37,182
Kayla: Correct. We're not getting into that. Go look it up yourselves. But when you said, who got murdered?

43
00:05:37,206 --> 00:05:39,966
Chris: Well, maybe Prabhupda.

44
00:05:40,118 --> 00:05:50,830
Kayla: Luckily, Sharila Prabhupda planned for this particular issue of, like, what happens when I am no longer here. He started this when he was rather old. He started this when he was, like, 70 or whatever.

45
00:05:50,950 --> 00:06:02,422
Chris: Can I just say what? Because I'm gonna say this on my next episode, too. It is so important to have a good succession plan. It is so important if anyone has.

46
00:06:02,446 --> 00:06:04,494
Kayla: Watched the show succession, if anybody's.

47
00:06:04,662 --> 00:06:12,482
Chris: The next episode is not about succession. I wish it was, but it's about another situation where you really could have used the succession plan.

48
00:06:12,626 --> 00:06:25,450
Kayla: During the ten years before his death, Prabhupda dedicated a lot of time setting up the organizational management structure of ISKCON so that there was more administrative infrastructure to the leadership besides just him.

49
00:06:25,530 --> 00:06:26,666
Chris: See, that's just smart.

50
00:06:26,778 --> 00:07:02,112
Kayla: In 1970, Prabhupda established the governing body Commission, or GBC, as the managerial authority of ISKCON. The group still around still meets annually to improve the standard of temple management, how to spread the faith, the distribution of literature, and more administrative issues. In that vein, and while the GBC is currently made up of 48 senior ISKCON members, when it was first established, Prabhupda handpicked eleven disciples to serve on the board. Those disciples would become sannyasis and renounce the material world as a way to ensure that ISKCON leaders would not use the group to cultivate personal wealth.

51
00:07:02,266 --> 00:07:11,200
Chris: Right? Yeah. You never want your succession leaders to have it be about them and using their power in ways that is improper and untoward.

52
00:07:11,620 --> 00:07:33,914
Kayla: More on that later. Many of these disciples were also so close to Srilu Prabhupada and so learned in his teachings, they were initiated into the ISKCON guru system that Prabhupda set up, which allowed them to initiate disciples into the ISKCON traditions. So up until this point, it was only like, Prabhupada who could initiate you, and now there was, like, an infrastructure for that.

53
00:07:33,962 --> 00:07:41,978
Chris: Got it. So he recruited people who were then supposed to recruit their own people in a sort of like a line, like.

54
00:07:41,994 --> 00:08:18,770
Kayla: A chain, if you will. Essentially, six months before his death, Srila Prabhupda handpicked eleven successors who would oversee eleven worldwide zones and continue the ISKCon traditions as they were. There is, however, some dispute over these eleven were chosen by the founder to have as much authority as they would later assume, or if their rise to power was closer to a quote unquote bloodless coup. Like, again, that kind of gets into the were they taking advantage of the fact that he was getting older? Was there? And again, there's not enough. I didn't come across enough, like, really firm ground for these theories. But just know those theories are out there.

55
00:08:19,190 --> 00:08:22,342
Chris: It's all, even when you have a plan, there's still Game of Thrones, man.

56
00:08:22,446 --> 00:08:30,798
Kayla: Either way, almost immediately after the disappearance of ISKCoN's leader, eleven men stepped into power, filling the massive vacuum now at the top of the organization.

57
00:08:30,934 --> 00:08:32,140
Chris: All Mendez.

58
00:08:32,590 --> 00:08:39,850
Kayla: We'll get to that. And shortly after. The answer is yes. And shortly after, a wave of crimes followed in their wakes.

59
00:08:40,470 --> 00:08:46,190
Chris: Oh, okay, you know what? I was complimenting him for a succession plan. I feel like I have to walk that back a little bit.

60
00:08:46,270 --> 00:08:49,878
Kayla: When I say crimes, I mean crimes.

61
00:08:50,054 --> 00:08:51,942
Chris: Like, were they robbing liquor stores?

62
00:08:52,086 --> 00:09:29,880
Kayla: Okay. Not only did the g b, c. Members and gurus, eventually many went on to adopt lavish lifestyles, like using the organization as their personal piggy banks. They also broke laws increasingly insidious ways. So crimes that ISKCON and its members have been accused range from. So they've always kind of been accused of kidnapping and brainwashing, because again, back in the seventies, many parents, that's standard stuff. Oh, no. My kid joined a cult, and they're being held. Other crimes are amassing illegal firearms, drug smuggling and selling, racketeering, child abuse and murderous dude and murder.

63
00:09:30,260 --> 00:09:40,120
Chris: These are the. Hold on. So the place went to where it was just like people swaying back and forth and singing, they're gun running and murdering.

64
00:09:40,500 --> 00:10:02,416
Kayla: Okay, we're talking about a very kind, we're talking kind of about a specific period of history. The organization is different these days. I will say that again. It's a big organization. Individuals do individual things, but generally, as rule, we are talking about crimes that were committed seventies to nineties kind of thing.

65
00:10:02,568 --> 00:10:40,044
Chris: Okay, so this is really interesting because I double checked myself. So last episode, I talked about how they made an appearance in Grand Theft Auto. And so in GTA one, yeah, that's where they first made their appearance. GTA two, they brought them back. But then they're like, in GTA two, the Krishna are like a gang that can give you quests and whatnot. And when I was reading that, at first, I was like, oh, that's weird. They made him into a gang. That's crazy. Like, I do gang stuff. But now that you're telling me this, I'm kind of going like, oh, wait, no, that actually kind of does sound like they. You could call them like a. Like a culty gang.

66
00:10:40,172 --> 00:10:46,556
Kayla: I wouldn't call them a gang, but you can boil it down to the, like, unnuanced world of GTA in that way, for sure.

67
00:10:46,668 --> 00:10:47,236
Chris: Yeah, yeah.

68
00:10:47,308 --> 00:11:04,944
Kayla: It's a lot to cover, but luckily we have some help today. We're obviously not the first people to try and document the crimes related to ISKCON members. During my research for this episode, I came across an investigative author named Henry Dokdorsky, who has written twelve books on the history of ISKCON crimes.

69
00:11:04,992 --> 00:11:05,936
Chris: That's a lot of books.

70
00:11:06,008 --> 00:11:11,480
Kayla: And he agreed to sit down with us to help answer some questions about all of this and provide some much needed context.

71
00:11:11,560 --> 00:11:13,336
Chris: I don't even think I've read twelve books.

72
00:11:13,448 --> 00:12:34,550
Kayla: Mister Doktorsky was also a member of ISKCON himself, a student under one of Srila Prabhupdas most trusted disciples, who rose to power after the leader's passing. Kirtananda, Swami Bhaktipada. Let's talk for a minute about Kirtananda to give some context before we get into our conversation. Born as Keith Ham, he met his guru Prabhupda in New York in June 1966. Ham had recently returned from India after fruitlessly searching for a guru there, and was surprised to find the perfect leader right there in his own city. He began attending classes, accepted Prabhupada as his spiritual master, and was initiated into ISKCoN as Kirtananda Dasa. Over the following years, Kirtananda became one of Prabhupdas most beloved disciples. He was one of the first to shave his head and wear robes in the traditional fashion, as well as move into the temple and become a sannyasi.

73
00:12:34,890 --> 00:12:51,464
Kayla: He traveled the world helping Prabhupda establish temples in places like Montreal. And after a brief period in which Kirtan Ananda was banned from preaching in ISKCON temples, and eventually forgiven and welcomed back, Kirtananda approached his teacher with a new idea.

74
00:12:51,552 --> 00:12:52,808
Chris: Wait, why was he banned?

75
00:12:52,984 --> 00:13:13,800
Kayla: Because he tried to. I might get into it later. He tried to syncretize christian esoterica into ISKCON teachings as an interfaith thing. And some followers were like, this is a coup. And Prabhupada was like, you shouldn't do that, and you can't preacher anymore. And then like, he went back and apologized and always forgiven, especially when Kir.

76
00:13:13,840 --> 00:13:20,352
Chris: I thought they were like, they liked that whole, like, oh, every God is actually Krishna.

77
00:13:20,416 --> 00:13:32,700
Kayla: So I don't know the exact flavor of it, but whatever he was doing was not acceptable at the time. And I think it was more a disciple taking on authority of changing the teachings.

78
00:13:33,080 --> 00:13:33,704
Chris: Okay.

79
00:13:33,792 --> 00:13:36,544
Kayla: Against what Prabhupada was teaching, right?

80
00:13:36,592 --> 00:13:37,304
Chris: That's a no.

81
00:13:37,392 --> 00:13:59,168
Kayla: But Girjunnanda was welcomed back and he approached his teacher with a new idea. Nu vrindraban kazoontite. Now, Nuvindraban. What's that? Founded in 1968 after the guidance of Prabhupda and under the direct leadership of Kirtananda and another ISKCON student. So the two of them were kind of leading this new Vrindraben project.

82
00:13:59,304 --> 00:13:59,792
Chris: Okay.

83
00:13:59,856 --> 00:14:26,478
Kayla: Kirtan Ananda proposed the project as basically a big ashram community in West Virginia. So a community by and for ISKCON members to promote, encourage and cultivate the one, cow protection and promoting local agriculture. Two, simple living. Three, holy pilgrimage. Four, spiritual education and five, above all, loving Krishna. So an intentional community based on these.

84
00:14:26,534 --> 00:14:29,766
Chris: Ideals, why West Virginia? It was because of John Denver.

85
00:14:29,958 --> 00:14:52,252
Kayla: It was largely because everybody in ISKCON also worships John Denver. No, there was a, if I remember correctly, there was an ISKCON follower who proposed this idea, kind of like in a letter to the editor in one of the magazines, because they had land in west Virginia. And so Kirito Nanda and others were able to purchase this land very cheaply.

86
00:14:52,366 --> 00:14:54,992
Chris: Damn. That is some powerful letter to the editor there.

87
00:14:55,056 --> 00:15:01,144
Kayla: Yeah. Yeah. Especially because this intentional community is about 1200 acres.

88
00:15:01,312 --> 00:15:01,888
Chris: Whoa.

89
00:15:01,984 --> 00:15:04,328
Kayla: Might have been bigger at one time, but it's currently 1200 acres.

90
00:15:04,384 --> 00:15:06,328
Chris: Wonder how that compares to best friends.

91
00:15:06,464 --> 00:15:41,706
Kayla: Currently has a population of around 352. But we'll get to the. Currently. Let's go back to. Let's go back in time, back to where were. During his life, Prabhupda was hands on with the development and purpose of new Vrindraban. And this was named after the holy city of Vrindavan india, where Prabhupda would eventually die. What started as essentially a rural farm community grew into an ISKCON and hindu destination with homes, apartments, businesses and eventually something that would be called Prabhupdas palace of Gold, which was started in 1972.

92
00:15:41,818 --> 00:15:46,034
Chris: This is like El Dorado cities of Gold. Exactly like that cartoon from the eighties.

93
00:15:46,202 --> 00:15:49,122
Kayla: It was based on that, but it was before it happened.

94
00:15:49,186 --> 00:15:50,514
Chris: That's a deep cut. Sorry.

95
00:15:50,642 --> 00:16:10,898
Kayla: Planned as quarters for the leader. Things obviously changed with his death, and the residents then ballooned into a baroque palace built with marble, gold, and teakwood. Costing $600,000 in materials, with labor donated by ISKCON students, it became a place of pilgrimage and still sees around 50,000 visitors and tourists each year.

96
00:16:10,994 --> 00:16:12,120
Chris: Is it really pretty?

97
00:16:12,290 --> 00:16:13,748
Kayla: Oh, yeah. Do you wanna see some pictures?

98
00:16:13,924 --> 00:16:19,172
Chris: So there's like, there's just this giant hare Krishna temple in the middle of West Virginia.

