S2E6 - The Coaches (Team Beachbody MLM)

1
00:00:41,570 --> 00:00:47,018
Kayla: Just saying, if you want banter that's not related to what's happening to the goings ons.

2
00:00:47,114 --> 00:00:50,810
Chris: I don't know. Maybe we should say. Maybe we should. I don't know.

3
00:00:50,970 --> 00:00:51,882
Kayla: I know.

4
00:00:52,066 --> 00:01:25,102
Chris: I just. I don't want to. Okay, fine. Here's what we'll put in the show is we know what's going on right now, and we are making an active decision to not talk about it because there are many other voices that are and will say things better than we can. And we want this show right now to be able to be a respite from what's going on and not something that will just remind you and be yet one more piece of news in this currently shitty news cycle.

5
00:01:25,206 --> 00:01:30,862
Kayla: You can check out our social media for more pointed covering of this topic.

6
00:01:31,006 --> 00:01:53,516
Chris: Yeah. Yeah. Well, we're here for it, and we are here for you guys, but we don't want to have, like, a long five minute segment where we talk about it because there's plenty of time to go read the news. And yours truly may have been doing that a lot, so I know how bad it can be, and I'd rather this be like, let's talk about something else for a bit.

7
00:01:53,678 --> 00:01:54,560
Kayla: Agreed.

8
00:01:54,720 --> 00:01:57,580
Chris: So what do you want to talk about? You said Star Trek.

9
00:01:58,120 --> 00:02:00,568
Kayla: You just made me watch a weird Star Trek episode, so.

10
00:02:00,704 --> 00:02:03,064
Chris: Okay, that was redundant. They're all weird.

11
00:02:03,112 --> 00:02:06,020
Kayla: They're all weird. I don't know why you want me to watch them.

12
00:02:06,720 --> 00:02:07,840
Chris: It's a good show.

13
00:02:07,920 --> 00:02:09,580
Kayla: It is a good show. I'm enjoying it.

14
00:02:10,680 --> 00:02:33,008
Chris: It's very. This is next generation, by the way, nerdy as we are. It's just been nice to watch a show that was made in the eighties and the nineties that has a very. Everything gets resolved at the end and everybody's friends and happy and nobody dies. Except for Tasha Yar. Spoiler alert.

15
00:02:33,064 --> 00:03:00,468
Kayla: Oh, rip. No. The best. The best thing that. My favorite thing that's happened this week, television wise, was when I was watching a drama show and there was a mention of, like, some of the horrors going on in our world, but, like, six month ago horrors, as opposed to, like, current right now, like, what we're living through horrors. And you commented on it, obviously. And I was like, this is escapism for me. Don't talk about it.

16
00:03:00,524 --> 00:03:04,692
Chris: I know. And it was like talking about, like, children in cages, and you're like, that's escapism.

17
00:03:04,836 --> 00:03:16,580
Kayla: And then. And then it was like, we turned on the news and it was like, yeah, see, that. That. That was escapism. Considering what's going on. So all television is escapism right now, unless it's the news.

18
00:03:16,660 --> 00:03:28,864
Chris: Well, okay. Sorry that I. I prefer to watch a show about a giant void in the middle of space that eats the Enterprise and has a weird little baby face with terrible.

19
00:03:29,032 --> 00:03:30,136
Kayla: It killed someone.

20
00:03:30,248 --> 00:03:33,880
Chris: Graphical effects. It killed a red shirt. Kayla, that's barely a someone.

21
00:03:33,960 --> 00:03:40,240
Kayla: You know what? In the year of our lord 2020, we no longer can stand for the cannon fodder.

22
00:03:40,400 --> 00:03:49,590
Chris: Anyway, it's been nice to watch Star Trek because it's, like, just total weird bullshit, and it's great.

23
00:03:49,930 --> 00:03:50,738
Kayla: Except there's, like.

24
00:03:50,794 --> 00:03:52,510
Chris: Okay, yeah, except what?

25
00:03:53,570 --> 00:04:06,562
Kayla: Like, all good science fiction. It, like, makes commentary on the social topics of the time, and those are difficult to grapple with sometimes. Did you like that?

26
00:04:06,666 --> 00:04:13,186
Chris: Yeah, that was great. That was a little ping. Plus one virtue point for Kayla.

27
00:04:13,298 --> 00:04:22,029
Kayla: I love a good virtue point. Yeah. So. No, I'm enjoying it. Thank you for showing it to me. It's a good show.

28
00:04:22,730 --> 00:04:24,910
Chris: Also, it's great to get high to.

29
00:04:25,490 --> 00:04:28,746
Kayla: We should probably introduce the podcast. We haven't done that yet.

30
00:04:28,898 --> 00:04:35,002
Chris: Oh, this is Chris, this is Kayla, and this is. Wait, do we do the weird, like, back and forth thing?

31
00:04:35,026 --> 00:04:35,970
Kayla: No, we just do this as culture.

32
00:04:36,010 --> 00:04:37,458
Chris: I don't even think we should do that at the end.

33
00:04:37,514 --> 00:04:38,914
Kayla: I don't think we should do it at all.

34
00:04:39,042 --> 00:04:39,786
Chris: Cheesy.

35
00:04:39,898 --> 00:04:40,658
Kayla: Let's just not even end.

36
00:04:40,674 --> 00:04:42,750
Chris: This belongs on something like Star Trek.