99
00:16:19,236 --> 00:16:23,160
Kayla: Yeah, that's normal. It's like this.

100
00:16:24,060 --> 00:16:24,956
Chris: Holy shit.

101
00:16:25,028 --> 00:16:26,204
Kayla: Yeah, I wanna go there.

102
00:16:26,292 --> 00:16:28,196
Chris: Yeah, I wanna go there, too. That's large.

103
00:16:28,268 --> 00:16:31,360
Kayla: Yeah, it's large. It's beautiful. It's baroque. It's.

104
00:16:32,180 --> 00:16:41,232
Chris: Wow. I love it. I'm, like, watching. I'm looking at these pictures going, wow. On our audio program, we will post them. We'll post them on Instagram.

105
00:16:41,256 --> 00:16:53,768
Kayla: On our Instagram. The palace was not the only thing that changed after Prabhupdas death. Kirtananda changed, too. Eventually, he established himself as the sole authority of the new Vrindraban community, calling.

106
00:16:53,824 --> 00:16:56,232
Chris: Only authority or the authority over souls.

107
00:16:56,296 --> 00:17:17,180
Kayla: S O l E. He called himself the founder Acharya of the ashram, lifting that singular title from Sreela Prabhupdas own honorific. So Sreela Prabhupada is called the founder Acharya of IskCon, and he's the only one with that title. And then Kirtan Ananda was like, but I'm that of new Vrindraman.

108
00:17:17,480 --> 00:17:20,560
Chris: All right, that's a little power play right there. Nice work.

109
00:17:20,680 --> 00:17:30,224
Kayla: The population grew from a few dozen at its inception to around 500 in the 1980s. But, like, with many schisms, things went south.

110
00:17:30,312 --> 00:17:36,432
Chris: So was this full schism, or was he like, just sort of like a usurper to the existing throne?

111
00:17:36,536 --> 00:17:37,260
Kayla: Yes.

112
00:17:39,400 --> 00:17:40,352
Chris: Which one?

113
00:17:40,496 --> 00:18:01,460
Kayla: All of the above. I'm going to go ahead and I'll let Mister Doktorsky dive a little deeper into this part of the conversation. I will give a trigger warning up front as this conversation continues, we do get into sensitive topics such as sexual assault and child abuse. So take care of.

114
00:18:01,830 --> 00:18:07,494
Chris: If you could just introduce yourself and talk a little bit about your background for our listeners.

115
00:18:07,622 --> 00:18:39,160
Henry Doktorsky: Thanks for inviting me. My name is Henry Doktorsky. I'm a former harsh devotee. I lived for close to 16 years as a resident of the new Vrindavan Hare Krishna farm community in West Virginia. I finished, completed my life's work, actually, just a few months ago, finished the 12th volume of history of the new Vrindavan, West Virginia. Hare Krishna community and a biography of my former future masterpiece.

116
00:18:40,860 --> 00:18:44,160
Kayla: Congratulations on finishing your life's work. That's amazing.

117
00:18:46,100 --> 00:18:47,972
Henry Doktorsky: It was over 20 years.

118
00:18:48,076 --> 00:18:51,204
Chris: How do you know that book? Twelve is the last book.

119
00:18:51,372 --> 00:19:07,754
Henry Doktorsky: Well, I've told the story. I think the story's over. I finished the story about Swami pontiff. Of course, the new verdant community is still there, but someone else is going to have to write any more chapters that may follow.

120
00:19:07,922 --> 00:19:18,122
Kayla: You mentioned that you are no longer a student, so can you share with us what brought you to ISKCon in the first place and then maybe a little bit about why you eventually left?

121
00:19:18,266 --> 00:20:11,082
Henry Doktorsky: Well, in college I was a music student in Parkville, Missouri. And during that, during my time there, I became interested in eastern thought. And my sophomore year I saw a flyer up on the comments somewhere about transcendental meditation. And I paid my $35 mantra fee, and I got my mantra, and I'd meditate twice a day for 20 minutes. And I thought it was a good thing. Sometime later, I went to hear a lecture by Baba Ram Dass, and that's the first time I'd heard of reincarnation. Why? The yogis are vegetarians. And I thought, oh, this is pretty cool, too. And I liked it. I liked it a lot. So I told my piano professor one time, I said, you know, after I graduate, I'm going to go find a spiritual commune somewhere and devote my life to the search for the absolute truth.

122
00:20:11,106 --> 00:21:04,372
Henry Doktorsky: It was just something that was very, very fascinating. And there were, of course, some negative experiences I had which made me doubt my capacity to succeed in life. And then I made a stop at the Maharishi University in Fairfield, Iowa, just to check them out. And I just, it wasn't my kind of thing, because the young men who were there, they were, or white shirts and ties, and I had gone to like twelve years of catholic school, had to wear a white shirt and tie. And so it just wasn't for me. I wanted establishments, the way they looked. And then on the way back to New Jersey, I stopped and wheeling to visit a friend, a high school buddy who had a summer job there. We were sitting in his hot and stuffy apartment with nothing to do.

123
00:21:04,396 --> 00:22:00,098
Henry Doktorsky: He said, let's go visit the Hare Krishna people. It's only 10 miles from here. They're building a palace for their foundry. It's pretty cool. So we got in the car and we drove there. And I really liked what I saw. I saw the community of, I don't know, it could have been 100, 150 people, maybe their motto was kind of living high, thinking they were vegetarians. They did temple services in the morning. They chanted on beads, quietly doing their mantra meditation for about 2 hours in the mornings. And the men, the single men, slept in sleeping bags on the floor of the dash room. And the bathrooms were, you know, other people would be disgusted, but I thought it was pretty cool. The toilets were these holes in the floor, like india, you go, it's just a hole in the floor.

124
00:22:00,154 --> 00:22:19,960
Henry Doktorsky: And they got, you got a water tap behind so you can wash your rear end when you're done. And you're very clean, actually, it's very clean. I thought, oh my God, this is so cool. They're like renouncing the unnecessary pleasures of material life, you know. And I decided to try this Bhakti yoga.

125
00:22:20,500 --> 00:22:27,570
Kayla: And so that's kind of how you started. So what caused you to eventually leave? I think you said maybe 16 years later.

126
00:22:27,740 --> 00:23:25,908
Henry Doktorsky: Well, I mean, a number of factors. Beginning to have doubts about the sanctity of my spiritual master. And in time, I basically understood that one of his pleasures in life was to give fellatio to young men and teenagers, of course. I mean, this is all very covered up, you know, all depends. But. But as time goes on, things often become uncovered and things were getting uncovered. And I even did a little investigation myself and talked to some of the boys that I knew who were now in their twenties, and they told me, oh yeah, baci pad used to, you know, give us palatio, you know, I mean, I was there for my spiritual development, you know, and you're supposed to except the guru who is on the very high platform, you know, that they.

127
00:23:26,004 --> 00:24:11,406
Henry Doktorsky: As far as no illicit sex goes, it's one of the four basic rules that a christian devotee, any Krishna devotee, is expected to follow. No meat eating, no incarnation, no illicit sex, no gambling like that. And much less someone, a great sannyasi, basically visited him at his home and presented him with this very long letter with all my doubts. And then he denied everything. He said, I never haven't had sex since I had met Prabhupada somewhere 26, seven years earlier. And I knew he was lying, so I basically rejected him. And not too many months later, I finally meth.

128
00:24:11,508 --> 00:24:23,290
Kayla: Let's pause here for a second and unpack what Mister Dokdorsky just revealed. So remember how we said that Srila Prabhupdas closest disciples became sannyasis or renunciates?

129
00:24:23,370 --> 00:24:24,034
Chris: Yes.

130
00:24:24,202 --> 00:24:27,750
Kayla: This also includes a vow of celibacy.

131
00:24:28,050 --> 00:24:28,810
Chris: Huh.

132
00:24:28,890 --> 00:24:44,760
Kayla: But apparently not only was kirtan Ananda secretly violating this vow by persuading or coercing or manipulating male followers into sex, and particularly oral sex? He was abusing teenage and even underage boys as part of this transgression.

133
00:24:45,180 --> 00:24:55,244
Chris: Yeah, it's interesting that Mister Joktorsky was saying that he was in catholic school at one point, because I'm just like. There's a lot of parallels here.

134
00:24:55,372 --> 00:24:56,676
Kayla: Throwing pan into the fire.

135
00:24:56,828 --> 00:25:20,090
Chris: Yeah. Not to keep ragging on the catholic thing, but that's very similar, just to be clear. So the. The boys were underage in this scenario that I'm just trying to understand, like, whether it was like, is like, was there an illegal component as well as a transgressive against Krishna component?

136
00:25:20,390 --> 00:26:16,736
Henry Doktorsky: You know, most of. He liked teenage boys, and these boys were. I think most of them were above the age of consent in West Virginia. So I don't think there was any crimes committed. There were younger boys. For us, as investigators, trying to uncover all this stuff, it takes years, decades, actually, sometimes. But I did have one mother tell me that when her seven year old boy, when she visited him, he was living at the new Verde ovens courting school, and she hadn't seen him for months. And then when she finally saw him, the boy told her, very proud and quite pleased. He said, you know, I had a great honor when I first became your. He selected me, out of all the boys, to be his personal servant. And I lived with him in his cabin for a week.

137
00:26:16,888 --> 00:27:13,494
Henry Doktorsky: And he tells his mother, and. And you know what he said? Octopod, like, fondled my genitals. And he was quite proud of it. And the mother told me that she was, like, really, like, shocked. He told me, she said, where did he learn that word, Fondle? He never didn't learn it from me, that's for sure. You know, he learned it somewhere, you know, somewhere else. And. And because of her also deranged devotion to the spiritual master, she dismissed her. Her child's statement as a fanciful invention of a child's mind. And she chastised her son. She said, don't you. Don't you ever say things like that about Swami Kirtananda. He's a great devotee, you know, don't make up stuff like that, or I'll punish you. Which later I discovered that quite frequently the parents, you know, just, they dismiss it and they reject it.

138
00:27:13,662 --> 00:27:32,624
Henry Doktorsky: The boys admission of some sexual abuse from an elder or a family member or grandfather or a priest or a teacher. To answer your question, I think most of the boys were of legal age, but there were some that were underage.

139
00:27:32,792 --> 00:27:48,494
Kayla: That's heartbreaking. And, like, you're talking about, it seems like it's heartbreaking that something like that occurred in this organization. And it's also. Yeah, we've seen that in other organizations, spiritual organizations, and otherwise, it's just a widespread problem.

140
00:27:48,622 --> 00:27:55,950
Chris: Parents taking the side of the spiritual leader seems pretty common. Like, that's definitely a feature in catholic abuse as well.

141
00:27:56,030 --> 00:28:16,360
Kayla: Yeah. So to clarify, the age of consent in West Virginia is 16. Okay, so Kirito Nanda was having legal sexual relationships with teenagers. Like teenagers, as well as. As Mister Jashorski pointed out, as well as illegal sexual relationships with minors.

142
00:28:16,940 --> 00:28:17,580
Chris: Okay.

143
00:28:17,660 --> 00:29:10,814
Kayla: These were all men and boys. And his relationships, obviously, with underage boys were, by definition, abusive. But I also can't help but think that the other sexual relationships with people of age were also abusive. I mean, he is the leader of this community, and he has been like, oh, I'm like, I'm the sole guy. Eventually, he would say that he is the only legitimate spiritual successor to Srila Prabhupda, not just like, oh, I'm the king of Nuvindraban. I'm the only one who's really the spiritual successor here. That puts him in an extremely powerful position. And in ISKCON traditions, devotees, not just the sannyasis, but devotees, are prohibited from engaging in illicit sexual activity and relationships outside of marriage. But if your spiritual master engages with you in a sexual way, what are you supposed to do?

144
00:29:10,942 --> 00:29:33,610
Chris: Yeah, I imagine that there's a lot of, I don't know, brain fuckery going on there where, like, well, this must be okay, because it's the, you know, it's the master that's doing it. So even though XYZ thing is against the rules, they must not be talking about this. I imagine there's a lot of that kind of stuff. I don't know. This sucks.

145
00:29:33,690 --> 00:29:34,630
Kayla: This sucks.

146
00:29:35,490 --> 00:29:50,738
Chris: I kind of am, like, I'm getting to the point, like, when we first started doing the show and something like this came up, it would be like, what? Crazy. Whoa. And then it's like, gotten to the point now where I'm just like, oh, yeah, yeah. That's expected.

147
00:29:50,834 --> 00:29:59,290
Kayla: Now it's crazy if it doesn't come up. Yeah, that's why we did ethereuse, right? Because were like, what's the crazy twist about this group? They don't have abuse, probably.

148
00:29:59,450 --> 00:30:01,146
Chris: They don't have abuse that we know of.

149
00:30:01,218 --> 00:30:04,890
Kayla: They don't have documented cases. It's very depressing.

150
00:30:05,010 --> 00:30:33,502
Chris: Yeah. And like, I, it's almost to the point where, like, I kind of don't, I don't really blame IskCon, you know, like, I think, like, with a lot of these groups, there's, you know, we're like, oh, well, that's, you know, of course that group is going to be, that's the type of thing that's going to lead to child abuse. And there is definitely some stuff there. Like, I think that vow of celibacy is pretty sus, I mean, at least historically it has been with, you know, with Catholics.

151
00:30:33,566 --> 00:30:34,222
Kayla: Right.

152
00:30:34,406 --> 00:31:04,806
Chris: But at this point, like, because it's just such a feature of these, of any organization where there may be a power dynamic and religious ones, that power differential can be pretty significant. It just feels like it's just an environment where this is probably going to happen. Definitely part of me wants to blame ISKCON and be like, well, you shouldn't have made this environment this way. But then part of me is also like, I guess we're just always abusing kids. I don't know.

153
00:31:04,958 --> 00:31:37,506
Kayla: Yeah, I mean, it kind of just goes back to the conversation that we had with Daenery Grace last season of we talk a lot about living in rape culture, living in this kind of culture. And Daenery specifically brought up living in abuse culture, I think, is what we talked about. And it does kind of seem like maybe there is something specific to the way we shape dynamics in our society that, like, abuse runs rampant. Unfortunately, these weren't the only crimes that kirtan, Ananda Nu van Drabin and other disciples were engaged in.

154
00:31:37,578 --> 00:31:39,194
Chris: Yeah. You said gun running. Was that him?

155
00:31:39,282 --> 00:31:40,310
Kayla: We'll get to that.

156
00:31:40,690 --> 00:32:10,360
Henry Doktorsky: Well, I mean, there's a lot there. Yeah, yeah. Fraudulent fundraising for a few years in the early eighties, mid eighties, I was one of the top new v men's collectors. One year I made like $150,000 getting 30,000 people that year to give me $5, including Howard Cosell, who was a famous sportscaster at the time.

157
00:32:10,400 --> 00:32:11,056
Chris: Wow. Yeah.

158
00:32:11,088 --> 00:33:07,740
Henry Doktorsky: Monday Night Football, we had these stickers and they would say, they'd have a picture of Snoopy on it and it would say something like, are we having fun yet? Or something like that. They're little bumper stickers, you know, about four inches, I would say squares. And we hit up, you know, we just approach people and give them a sticker and give them a quick line and ask them for $5. And I used to make 3000 a week doing that. And it's mostly all profit. I mean, we had very spent. We spent very little on ourselves. So Nubrindav and that we did get in trouble with that because were using the Snoopy's image and many other copyrighted images without permission or without paying for the right to copy this, knew that it was illegal, but they were making millions of dollars a year, right.

159
00:33:07,900 --> 00:33:18,850
Henry Doktorsky: Between 1981 and 85. The community gross like twelve to twelve point something million dollars. Another source says it was 17 million.

160
00:33:19,150 --> 00:33:22,610
Chris: That's not for the lawsuit then. So that's, you know, it's fine.

161
00:33:24,230 --> 00:34:19,391
Henry Doktorsky: Well, well, no. Well, most of that money went into construction because we're building a place of pilgrimage. So, you know, lakes were dug and statues, you know, 40 foot tall statues were built and a temple was built and a guest lodge was built in a restaurant behind the palace. So there was an earth moving equipment. And so were like really gung ho to build this transcendental place of pilgrimage where Hindus, in fact, we had tens of thousands of hindu people would come to visit, you know, for their summer vacations when their kids were off. And they. They were cabins they rented. They stayed in the guest lodge and they went to the temple. And it was like a happening place for the north american Hindus. So anyway, so that money, most of it was spent.

162
00:34:19,456 --> 00:34:32,438
Henry Doktorsky: I don't think at that time, in the eighties, that people was, like, stashing it away in private bank accounts. But certainly he was by the time the nineties.

163
00:34:32,938 --> 00:34:45,882
Chris: Okay, so it started off by being put in the right place. It sounds like you were building things for the. For the Krishna community. But then as time went on, more and more of it got siphoned off into his personal right.

164
00:34:45,971 --> 00:35:16,260
Henry Doktorsky: And why that happened was because of all the big court cases. And he was, you know, he was the prime defendant, I think. I mean, he had to spend millions on legal fees. He knew that everybody. He was guilty, you know, the community had done all. But. So he had to hire the most expensive, the greatest lawyers in the United States in order to get off.

165
00:35:17,240 --> 00:35:20,176
Kayla: Okay, pause. Court cases?

166
00:35:20,328 --> 00:35:21,424
Chris: Yeah. What court cases?

167
00:35:21,512 --> 00:35:22,576
Kayla: What court cases?

168
00:35:22,728 --> 00:35:34,556
Chris: First of all, law. Snoopy sticker scam. It was effective, I guess. Yeah. Do you want to start selling some stuff? Let's do mickey Mouse. They're not litigious, right?

169
00:35:34,748 --> 00:35:49,556
Kayla: I know somebody who made an entire comic. They got famous off of using characters they had no copyright over. And it was kind of funny and great. I'm sure we could just put a Mikey mouse and we'll be fine.

170
00:35:49,628 --> 00:35:53,674
Chris: Mikey. Or we could do the. Cause our logo is circular. We could do it in Mickey.

171
00:35:53,812 --> 00:35:54,462
Kayla: Hidden Mickey stuff.

172
00:35:54,486 --> 00:35:55,730
Chris: Hidden Mickey style.

173
00:35:57,070 --> 00:36:12,662
Kayla: Eventually, Kiritan Ananda would be charged with a variety of crimes, some of which we mentioned. So there was, yes, the talk of child abuse, but he was charged with racketeering, fraud, and then even conspiracy to commit murder.

174
00:36:12,806 --> 00:36:14,838
Chris: Oh, here we go. The cool stuff.

175
00:36:14,934 --> 00:36:37,048
Kayla: First, let's talk about the racketeering and fraud. So, over a period of four years, Kiritan Ananda illegally amassed more than $10 million using the infrastructure of ISKCON and its devotees. Like some of the stuff that Henry Doktorsky was talking about, of the way that the students were raising money. And this is supposed to be a renunciate, remember, this is.

176
00:36:37,144 --> 00:36:39,056
Chris: Yeah, you renounce, and then you get your 10 million.

177
00:36:39,128 --> 00:37:11,108
Kayla: Yeah, it's fucked up, but it gets more fucked up again. Kirito Nanda propped himself up as a singular leader of the movement. He had many followers, largely because he was the most devout, the direct disciple of the founder. He had a reputation to uphold, the devoutest. So what happens when followers become disillusioned with their leader? What happens when stories like the ones Mister Doktorsky shared with us, stories of child molestation and abuse? What happens when those start to come out?

178
00:37:11,204 --> 00:37:18,028
Chris: Okay. And just, everyone keep in mind, this is the seventies, so people still had space to become disillusioned.

179
00:37:18,084 --> 00:37:18,564
Kayla: Right.

180
00:37:18,692 --> 00:37:32,076
Chris: Right now it's 2023. I'm like, okay, yeah, of course, there was racketeering and child abuse, but at the time, there was still trust institutions. So I just want to put that context out there.

181
00:37:32,188 --> 00:37:45,080
Kayla: Someone like Kirchhen Ananda and his inner circle needed to maintain power somehow. They needed to squash these stories somehow. And one way to keep things quiet is to kill the whistleblowers.

182
00:37:46,070 --> 00:37:55,646
Chris: That is. That's quite the gambit, because if you kill the whistleblowers, then now you have a murder as well. That. That's.

183
00:37:55,718 --> 00:38:05,334
Kayla: You have to cover that up. Yeah, it's kind of like there was an old woman who swallowed a fly, and she swallowed a cat to catch the fly or whatever, and then she's like, it gets very complicated, and you have to cover up multiple times.

184
00:38:05,382 --> 00:38:07,358
Chris: She has quite a time trying to get herself.

185
00:38:07,374 --> 00:38:27,494
Kayla: I don't know why she swallowed the fly. In 1985, a disillusioned former ISKCON student, Stephen Bryant, wrote a book titled the Guru Business. This book exposed many of the crimes and transgressions we've talked about, specifically calling out Kirtan Ananda, as well as Ramaswara, Maharaja of the Los Angeles temple that you and I visited.

186
00:38:27,542 --> 00:38:28,902
Chris: Oh, snap.

187
00:38:29,086 --> 00:38:34,694
Kayla: The book was shockingly not well received by many in the ISKCON community.

188
00:38:34,782 --> 00:38:35,750
Chris: Don't say.

189
00:38:35,910 --> 00:38:40,008
Kayla: Particularly by those who followed Kirjan, Ananda and Ramasvara.

190
00:38:40,094 --> 00:38:40,812
Chris: Okay.

191
00:38:40,956 --> 00:38:53,804
Kayla: Steven Bryant traveled the country trying to get the word out about his book, about the corruption within the organization. But wherever he went, he was stalked by ISKCON followers under the orders of their gurus.

192
00:38:53,892 --> 00:38:54,892
Chris: What the fuck?

193
00:38:54,956 --> 00:39:09,248
Kayla: So he was stalked from West Virginia to Ohio to Michigan to California. He was living out of a van cult one night in 1986, while parked less than a mile from the Los Angeles ISKCOn temple.

194
00:39:09,304 --> 00:39:10,144
Chris: The one were at.

195
00:39:10,192 --> 00:39:10,840
Kayla: The one were at.

196
00:39:10,880 --> 00:39:12,840
Chris: The one we drive by all the time to get in and out.

197
00:39:12,880 --> 00:39:14,640
Kayla: One we live less than five minutes from.

198
00:39:14,720 --> 00:39:17,456
Chris: Okay. Don't know.

199
00:39:17,568 --> 00:39:21,380
Kayla: Stephen Bryant was shot twice in the head in his van window.

200
00:39:21,800 --> 00:39:22,952
Chris: Like, down the street.

201
00:39:23,016 --> 00:39:23,900
Kayla: Down the street.

202
00:39:24,200 --> 00:39:26,472
Chris: Somebody was assassinated down the street from us.

203
00:39:26,496 --> 00:39:27,220
Kayla: That's awful.

204
00:39:28,160 --> 00:39:39,130
Chris: Yo, that's messed up. And also, now I have a whole different appreciation for Mister Doktorsky, because now I'm like, he wasn't just writing books, he was putting his life on the line, I guess.

205
00:39:39,250 --> 00:39:39,858
Kayla: Yeah.

206
00:39:39,994 --> 00:39:40,786
Chris: Holy shit.

207
00:39:40,818 --> 00:39:51,746
Kayla: Definitely. Steven Bryant was murdered by a man named Thomas Drescher, a lifelong follower of Iskcon, specifically Kirito Nananda. And he was known in the organization as an enforcer.

208
00:39:51,938 --> 00:40:01,110
Chris: Oh, my God. They just. They literally had hired murderer. This is the mafia. What the he. Okay. Of course they belong in grand theft auto.

209
00:40:01,780 --> 00:40:36,638
Kayla: Steven Bryant wasn't the first. Three years earlier, another ISKCON student, Charles St. Denis, was also murdered by Thomas Drescher, allegedly with the approval of Kirtan Ananda. Charles St. Denis had been having an affair with another member's wife. I think some testimonials say that he had raped another member's wife. I'm not sure which story is he was most closely the truth. Neither thing is good, right? Drescher would later characterize the killing as dispatching an undesirable element from the community.

210
00:40:36,814 --> 00:40:42,150
Chris: Dude, this guy sounds fucking ice cold. Motherfucker. This guy sounds scary.

211
00:40:42,310 --> 00:40:47,190
Kayla: Kiritan Ananda was charged with conspiracy to commit murder in relation to these killings.

212
00:40:47,350 --> 00:40:56,366
Chris: Yeah, see, that's what I'm talking about. You're gonna silence somebody, but now you have two murders to come. You got two murders, and there's no volcanoes to throw people in Los Angeles.

213
00:40:56,398 --> 00:40:58,370
Kayla: It's the only way to really get rid of a body.

214
00:40:58,870 --> 00:42:11,830
Henry Doktorsky: Now, he was not guilty at all conscious, but there was a significant amount of guilt. And there have been cases against Luther Daven. Since at least since 1973. It was a primitive community back then. That was before the palace of gold was built, you know, but some of the neighbors sued Luberdun for a half a million dollars. But then after the murder of Steve Bryant, known as Sulocho, he was. He was assassinated by a disciple of Vaktipali. And the federal government became very interested in New Vrindavan because they tied that murder to Nuvrindavan. There were two murders, actually, one in 83 and one in 86. So Bhagipad was charged with ordering his disciple to do this murder. He was involved some way, and of course he knew this was going to happen. I'm not convinced he ordered those murders. But. So there's two murders.

215
00:42:11,950 --> 00:43:08,026
Henry Doktorsky: Curiously enough, he was never charged with child abuse. I think that's partly because most of those boys, and I've talked to several of them, you know, once, you know, I mean, they tolerate this for some time, perhaps years, and then. And then at some point it stops. And they. Maybe they realize that this is not right in the beginning. They don't know, you know, this is. Maybe this is the way all kids grow up. You know, they don't want it known that they were sexually abused when they were young. It's like a stigma to them. Very embarrassing, you know, so. So they would rather not get involved with filing charges and doing court cases because that's going to take up a hell of a lot of their life energy just fighting this thing.

216
00:43:08,058 --> 00:43:27,014
Henry Doktorsky: And there's no guarantee that they're going to win or anything, you know, so anyway. But that's just a state of our current society and how hard it is for victims and for women who get raped also. Same thing, you know, same thing. It's hard to. Hard to get justice.

217
00:43:27,142 --> 00:43:42,494
Kayla: You have a trauma happen to you and then you have to weigh, do I want to have to relive this trauma in court and in the court of public opinion? And do I have to, do I want to face this person or do I want to put that behind me.

218
00:43:42,502 --> 00:43:43,278
Kayla: And not think about it?

219
00:43:43,294 --> 00:43:48,238
Kayla: Like, I understand people who don't choose to pursue or file charges.

220
00:43:48,294 --> 00:43:53,930
Chris: Like you're saying, yeah, I feel like I would probably not choose. I mean, that totally makes sense.

221
00:43:54,790 --> 00:44:39,458
Kayla: So there were no child abuse charges in these charges that were filed. And interestingly enough, even though Kirtan Ananda was initially convicted on nine of the eleven charges in 1991, those convictions were thrown out. What the court of appeals was convinced by Kirito Nanda's attorney, who argued that the allegations of child molestation unfairly prejudiced the jury against his client, who was not charged with child molestation crimes. So the attorney was saying he didn't get a fair shake because the jury is influenced by all these stories swirling that he molested children. So let's throw that shit out. Do you want to guess who his attorney was?

222
00:44:39,594 --> 00:44:43,458
Chris: Oh, my God. When did this happen? When was the trial?

223
00:44:45,330 --> 00:44:48,506
Kayla: Johnny Cochran, Alan Dershowitz.

224
00:44:48,618 --> 00:45:06,464
Chris: Oh, Alan Dershowitz. He's made a whole career of defending absolute shitheads. Look, I do want to say it is important in our legal system that even the worst people do deserve a spirited defense.

225
00:45:06,592 --> 00:45:07,016
Kayla: Absolutely.

226
00:45:07,048 --> 00:45:23,420
Chris: That is part of that is part of how our legal system is set up, and it's a flawed system, but I don't think that's one of the flaws. That being said, alan Dershowitz is a lawyer who defends real shitheads.

227
00:45:26,560 --> 00:45:32,968
Kayla: Unfortunately, after this, Kirtan Ananda was released from house arrest in 1993, and he returned to new Vrindraban.

228
00:45:33,104 --> 00:45:44,152
Chris: Also, that makes me kind of go like, oh, yeah, so he did it. If it's like, alan Dershowitz is your lawyer? I'm like, okay, definitely these were accurate charges then. I'm just saying.

229
00:45:44,176 --> 00:45:45,040
Kayla: I don't disagree with you.

230
00:45:45,080 --> 00:45:45,940
Chris: I'm just saying.

231
00:45:46,480 --> 00:45:52,504
Kayla: Kirtananda wasn't the only Srila Prabhupada disciple abusing his power and status in order to do crimes.

232
00:45:52,552 --> 00:45:53,208
Chris: Oh, no.

233
00:45:53,304 --> 00:46:02,872
Kayla: Hansa Dutta Swami was arrested in 1980 for the possession of illegal weapons. So this guy, like, a masked. A bunch of weapons that I think he got super paranoid and did the weapons running.

234
00:46:02,896 --> 00:46:05,680
Chris: That's cool though, right? At least you're not abusing kids.

235
00:46:05,760 --> 00:46:06,360
Kayla: Sure.

236
00:46:06,520 --> 00:46:14,336
Chris: You're like, oh, cool, I just got a bunch of fucking weapons because, I don't know, like, the Rajnishis, they were fucking.

237
00:46:14,368 --> 00:46:15,504
Kayla: They were not great.

238
00:46:15,592 --> 00:46:18,088
Chris: They were badass, though. They had those automatic rifles.

239
00:46:18,144 --> 00:46:19,824
Kayla: They were blending beavers and putting.

240
00:46:19,872 --> 00:46:21,940
Chris: Yeah, you shouldn't blend beavers, for sure.

241
00:46:22,320 --> 00:46:44,190
Kayla: In 1979, Alexander Kulik, a California ISKCON leader, was accused of smuggling heroin, laundering drug money, and having mafia ties. Like, there was kind of a thing where, like, ex mafia members were like, maybe by the government put into, like, witness protection or something in the Hare Krishna community and then, like, doing mafia stuff. I'm a little unclear.

242
00:46:44,310 --> 00:46:46,198
Chris: This whole GTA thing makes so much sense.

243
00:46:46,254 --> 00:46:51,414
Kayla: I'm a little unclear on that, so don't do your own research. But there was, like, mafia stuff going on.

244
00:46:51,542 --> 00:46:54,490
Chris: See, again, this GTA stuff just makes so much more sense now.

245
00:46:54,590 --> 00:46:59,002
Kayla: The time period following Prabhupada's death was fraught for the organization.

246
00:46:59,106 --> 00:47:04,858
Chris: Sounds like. So you mentioned. That's three people. You mentioned. You said he had eleven disciples.

247
00:47:04,914 --> 00:47:05,550
Kayla: Yeah.

248
00:47:05,930 --> 00:47:10,450
Chris: So were the other eight okay, or did they also have, like.

249
00:47:10,570 --> 00:47:21,962
Kayla: I will say that Henry Doktorsky wrote multiple books. I mean, he wrote twelve total books, but he did write multiple books specifically about these guys.

250
00:47:22,106 --> 00:47:26,506
Chris: That's enough books to cover one for one and then still have a whole book left over.

251
00:47:26,578 --> 00:47:38,818
Kayla: I recommend going and checking out. Obviously, we'll include a link to Henry Doktorsky's website, as well as his Amazon storefront, so that you can buy some of these books and read up on the craziness behind what we're talking about.

252
00:47:38,914 --> 00:47:40,670
Chris: Maybe that 12th book is a cookbook.

253
00:47:41,370 --> 00:47:49,984
Kayla: It turns out that these issues weren't simply a function of the loss of ISKcON's leader.

254
00:47:50,152 --> 00:48:00,740
Chris: Yeah, I'm sorry. It's never like, oh, the great leader died, and then everything. He was great, and then everything else sucked. It's not ever that.

255
00:48:02,160 --> 00:48:09,800
Kayla: I mean, the power vacuum, the eleven disciples abusing their new status, this shifting in the organization. Yes. Trouble, I'm sure.

256
00:48:09,920 --> 00:48:18,764
Chris: Yeah. That exacerbated it for sure. But if you asked me, okay, but do you think that it was pristine and perfect before that? I'd be like, no, there was trouble.

257
00:48:18,812 --> 00:48:21,556
Kayla: Just under the surface before Prabhupada disappeared.

258
00:48:21,628 --> 00:48:22,564
Chris: Not surprising.

259
00:48:22,732 --> 00:48:52,460
Kayla: It is interesting that you say that child abuse charges filed against Kiritananda, but I have been reading about how there have been accusations of systemic child abuse in the organization, maybe more recently in places like the boarding schools and educational programs. Is that something that you know about? Is that something. Can you talk a little bit about that particular transgression in the organization?

260
00:48:52,840 --> 00:49:58,620
Henry Doktorsky: In the seventies, Swami Prabhupda, he started the gurukula system, the boarding school system. 1971, that was Dallas, Texas. And he pretty much insisted all his disciples got to send their children there starting at the age of four. And they'll become great lovers of God and strict devotees. And they will, you know, from there, they'll conquer the world. But unfortunately, the boarding schools were underfunded. There really wasn't any prestige in being involved as a teacher or an administrator or an ashram moderator. Someone who watched, stayed with the kids at night in their ashrams. The prestigious positions went to people who could collect a lot of money. But the gurukuls were underfunded, and there wasn't much interest nationally or internationally.

261
00:49:58,760 --> 00:51:07,670
Henry Doktorsky: They had already teachers and ashram moderators who were pedophiles and they found a good place for them to abuse children because the children really couldn't say anything. So anyway, that Dallas guru pool eventually folded five years later when the government of Texas started investigating it, and they found all these violations. And then Prabhupda basically said, okay, we'll just close it and move all the kids to India. Vrindavan, India, the most holy place in the universe, where Krishna's love of Krishna automatically reveals, these children will have the greatest time of their lives. We start a boarding school in Vrindavan, India. Unfortunately, it turned out to be even worse. Anyway, it was, like, pretty sad. Mismanaged a haven for pedophiles. A haven.

262
00:51:08,090 --> 00:51:10,750
Kayla: Were these issues largely.

263
00:51:11,250 --> 00:51:12,882
Kayla: I mean, we've talked about a lot of issues at this point.

264
00:51:12,906 --> 00:51:44,940
Kayla: We've talked about now the systemic child abuse. We've talked about Kirtan Ananda. Were the issues that we're talking about. Was this mostly while Prabhupda was alive, or did this kind of. It seems, you know, from a. From a layperson's perspective, it seems like maybe more of the issues happened after he died and other folks stepped up to fill that power void. But I'm wondering if that perception is wrong, because you're saying that these boarding schools were established under Prabhupdas, like, while he was still around. So do you have any insight on that?

265
00:51:45,360 --> 00:52:52,580
Henry Doktorsky: Well, they certainly got worse after he passed away in 1977. But there was certainly a lot of abuse in Dallas, Texas, school and the Bhaktivedanta Gurukula in Vrindavan, India, during his lifetime. And you read this book, a bond of love with RLa Prabhupda and his daughters. And it's testimonies from women who served in ISKCON, and basically, they're glorifying their spiritual master and saying wonderful things about him. But there's one woman who tells a story that at the time she was living, I think it was in Dublin, and her son, I think he was seven, came to visit her from the Dallas, Texas. And the boy starts telling her about some of the physical abuses that the kids were getting there. Like, if the child wet is bad, they had to wear their urine, soak underwear on their head for the rest of the day.

266
00:52:53,560 --> 00:53:53,858
Henry Doktorsky: Some kids, they wet their beds so much that they weren't even allowed to sleep in beds anymore. They had to sleep in the bathtub and beatings. Now, Prabhupada said, you can slap a child on the face. So eventually it got so that there'd be a line of kids, the ashram teacher would go, slap, slap. You know, just like abuse, you know, in order to discipline them if they were unruly. This lady, her son's telling her about some of the abuse, and she had been told that these Krishna boarding schools would be a heavenly place for their child to grow up and learn about Krishna and be saved from all sorts of dangerous association, like. So she gets on a train to see Swami Prabhupda, who is currently in Bombay, which is at least, it's got to be close to 20 hours ride.

267
00:53:53,914 --> 00:54:50,158
Henry Doktorsky: She gets to Bombay, she goes to the Juhu temple there, and Prabhupada is in a meeting with Bigwig sannyasis and wealthy men. She just barges in. She's so upset, she has to tell them about the children's abuse at this Texas school. And Prabhupada sees this, and of course, in ISKCON, women, as a rule, are not respected. One of the sannyasis sitting next close to Prabhupda, when this woman comes in and she's very distraught, she says, oh, she's just a sentimental woman, Prabhupda. We can't really trust her. No, I want to hear what she has to say. So he dismisses everybody else, and she tells him what her son was telling him. And according to her, she says, Prabhupada was, like, intently listening the whole time.

268
00:54:50,214 --> 00:55:45,410
Henry Doktorsky: And when heard about this, he started roaring like a lion and said, those teachers should be dismissed, and before they're dismissed, they should be hanged. So she felt that Prabhupada was going to do something about this, and she got back on the train back to Vrindavan, where she was living. However, nothing happened. I don't know what happened, but I don't know. I know nothing happened. All right, so I'm assuming that Prabhupada spoke to one of his important Sannyasi advisors and said, I want you to go to Texas and investigate this. And apparently, Sannyasi had other, more important business to do, so he never did it. And Prabhupda never followed up either. So the abuse just kept going. In fact, this poor kid, when he went back, maybe he got it worse now, you know, because he was a snitch.

269
00:55:45,830 --> 00:56:00,650
Henry Doktorsky: So, yeah, of course, it was really bad after Pratha passed away. But, you know, he had. He was building temples india, three important, big temples. That was his life's work. And the guru gul, he just. It just gets forgotten about.

270
00:56:00,990 --> 00:56:07,862
Kayla: So, unfortunately, the issues that arose after Prabhupada's death. Already had a foundation from when he was alive.

271
00:56:07,966 --> 00:56:12,910
Chris: Yeah. All that stuff makes me kind of go like, all right, yeah. I mean, what did you expect was gonna happen, right?

272
00:56:12,950 --> 00:56:21,204
Kayla: Like, you found the boarding school system in the states, there's like, horrible, widespread abuse, and then you just close it and move it somewhere else.

273
00:56:21,372 --> 00:56:26,932
Chris: Yeah. I mean, you've demonstrated that there will be no consequences. So there you go. That's. Yeah.

274
00:56:26,996 --> 00:56:34,844
Kayla: When the conditions and the abuse are worse and it is brought directly to your attention and you still fail to act.

275
00:56:34,972 --> 00:56:35,892
Chris: Yeah, that's the thing.

276
00:56:35,916 --> 00:56:36,772
Kayla: What does that say about you?

277
00:56:36,796 --> 00:56:40,360
Chris: What that does is it enables everyone after you, which is what happened.

278
00:56:40,980 --> 00:57:32,450
Kayla: And as Mister Doktorsky mentioned, there were some less savory beliefs present in ISKCON during Prabhupdas life. So the thing about women, as a rule, were not respected in ISKCON. And unfortunately, Prabhupda himself also harbored some less savory beliefs. I didnt really put this in my script, but I do want to clarify. Im presenting the less savory beliefs, and theyre abhorrent. And also, these are alongside, this is a full human being. This is alongside other beliefs that are savory. So I don't want to present this as like, this is all that he believed. Clearly, he had a whole religion around, like Shizcon stuff. Here's a short list. Prabhupda made statements that women should not be trusted, as a rule, were not intelligent, were reliant and dependent on men. And he just generally had a negative politic towards women.

279
00:57:32,530 --> 00:57:34,282
Chris: Oh, man, he could be president of Harvard.

280
00:57:34,426 --> 00:57:42,128
Kayla: No, because it's worth noting that he generally is recalled as, like, being kind and welcoming two female disciples in practice.

281
00:57:42,224 --> 00:57:43,520
Chris: Never mind that you can't be president.

282
00:57:43,560 --> 00:57:52,940
Kayla: Of Harvard, but women were not allowed in leadership. Under his watch. He made statements supporting the enslavement of black people in America.

283
00:57:54,840 --> 00:57:55,568
Chris: Okay.

284
00:57:55,664 --> 00:57:56,500
Kayla: As well.

285
00:57:56,800 --> 00:57:59,600
Chris: That's like a gimme. How do you miss that one?

286
00:57:59,720 --> 00:58:08,720
Kayla: He also made statements supporting the caste system and oppression of lower castes india. He made statements blaming the jewish people for the Holocaust and for Hitler's violence.

287
00:58:10,060 --> 00:58:16,324
Chris: Okay, these are significant. Like, these aren't, like, he thinks that women should make sandwiches.

288
00:58:16,452 --> 00:58:28,748
Kayla: This is not good. These are not things that the religion was, like, revolved around. These seem to be more personal beliefs, but it's like, these things should be talked about because these are, like you said, these are significant feelings to harbor.

289
00:58:28,844 --> 00:58:37,312
Chris: Yeah. And like, I don't know. He did start it. So there's got to be. His DNA is in there.

290
00:58:37,376 --> 00:58:55,400
Kayla: It's important to know that these things exist so that when you do look at the texts, you are armed with the knowledge of, like, there might be less than, say, there might be really bad stuff in here that I need to push back against and not just take into my body of knowledge. He disputed theory of evolution on religious grounds. Not that bad.

291
00:58:55,400 --> 00:59:00,912
Chris: It's funny because normally I would have been like, oh, what an idiot. But, like, after the other stuff, he said, I'm like, oh, okay, that's fine.

292
00:59:00,976 --> 00:59:06,928
Kayla: I mean, it was just like, he believed in the vedic theory of, like, how people came to be.

293
00:59:06,984 --> 00:59:07,464
Chris: Right.

294
00:59:07,592 --> 00:59:09,260
Kayla: He didn't believe in the moon landing.

295
00:59:09,760 --> 00:59:20,944
Chris: Okay. Yeah. You know, this is what's called crank magnetism. When you're a Holocaust denier, you're probably also a moon landing denier. You're probably also anti vax. You're probably also blah, blah, blah.

296
00:59:21,032 --> 00:59:22,140
Kayla: Thoughts, feelings.

297
00:59:22,440 --> 00:59:23,856
Chris: Well, I have a question for you.

298
00:59:23,928 --> 00:59:26,060
Kayla: I probably don't have answer for you.

299
00:59:26,520 --> 00:59:28,140
Chris: Do you still want to join?

300
00:59:28,760 --> 00:59:30,376
Kayla: Well, he's not the leader anymore.

301
00:59:30,528 --> 01:00:01,276
Chris: I know, but, like, I don't know. I just. I remember last episode, we played the Kiritan, and it was so nice. And then we came back to, you know, to studio, and you were like, oh, man, I just want to join. And we talked about how you're a joiner a little bit. And now after talking about this stuff today, I'm like, I don't know. I wouldn't. Like. I know it's. I know it's different now, and I don't want to, like, sit here and say, like, iSKCON still has people committing heinous crimes and denying the holocaust, but I just have a bad taste in my mouth.

302
01:00:01,388 --> 01:00:21,302
Kayla: I know, but it becomes interesting when you think about this, how many years from now until that gets become. So, when does that become acceptable? And I'm not saying it should become acceptable. I'm just saying, historically, the founders of major world religions have just as brutal things to say.

303
01:00:21,406 --> 01:00:46,302
Chris: Right. That's true. Yeah. I mean, I don't care for most of those, either. Like, you know, like, that's part of it. Like, that's part of why I have in my life moved away from religion, and that's part of why I am, like, disillusioned with things. That was, like, the whole Ayn Rand episodes were about how, like, okay, I moved away from religion, right? And now I like this person. And, oops, she said that we totally should have persecuted Native Americans. Whoopsie daisy.

304
01:00:46,366 --> 01:00:49,912
Kayla: I think this is why I would never join, like, actually join something.

305
01:00:50,056 --> 01:00:50,408
Chris: Yeah.

306
01:00:50,464 --> 01:01:08,512
Kayla: I think this is why I have an aversion to, even if I, like, want to go back to the Hare Krishna temple and do the kirtan, I'm never going to become a Hare Krishna. I'm never going to become initiated into the thing. I'm never going to convert to Catholicism. I'm never going to start paying dues to the Ayn Rand Institute. Like, you know what I mean?

307
01:01:08,616 --> 01:01:14,500
Chris: They don't have dues, Kayla. I've never been online classes that are 11 hours.

308
01:01:14,880 --> 01:01:24,872
Kayla: It's interesting to be a joiner that doesn't actually want to join because I don't want to be associated with the bad parts. I really don't.

309
01:01:24,936 --> 01:01:55,402
Chris: I also think it's just the power corrupts thing, too. When we talk about founders, we are talking about powerful people, and when we're talking about powerful people, we are talking about tendencies towards sociopathy. Caveat. I know that's not in the DSM, but, like, were talking about people who tend towards things that are generally. It's just a different type of person that is drawn towards that amassing of power.

310
01:01:55,506 --> 01:02:13,308
Kayla: Right. I mean, this sucks. This is also why I'm moving away from affiliating myself with any sort of political party or political organization, because it's the same. It's the organized structure. We cannot seem to build organized structures that don't result in this. And I don't want to have a.

311
01:02:13,324 --> 01:02:31,060
Chris: Hand in this, but at the same time, I think it's also, like, there's no. I mean, there's no escape. Right? Like, it's not. It's not like, oh, I need to not do this. It's just society has these people, no matter what. Like, it's. There's value in joining with other humans to do things right.

312
01:02:31,100 --> 01:02:34,748
Kayla: Like, coalition is different than, like, joining.

313
01:02:34,924 --> 01:03:16,740
Chris: But, like, a lot of joint work, a lot of collective effort is guided from the top down. That's the way it is. That's the way it's been for a long time. It's not always like that, but there's a tendency for that. I think that sometimes we just have to accept that. Yeah, I worked at Blizzard and we made some great games. And also there were. There were people that were abusive there. You know, like, it's just. And I kind of think maybe the same thing was like, what's this? Like, there's value that people get. Clearly, there's value. I was there and witnessed it. There's value that people get from is con, right?

314
01:03:17,160 --> 01:03:46,178
Chris: And, like, I know it's shitty for me to say maybe, but, like, at a certain point, you kind of have to just go, like, oh, yeah, the leaders were fucked up, right? Yeah. That doesn't mean that there's no value in this organization. That doesn't mean that I'm not getting value from doing this Kiritan, or being in community with these folks. But leadership is just. I don't know. I kind of feel like we're just going back to the real basics of absolute power corrupts.

315
01:03:46,234 --> 01:04:18,708
Kayla: I just think it's a good lesson that you cannot. It doesn't matter who the person is. The structure of organized, hierarchical groups requires that you do not place all of your trust in the leader. It doesn't matter who it is. Doesn't matter if it's. If it's a saint. The way that these power structures end up playing out requires us to be vigilant and to have transparency when it comes to our leaders.

316
01:04:18,804 --> 01:04:54,228
Chris: Yeah. And at least with, like, corporations, at least there's, like, a Yde. An attempt at accountability. Whereas with these spiritual organizations that we cover on the show, who are they accountable to? Blizzard has accountability to its shareholders, to its parent company, to its employees. There's a lot to the state of California, and that's why you eventually have these house cleanings that happen, which sucks that they have to happen, but at least they happen. It seems harder with these spiritual organizations because it seems like there's less accountability. There's like, he is the infallible spiritual master, right?

317
01:04:54,284 --> 01:04:55,948
Kayla: Yeah, I remember. He's descended from Krishna.

318
01:04:56,044 --> 01:05:18,780
Chris: Right? I totally appreciate what Mister Doktorsky was saying about, you know, victims. That makes it so hard to come forward as a victim, because you're not just saying, like, this gross stranger touched me in an inappropriate way. You're saying this respected member of the community in this, like, spiritually infallible position. Like, so fucked, right?

319
01:05:19,480 --> 01:05:32,672
Kayla: So that kind of brings us to the end of our summary of the crimes and transgressions of ISKCON under Prabhupda and then immediately after his death. But how did ISkcon react to these issues at the time? And how have they moved forward since.

320
01:05:32,816 --> 01:05:35,860
Chris: They went to the airport and started doing chants?

321
01:05:36,560 --> 01:05:37,816
Kayla: Well, no, they were already doing that.

322
01:05:37,888 --> 01:05:46,974
Chris: Oh, they were. Oh, they were doing. Okay. So wait, so while these guys were in the airport doing chants off to the side, there was a guy, like, murdering and gun running?

323
01:05:47,102 --> 01:05:47,718
Kayla: Yeah.

324
01:05:47,854 --> 01:05:50,198
Chris: That's so fucking wild, man.

325
01:05:50,374 --> 01:06:19,350
Kayla: Let's start with the systemic child abuse. In 1997, after years of stories swirling about the abuse in boarding schools, the ISKCON GBC, the governing body, established the ISKCON Central Office of Child Protection Department. This department established guidelines for care of children and the running of boarding schools, as well as provided training to child care providers within the system. The department also established local child protection teams and conducts investigations into claims of abuse in poor conditions.

326
01:06:19,730 --> 01:06:22,858
Chris: Like, it's good to have that, but.

327
01:06:22,874 --> 01:06:24,434
Kayla: It'S fucked up that it's sucks to need it.

328
01:06:24,482 --> 01:06:25,150
Chris: Yeah.

329
01:06:26,170 --> 01:07:14,454
Kayla: In 1998, ISKCON and the department published an expose on its own systemic abuse, particularly focusing on the 1970s and eighties in both the US and India. This was a direct admission of physical, emotional, and sexual abuse as a widespread issue in their schools. The report revealed that the ISKCON followers charged with running these schools and caring for the children were not trained for the task, and many didn't even want to do it. Like, they were resentful of these responsibilities. The expose included testimony from former pupils who shared these stories of beatings, sexual assault, rape, and the denial of medical care. So they themselves published this story or this expose owning up to the wrongdoings. I don't know if it's enough to be like, sorry, but they admitted these claims.

330
01:07:14,622 --> 01:07:24,846
Chris: Yeah, this is a tough one. It's too much to go into on the podcast. But at a certain point, I'm like, I don't know. You can't just be like, whoops, maybe.

331
01:07:24,878 --> 01:07:26,410
Kayla: Just shut the whole thing down. Exactly.

332
01:07:26,870 --> 01:07:30,658
Chris: Is a certain point it's like, oh, you shouldn't be doing this. Don't do this anymore.

333
01:07:30,714 --> 01:07:31,310
Kayla: Right?

334
01:07:31,610 --> 01:07:32,138
Chris: Stop.

335
01:07:32,234 --> 01:07:41,310
Kayla: Right? Yes. And would it or would it not mean something if the catholic church did something like this?

336
01:07:42,530 --> 01:07:53,586
Chris: It would mean. It would mean something. But I would say the same thing. I would be like, you shouldn't even be at the point where you need to have, like, you know, your own little inquisition.

337
01:07:53,698 --> 01:07:56,036
Kayla: Also, like, I mean, we're just the admissions.

338
01:07:56,188 --> 01:08:22,939
Chris: That's what I mean. Like, yeah, okay, there's the admissions, and then there's also the, like, internal inquisition. But, like, yeah, I don't know. The admissions would be nice, but, like, the chur, the catholic church is old enough and powerful enough and wealthy enough that, like, I don't even know if I would trust the internal commission. No, you know, like, I don't trust the citizens. Yeah, I don't know. That's. Yeah, it's kind of getting internal affairs. Yeah, yeah.

339
01:08:22,979 --> 01:08:24,640
Kayla: Oh, we investigated ourselves.

340
01:08:25,220 --> 01:08:29,600
Chris: Turns out everything's cool now. Turns out all this stuff was just in the seventies and eighties, right?

341
01:08:30,660 --> 01:09:06,522
Kayla: We don't include this in our snippets of interview, but Mister Jaitorsky did share that while largely these issues are in the past, and his work has focused largely on the past. So he's not an authority on the present, but more authority on the past. He has heard stories from various temples that there are still issues. So take that with a grain of salt. In 2002, ISKCON abuse victims filed a $900 million lawsuit in Texas state court. The eventual settlement in 2008 was 15 million, and ISKCON would have to file for chapter eleven as a result.

342
01:09:06,666 --> 01:09:08,350
Chris: Okay, so here's another rant.

343
01:09:08,649 --> 01:09:10,229
Kayla: What the fuck is chapter eleven?

344
01:09:11,130 --> 01:09:23,404
Chris: No, that's a different rant. Everybody talks about blood sucking lawyers. They are the only fucking things that are, like, doing anything I like. I'm sorry, but why did we hit.

345
01:09:23,437 --> 01:09:24,477
Kayla: Lawyers in the nineties?

346
01:09:24,613 --> 01:09:26,037
Chris: We still hate lawyers.

347
01:09:26,093 --> 01:09:27,045
Kayla: Not the way we did.

348
01:09:27,197 --> 01:09:43,138
Chris: Like, if we're like, oh, blood sucking lawyers. And like, if we didn't have blood lawyers, then there would be zero consumer protections and nobody would do anything for these fucking kids. Yeah, I know. That's why the powers like them. I know, I know.

349
01:09:43,314 --> 01:09:45,270
Kayla: What about Kirch Nananda?

350
01:09:45,810 --> 01:09:47,546
Chris: Yeah. What the hell happened to that jackass?

351
01:09:47,658 --> 01:09:53,402
Kayla: After his release in 1993, Kirtan Ananda, when he was absolved of his crimes, or at least his convictions, were thrown.

352
01:09:53,426 --> 01:09:55,442
Chris: Out, did he do another cult? They usually do other cults.

353
01:09:55,506 --> 01:10:03,070
Kayla: Well, he just returned back to his community. The community did not divest from him.

354
01:10:03,890 --> 01:10:07,994
Chris: Really? Oh, that seems pretty stupid.

355
01:10:08,042 --> 01:10:15,770
Kayla: And again, he was not formally charged with child abuse. So for the community, it was stories. I'm not excusing it, but I'm saying that, like.

356
01:10:16,310 --> 01:10:22,766
Chris: Yeah, but, like, maybe, like, I'm not a witch hunt guy, but, like, maybe, just maybe, we need to just.

357
01:10:22,798 --> 01:10:24,574
Kayla: Well, let me finish this story.

358
01:10:24,742 --> 01:10:25,610
Chris: Okay?

359
01:10:26,150 --> 01:10:38,730
Kayla: It gets better and it gets worse. Okay, it gets worse and it gets better. I don't know. In 1993, after his release, Kiritan Ananda was discovered by followers in the back of a van with a teenage boy.

360
01:10:39,580 --> 01:10:40,884
Chris: So when does it get better?

361
01:10:40,972 --> 01:11:16,650
Kayla: This direct evidence of his abuse and indiscretion was the straw that broke the camel's back for some of his followers. His followers split, schisms formed. He did retain some believers, but a new camp of challengers finally arose. He left the community. He was formally ousted from Nuvindraban in 1994. ISKCON students returned the community and worship style to the traditional pre Kirtananda traditions established by Prabhupda Kirito Nananda took his remaining followers up to New York, and Nu Vrindraban returned officially to ISKCON in 1998.

362
01:11:17,590 --> 01:11:19,126
Chris: Cool. You know what?

363
01:11:19,198 --> 01:11:22,410
Kayla: There's still more, but no, you can react.

364
01:11:24,470 --> 01:11:30,190
Chris: I can just go listen to music on YouTube. I don't have to do kirtans. It's not that important.

365
01:11:31,790 --> 01:12:07,192
Kayla: During his retrial, Kirtan Ananda pleaded guilty to one charge of racketeering and was sentenced to 20 years in prison. He was released in 2004 due to a decline in his health. And then in 2000, the ISKCON Child Protection Office conducted a year and a half long investigation into Kirtan Inanda and determined that they could establish, yes, he had molested at least two underage boys. In response, he was banned from all ISKCON properties for five years. Should have been for all the years, but for five years.

366
01:12:07,296 --> 01:12:11,256
Chris: Five years. Maybe they were hoping that he would kick off in that amount of time.

367
01:12:11,288 --> 01:12:44,434
Kayla: He was very ill. He was very ill. ISKCON also offered the following conditions if he wanted to be reinstated in the organization. And I'm going to read you the conditions quoted from the official decision on the case of Kirtan Ananda Das. ISKCON Central Office of Child Protection. One, he must contribute at least $10,000 to an organization dedicated to serving Vaishnava youth, such as children of Krishna, the Association for the Protection of Vaishnava Children, or a gurukula approved by the APVC. I don't know what all those words mean, but essentially he had to give money to a child protection organization.

368
01:12:44,562 --> 01:12:46,834
Chris: PVC is like that plastic piping.

369
01:12:46,882 --> 01:12:47,346
Kayla: It's that.

370
01:12:47,418 --> 01:12:47,930
Chris: Yeah.

371
01:12:48,050 --> 01:13:23,380
Kayla: Two, he must write apology letters to all the victims described in this letter. In these letters, he must fully acknowledge his transgressions of child abuse, and he must take full responsibility for those actions. Also, he must express appropriate remorse and offer to make amends to the victims. These letters should be sent to the organization and not directly to the victims. Three, he must undergo a psychological evaluation by a mental health professional pre approved by the organization, and he must comply with recommendations for ongoing therapy described in the evaluation report. And four, he must fully comply with all governmental investigations into misconduct on his part.

372
01:13:24,810 --> 01:13:26,510
Chris: I assume he didn't do any of that.

373
01:13:27,010 --> 01:13:36,070
Kayla: No. Yeah, he never did any of it. But can we talk for a minute about these requirements, about these conditions?

374
01:13:36,490 --> 01:13:37,230
Chris: Sure.

375
01:13:37,970 --> 01:13:52,402
Kayla: Does it seem like it's imperfect? Obviously, it's imperfect. I think that these should be conditions for his ability to ever return to ISKCON at all. Not to return to being in leadership. That seems ludicrous to me.

376
01:13:52,466 --> 01:13:53,070
Chris: Right.

377
01:13:54,420 --> 01:14:02,412
Kayla: It is, however, an example of something more along the lines of restorative justice than punitive justice.

378
01:14:02,516 --> 01:14:07,732
Chris: Yeah, I do like that part of it. I think if it was more, it's.

379
01:14:07,756 --> 01:14:15,956
Kayla: Saying, you have to take ownership of this to the victims. You have to give physical material restitution. You have to make amends.

380
01:14:15,988 --> 01:14:34,028
Chris: All that stuff is good. I just think that I would like to see it connected to a little better teeth. Like the whole, well, five years, you can come back anyway. And, you know, I think if it was more like, you are permanently banned, do all these things, and you may come back as a member, then I'd be like, yeah, that's pretty good.

381
01:14:34,084 --> 01:14:34,748
Kayla: Yeah.

382
01:14:34,924 --> 01:14:41,428
Chris: But for that part of it, for, like, the, you know, the prescriptive part of it. Yes, I think it was. That's some pretty good stuff.

383
01:14:41,484 --> 01:14:45,588
Kayla: I think it's something that we can all, like, build off of.

384
01:14:45,724 --> 01:14:46,156
Chris: Yeah.

385
01:14:46,228 --> 01:14:53,620
Kayla: It's not perfect, but we can all be thinking in a more restorative justice framework rather than a punitive justice framework. And he did go to jail.

386
01:14:54,280 --> 01:14:55,460
Chris: Is he dead now?

387
01:14:55,760 --> 01:15:19,364
Kayla: Eventually, he moved to India in 2008. He maintained a number of dedicated disciples as a guru, preaching an interfaith message. So, again, bringing that christian stuff into the Hare Krishna stuff. He died of kidney failure in Mumbai at age 74, and he named his disciple, Madhusudan Das, as his successor. So, yes, he has died. He is gone.

388
01:15:19,532 --> 01:15:32,340
Chris: So in that succession scheme, it's like, okay, here's all of the abuse stuff. You have to molest these kids, and you have to do these crimes and murder some people. No, that's not what a succession plan looked like. Oh. Cause that's what he did during his life.

389
01:15:32,420 --> 01:16:04,002
Kayla: Yeah. The G B c. Has steadily worked since Prabhupda's death to respond to the issues of transgressive criminal gurus within their ranks. Obviously imperfectly, they've worked to address systemic child abuse, the treatment of women, as well as the cult accusations. In 1982, the GBC began adding new gurus to the original eleven that Prabhupda named to help diversify the power structure. In 1985, they decided to lower the standard of living for ISKCON leadership. So, like, you're gonna get less money. You're not gonna be able to. We're not trying to attract you.

390
01:16:04,026 --> 01:16:05,906
Chris: Renunciates are going to get less money.

391
01:16:05,978 --> 01:16:09,556
Kayla: We're not trying to attract people who are in this for the money kind of thing.

392
01:16:09,748 --> 01:16:24,084
Chris: Yeah, that's the type of thing, though. Right is like, if you have people that are attracted to it for the power, then you're going to get people that care about power differentials and will use them for the things that they care for them about. And that's not good.

393
01:16:24,212 --> 01:17:12,234
Kayla: That same year, they made the decision to replace a number of leaders and consulted one of Prabhupdas God brothers on their selections. They made efforts to engage with and integrate into the wider hindu community. So to not be as insular and isolated, but to actually be. We are a hindu related organization. In the nineties, the G. B. C. Undertook a variety of discussions and reforms that paved the way for women to enter leadership. In 1998, Malati Davidas was the first woman appointed to the G. B. C. And Dina Sharana was the second in 2009. Over the years, ISKCON has moved away from the more identifiable public displays, such as wearing distinct orange robes, having shaved heads, public kiriton, and literature sharing. This is part of the wider integration effort, part of this move away from cult accusations.

394
01:17:12,362 --> 01:17:32,148
Kayla: And also it's just a practical response to legislation against their activities. In places like airports, you can't do it. You know, they're kind of. There was a lot of legislation, particularly in places like Lax, where it was, yes, you can be hare Krishna's here, but we're going to put you in like a booth in the corner with like the other nonprofits. And you can't like, be in the middle of everything. And so then what's the point?

395
01:17:32,234 --> 01:17:33,920
Chris: I think that's pretty reasonable.

396
01:17:34,080 --> 01:17:54,968
Kayla: I don't like being annoyed in public. The group grew rapidly in the sixties due to the counterculture movement in the US and Europe, but faced decline starting in the 1980s. In 2000, it was estimated that around 800 or 900 members lived in ISKCON centers in the US. So that was down from like the thousands that there were.

397
01:17:55,024 --> 01:17:56,984
Chris: Oh, that's like smaller than I would have thought. Wow.

398
01:17:57,072 --> 01:18:05,804
Kayla: Since this time, it has grown largely india and also in Russia after the fall of the Soviet Union. I don't really know why, but it has.

399
01:18:05,852 --> 01:18:06,732
Chris: That's interesting.

400
01:18:06,836 --> 01:18:10,252
Kayla: ISKCON currently claims around 1 million members worldwide.

401
01:18:10,316 --> 01:18:10,964
Chris: Oh, shit.

402
01:18:11,052 --> 01:18:12,628
Kayla: Most residing india.

403
01:18:12,724 --> 01:18:17,612
Chris: Okay. Yeah. 1 million is probably what I would have guessed, but that's quite.

404
01:18:17,676 --> 01:18:18,572
Kayla: It's not small.

405
01:18:18,676 --> 01:18:19,436
Chris: Yeah.

406
01:18:19,628 --> 01:18:30,380
Kayla: In the US, ISKCON has shifted away from a congregation base of mainly young white american devotees to a base that is largely that of the indian diaspora.

407
01:18:30,540 --> 01:18:31,268
Chris: Interesting.

408
01:18:31,364 --> 01:18:38,396
Kayla: Indian immigrants and people of indian descent are now largely responsible for kind of like a current revitalization of the movement. In recent years.

409
01:18:38,508 --> 01:18:42,908
Chris: Okay. I mean, based on what I saw when we visited there, that tracks.

410
01:18:43,044 --> 01:18:58,946
Kayla: In some temples, it can be as many as 80% of members are of indian descent. And much of this is related to IsKCon's kind of, like, reversing from its original course of, like, we're not hindu, which Prabhupda was very explicit about to this, like, yes, we are part of the broader hindu community.

411
01:18:59,058 --> 01:19:01,114
Chris: Right. That makes sense. That would give you more. Yeah.

412
01:19:01,202 --> 01:19:10,506
Kayla: They've also stepped back from pushing this more, like, monastic lifestyle on its followers. So, like, you don't have to be celibate. You don't have to, like, take a valve or denunciation. You have to live in a commune.

413
01:19:10,538 --> 01:19:14,090
Chris: Followers are, you don't have to sit on a pile of $12 million in your house.

414
01:19:14,170 --> 01:19:48,428
Kayla: Followers are now welcome to attend weekly services like you and I did. You're more akin to traditional mainstream religious worship. Theyve also toned down the hard sell recruitment. They welcome doubters. They tend to wait for followers to approach rather than go out and evangelize. Theyre more trying to be attractive rather than evangelize. Y one last thing before we head to our criteria. I mentioned in the last episode that I wanted to look into the veracity of ISkCons claims about its good works, particularly when it comes to its Food for Life program, which they says provides over a million free meals daily to those in need.

415
01:19:48,574 --> 01:19:50,312
Chris: I'm really crossing my fingers here.

416
01:19:50,376 --> 01:20:10,712
Kayla: From what I was able to learn, ISKCON's claims about its good works are generally undisputed these days. Food for Life Global is an independent non profit organization affiliated with ISKCOn. It has its roots in the group, but it operates on its own. It spans across 65 countries, provides hunger relief to the homeless, to children, and in response to natural disasters.

417
01:20:10,896 --> 01:20:12,856
Chris: I appreciate that you saved that for the end.

418
01:20:12,928 --> 01:20:29,230
Kayla: Other good works, such as their cow protection efforts, which saves cows from factory farming and slaughter and provides them with happy, comfortable lives and also promotes vegetarianism. This also operates as an independent nonprofit across the world. So it's not all controversy all the time.

419
01:20:29,570 --> 01:20:34,230
Chris: That's nice. Thank you for saving that till the end, even though I do eat cows.

420
01:20:34,770 --> 01:20:38,426
Kayla: And with that, let's take it to the criteria. Chris, you ready?

421
01:20:38,458 --> 01:20:41,264
Chris: All right. Yep, I'm ready. It's called charismatic leader. Bye, guys.

422
01:20:41,312 --> 01:20:42,820
Kayla: I think it's not so clear cut.

423
01:20:43,560 --> 01:20:47,264
Chris: I don't know. I'm just, like, really affected by all the stuff we talked about today, I guess.

424
01:20:47,432 --> 01:20:48,376
Kayla: Charismatic leader.

425
01:20:48,488 --> 01:20:48,880
Chris: High.

426
01:20:48,960 --> 01:20:50,728
Kayla: High. We don't even need to talk about it.

427
01:20:50,784 --> 01:20:57,872
Chris: Yeah. Very high. I mean, we can differentiate between Prabhupda, who sounded like he was quite charismatic, quite leaderful.

428
01:20:57,976 --> 01:20:58,352
Kayla: Yeah.

429
01:20:58,416 --> 01:21:05,384
Chris: And then, like, Kirtan Ananda had followers up until. Up until he died.

430
01:21:05,472 --> 01:21:13,580
Kayla: Up until he went to jail and got convict. Like, not convicted, but, like, had an organization go. Yes. He molested. He was found in a. A van with a boy.

431
01:21:13,740 --> 01:21:16,452
Chris: Yeah. So something there was charismatic.

432
01:21:16,516 --> 01:21:19,080
Kayla: Very high, expected harm.

433
01:21:21,580 --> 01:21:28,188
Chris: I don't see how this can be any, like, I know things are. Whatever may be different these days, I.

434
01:21:28,204 --> 01:21:39,652
Kayla: Would not expect you and I to have harm. But the fucking school system, the shit that, like, those followers went through, the women that had to deal with being disrespected. I don't know, I just.

435
01:21:39,676 --> 01:21:55,418
Chris: It feels like you. Even though. Yeah. I feel like I have to score this high, even though. I know. Yeah. If we joined, we probably wouldn't be like, oh, shit, I got abused. What? But the expected harm overall is so high that it just. I feel like we have to call it high.

436
01:21:55,474 --> 01:21:56,986
Kayla: It's like that karmic thing.

437
01:21:57,098 --> 01:21:57,790
Chris: Yeah.

438
01:21:58,370 --> 01:21:59,590
Kayla: Presence of ritual.

439
01:22:00,010 --> 01:22:04,786
Chris: Hi. Yes, we saw it. Yes, were there. We sang. No, did we sing? I didn't sing.

440
01:22:04,858 --> 01:22:05,626
Kayla: I did not sing.

441
01:22:05,698 --> 01:22:06,590
Chris: I listened.

442
01:22:07,370 --> 01:22:08,750
Kayla: Niche within society.

443
01:22:11,460 --> 01:22:15,404
Chris: A million is not a lot in the scheme of things.

444
01:22:15,452 --> 01:22:17,960
Kayla: It's not. But it's also really well known.

445
01:22:18,300 --> 01:22:25,960
Chris: It's well known. It is well known. It makes appearances in popular video game franchises, so maybe that alone.

446
01:22:27,380 --> 01:22:35,684
Kayla: And it's also, like, if you look at ISKCON as a piece of the wider gaudiya Vaishnavism faith.

447
01:22:35,772 --> 01:22:36,560
Chris: Mm.

448
01:22:37,100 --> 01:22:38,600
Kayla: That's not niche at all.

449
01:22:39,100 --> 01:22:40,340
Chris: Yeah. And then, like.

450
01:22:40,460 --> 01:22:42,084
Kayla: And it is just a branch of that.

451
01:22:42,132 --> 01:22:49,412
Chris: Being a branch of that definitely makes it seem like religion because it's like, well, it's the branch of that, which is a branch of Hinduism. And, like, that's definitely religion.

452
01:22:49,476 --> 01:22:51,080
Kayla: I think it's a religion.

453
01:22:53,380 --> 01:23:03,354
Chris: All right, well, stick with this criteria, I guess. We'll say niche is low because it's well known. And I'll give you. I'll give it to you on the branch thing, too.

454
01:23:03,452 --> 01:23:04,730
Kayla: Antifactuality.

455
01:23:05,990 --> 01:23:19,130
Chris: I don't think that in general, they're not doing weird conspiracy stuff or, like, anti vaxx, as far as I'm aware. Not that I really came across at the same time.

456
01:23:20,110 --> 01:23:42,374
Kayla: And they did. When we did go to the temple again, were the only ones. No, weren't. There was low mask wearing when went, but when were there were signs from, like, the pre vaccine days of like, you have to wear a mask. You have to be, you know, 6ft from each other. So there was. I do look at. That's evidence of a barometer. Factuality.

457
01:23:42,422 --> 01:23:58,966
Chris: Yeah, it's a bit of a barometer for factuality. I. Yeah, I don't know. But then I think about, like, all of the. I don't know, like they tried to. Kirito Nana tried to cover up things by killing people. That says antifactual to me.

458
01:23:59,118 --> 01:24:03,650
Kayla: And it is baked into the religion to, like, not believe in things like evolution.

459
01:24:04,270 --> 01:24:04,998
Chris: Yeah.

460
01:24:05,134 --> 01:24:17,854
Kayla: I don't know if it's like, super. I don't know if it's like super dangerous antifactuality, but it is more like the religious style antifactuality of like. Yeah, we're talking about faith versus science, right?

461
01:24:18,022 --> 01:24:22,986
Chris: I mean, like, Krishna doesn't exist. Is that antifactual? I don't know.

462
01:24:23,018 --> 01:24:24,986
Kayla: I don't know. I don't think that's the same as antifactuality.

463
01:24:25,018 --> 01:24:31,906
Chris: I think that there's antifactuality when we say more like logical fallacies. Yeah, I don't know.

464
01:24:31,938 --> 01:24:44,570
Kayla: Or like the obfuscation of truth. I think medium. 52% percentage of life consumed. I think that's changed over the years. I think it was, in its initial inception, very high. And now seems to be.

465
01:24:44,610 --> 01:24:46,098
Chris: Yeah. If you're sending kids to boarding school.

466
01:24:46,154 --> 01:24:46,386
Kayla: Yeah.

467
01:24:46,418 --> 01:24:47,970
Chris: I mean, that's like all of it.

468
01:24:48,050 --> 01:24:50,714
Kayla: But now it seems to be. It's just the same.

469
01:24:50,762 --> 01:24:52,154
Chris: More of like a church service thing.

470
01:24:52,242 --> 01:24:53,510
Kayla: Any other religion?

471
01:24:54,010 --> 01:25:05,870
Chris: Should we split this up into, like, iskcon now and ISkCon in the seventies and eighties, we could. I don't know. Like, if we did, then I would say, yeah, high before, low now.

472
01:25:06,170 --> 01:25:07,710
Kayla: Dogmatic beliefs.

473
01:25:08,730 --> 01:25:12,794
Chris: I mean, I was. I would have. Last week or last episode, I would have said low.

474
01:25:12,962 --> 01:25:15,346
Kayla: I still would say. Well, I don't know.

475
01:25:15,458 --> 01:25:28,010
Chris: It seemed like they were like, everybody's welcome. Whatever sense of, like, the only thing that got them to kick that guy out of their religion was when he was like, maybe we should do some Christianity stuff, not the abusing kids.

476
01:25:28,050 --> 01:25:32,910
Kayla: No, that's okay. That's not true. He was kicked out for doing that before he molested the kids.

477
01:25:33,210 --> 01:25:36,538
Chris: Right, I know, but like, maybe.

478
01:25:36,674 --> 01:25:37,570
Kayla: No, he was.

479
01:25:37,690 --> 01:25:39,466
Chris: He was saying he might have been molesting kids back.

480
01:25:39,498 --> 01:25:45,434
Kayla: Well, yeah, that's true. What are we on dogmatic beliefs?

481
01:25:45,482 --> 01:25:46,110
Chris: Yeah.

482
01:25:47,810 --> 01:26:21,580
Kayla: I just didn't really get the sense of if you had questions, you were going to be shunned. But I could be wrong. I also didn't get the sense that you could necessarily question Prabhupda and have a good time. Yeah, medium chain of victims is very high. Yeah, it's kind of. Again, I think we should change this criteria, chain of recruits and that, especially back in, like, the sixties and seventies when it was like, I'm a hippie. I'm gonna get all my hippie friends in on this. I'm George Harrison. I'm gonna write a song about it to get people chanting before they even realize they're doing it.

483
01:26:21,660 --> 01:26:23,160
Chris: Yeah. Yeah. Hi.

484
01:26:23,540 --> 01:26:28,012
Kayla: This one, I don't know. Safe or unsafe exit? This would have been a really good one to.

485
01:26:28,036 --> 01:26:31,682
Chris: Well, for those guys that got murdered, I would say pretty unsafe. Am I right?

486
01:26:31,796 --> 01:26:38,606
Kayla: Yeah, I get the sense that now you can go. You could be there for a little bit. You could leave. You're not gonna get in trouble.

487
01:26:38,638 --> 01:26:39,854
Chris: Am I gonna get assassinated?

488
01:26:39,902 --> 01:26:40,654
Kayla: I don't think so.

489
01:26:40,702 --> 01:26:42,438
Chris: Are we gonna get assassinated for doing this podcast?

490
01:26:42,494 --> 01:26:47,350
Kayla: You know what, I kind of want to send an email to Mister Doktorsky and ask this question.

491
01:26:47,470 --> 01:26:49,486
Chris: Ask him if our life is in danger.

492
01:26:49,598 --> 01:26:55,490
Kayla: Ask him if there's a safe or unsafe exit in this organization or what his answer would be to that.

493
01:26:56,230 --> 01:27:09,928
Chris: I'm going to say unsafe. I'm sorry. And if we're doing the split, used to be unsafe, seems safe now. But, you know, if you don't hear from us in two weeks, then you'll know the answer to this was unsafe exit.

494
01:27:09,984 --> 01:27:14,328
Kayla: I think it's pretty clear. Honestly. I think it's like, based on the.

495
01:27:14,344 --> 01:27:15,504
Chris: Criteria, it's definitely religion.

496
01:27:15,552 --> 01:27:19,072
Kayla: I think pre 2000 cult. Post 2000 religion.

497
01:27:19,216 --> 01:27:19,888
Chris: Yeah.

498
01:27:20,024 --> 01:27:22,704
Kayla: I don't know why I'm using that as a specific time.

499
01:27:22,872 --> 01:27:32,130
Chris: Well, I would say pre 2000, harmful religion. Post 2000, probably benign religion.

500
01:27:32,170 --> 01:27:33,270
Kayla: You don't think it was a cult.

501
01:27:34,010 --> 01:27:37,750
Chris: Because it still didn't have the niche thing back then. It was even bigger back then.

502
01:27:38,410 --> 01:27:39,154
Kayla: Grand theft auto.

503
01:27:39,202 --> 01:27:39,666
Henry Doktorsky: But it wasn't.

504
01:27:39,698 --> 01:27:44,298
Kayla: No, it wasn't bigger. It wasn't bigger. It didn't have a million followers. It had thousands of followers.

505
01:27:44,354 --> 01:27:45,642
Chris: But they were in airports.

506
01:27:45,746 --> 01:27:49,874
Kayla: They were in airports and they were still part of the branch. Man.

507
01:27:50,042 --> 01:27:53,840
Chris: Maybe, right? Maybe it's called either way harmful before, not as harmful now.

508
01:27:53,930 --> 01:27:54,916
Kayla: Cult to religion.

509
01:27:55,028 --> 01:27:56,308
Chris: Cult to religion.

510
01:27:56,484 --> 01:28:01,440
Kayla: And not because the faith changed. Can we say that simply because the structure seemed to change?

511
01:28:01,740 --> 01:28:05,868
Chris: Are we breaking our own rules here? Like, I kind of feel like we're playing fast and loose here with our critics.

512
01:28:05,884 --> 01:28:13,036
Kayla: I don't know. We shouldn't even be using the word cult. Like, we shouldn't even be using the word cult. So it's not a good word. It's a right word.

513
01:28:13,148 --> 01:28:16,680
Chris: Cult. Tm, cult are just weird style cult.

514
01:28:17,140 --> 01:28:19,172
Kayla: So that's our answer.

515
01:28:19,316 --> 01:28:23,414
Chris: Yes, cult. Harmful cult. Then probably benign religion.

516
01:28:23,502 --> 01:28:26,130
Kayla: But what does Mister Doktorsky have to say about it?

517
01:28:26,870 --> 01:28:35,650
Kayla: We just always ask this. If anybody we talk to, would you personally define this group, define ISkcon as a cult? Or would you define it as just weird?

518
01:28:36,470 --> 01:29:38,820
Henry Doktorsky: Well, it's not weird. I would never say it's weird. You could say that it is a religion with cult like aspects. That's what I would personally say. You could also say that it's a cult based on an actual religion, which is gaudiya vaishnavism. The cultist aspects come because the guru is supposed to be worshipped as good as God. He's not God, but he's as good as God because that's the only way the disciple can approach God, is through the guru. So that's part of theology. Like that. You know, I don't think it's weird at all. I don't. What else would be weird about it? That they're vegetarians? That they worship. That they worship statues and feed the statues? Well, maybe that's might be a little weird, but. But it's tradition with thousands of years india to feed the statues. You know, it's like.

519
01:29:38,940 --> 01:30:30,762
Henry Doktorsky: And to say this is. And this is God, you know, because. Because for one thing, where is there not God? God is all pervasive, right? So everywhere. He's everywhere. He's everywhere. So why can he not be in this statue, you know? And it gives you a chance to render some service. Bhakti yoga. It's about service and service with love. All right, so you can't have Bhakti or love or service if you don't have two individuals like the Maya bodies and the Monas. You say that all is one. But if all is one, then there's no love. There's a bliss in all that is one. There's no doubt about that. The Brahman realization. There's a great peacefulness and tranquility and wonderful experience. However, you don't have love.

520
01:30:30,946 --> 01:30:53,150
Henry Doktorsky: And according to the Gaudi of Aishtav, they say that the exchange of the pleasure from love is higher than the pleasure of everything being one and connected and all together. And in order to have love, you have to have two individuals, one to reciprocate loving exchanges like that. I forgot what your original question was, but maybe it's answered.

521
01:30:53,230 --> 01:31:06,606
Kayla: I mean, that's a beautiful answer and that's a great note to go off of. So thank you so much for spending time with us, for answering our questions. I really appreciate you making the time to share your experiences and everything you've investigated.

522
01:31:06,758 --> 01:31:08,090
Henry Doktorsky: Terrific. Thank you.

523
01:31:08,990 --> 01:31:20,890
Kayla: Thank you for going on this journey with me to learn more about the International Society for Krishna Consciousness, aka the Hare Krishnas. Now I'm hungry and I know a great place where we can get some cheap vegetarian food.

524
01:31:21,390 --> 01:31:23,782
Chris: This is Chris, this is Kayla, and.

525
01:31:23,806 --> 01:31:27,010
Kayla: This has been cult or just weird.