37
00:04:43,790 --> 00:04:46,130
Kayla: I think it might be too cheesy even for Star Trek.

38
00:04:46,710 --> 00:04:47,566
Chris: Wow.

39
00:04:47,758 --> 00:04:53,070
Kayla: They never go. And this is Star Trek. There you go.

40
00:04:53,230 --> 00:04:55,822
Chris: Yeah, no, they do that. They start doing that in season three.

41
00:04:55,886 --> 00:04:58,094
Kayla: Oh, gotcha. The one that. The season that gets good.

42
00:04:58,182 --> 00:05:03,310
Chris: Yeah. They look into the camera at the end of the show, and they say, this has been Star Trek.

43
00:05:03,350 --> 00:05:04,450
Kayla: I'm Jean Luc.

44
00:05:07,630 --> 00:05:09,954
Chris: That's the season they start podcasting from the Enterprise.

45
00:05:10,022 --> 00:05:10,554
Kayla: Gotcha.

46
00:05:10,642 --> 00:05:24,578
Chris: Yeah. So, anyway, this episode is not about Star Trek. Although, actually, Trekkies are kind of like their own cult. Right? Trekkies or Trekkers. They're supposed to be called Trekkers now. I don't know. At some point. At some point, they, like, changed their name, I think.

47
00:05:24,754 --> 00:05:25,210
Kayla: Why?

48
00:05:25,290 --> 00:05:27,066
Chris: Because they didn't like being called Trekkies.

49
00:05:27,258 --> 00:05:31,146
Kayla: Because it sounded like groupies, maybe. I don't know.

50
00:05:31,178 --> 00:05:32,258
Chris: Sounds like it needs an episode.

51
00:05:32,314 --> 00:05:36,258
Kayla: I feel like it doesn't need an episode. I'm claiming it. I'm claiming it.

52
00:05:36,314 --> 00:05:36,898
Chris: Fair enough.

53
00:05:36,994 --> 00:05:40,686
Kayla: For one, you're too close to it. You're too close to the topic.

54
00:05:40,878 --> 00:05:43,918
Chris: I am not, like, a huge Star Trek fan.

55
00:05:44,054 --> 00:05:45,038
Kayla: Too close to the topic.

56
00:05:45,094 --> 00:05:47,570
Chris: I haven't even seen all of deep space nine two.

57
00:05:47,870 --> 00:05:53,614
Kayla: Star Trek fandom is the, like, birthplace of all fandom.

58
00:05:53,742 --> 00:05:54,926
Chris: Oh, it's the Ur fandom.

59
00:05:54,958 --> 00:05:56,046
Kayla: It is ur fandom.

60
00:05:56,118 --> 00:05:56,890
Chris: Is it?

61
00:05:57,190 --> 00:05:58,110
Kayla: I think it.

62
00:05:58,190 --> 00:05:58,774
Chris: It might be.

63
00:05:58,822 --> 00:06:04,966
Kayla: I think it's technically considered, like, the birthplace of modern fandom. And it was largely.

64
00:06:04,998 --> 00:06:06,854
Chris: So we're just doing this. Is this just the episode?

65
00:06:06,902 --> 00:06:13,442
Kayla: Yeah, were switching to me, it was largely driven by women. Like, mostly women, and mostly because.

66
00:06:13,506 --> 00:06:15,778
Chris: Okay, wait. All of it. Save this. Put this in your back pocket.

67
00:06:15,794 --> 00:06:43,900
Kayla: This is an episode, and a big part of it was. And it also kicked off. It was also responsible for kicking off the slash fiction. You know what? Slash fiction is fanfic, and it's gay fanfic because it's Kirk Spock or Kirk whoever. I think it was Kirk Spock slash fic. That was like, that's where Fanfic is from.

68
00:06:44,020 --> 00:06:44,388
Chris: Got it.

69
00:06:44,404 --> 00:06:45,780
Kayla: Again. Women are behind it.

70
00:06:45,900 --> 00:06:47,492
Chris: Right. That would make sense.

71
00:06:47,636 --> 00:06:48,660
Kayla: I'm claiming it.

72
00:06:48,780 --> 00:06:54,108
Chris: Okay. Yeah, you got this. I just. It sounds like you already, like, have half the episode written in your head.

73
00:06:54,164 --> 00:06:55,876
Kayla: No, I just spent too much time on Tumblr.

74
00:06:55,948 --> 00:06:57,596
Chris: Hold on to those tidbits there.

75
00:06:57,788 --> 00:06:59,480
Kayla: Hold on to your tidbits.

76
00:06:59,820 --> 00:07:16,342
Chris: Speaking of which, you were saying, like, oh, switch to Kayla. Actually, I am doing the topic today. We're doing a weird thing. Even though before I did the topic, before last episode, before we talked to Nikto and Sooksie, I did the Roku's basilisk episode.

77
00:07:16,446 --> 00:07:18,918
Kayla: Oh, but we recorded that, like, four months ago.

78
00:07:19,094 --> 00:07:24,790
Chris: Yeah, it doesn't matter when we recorded it. I just want to explain to our listeners, who are used to us switching off.

79
00:07:24,870 --> 00:07:25,206
Kayla: Right.

80
00:07:25,278 --> 00:07:32,884
Chris: So we're just doing a little bit of a shuffle here, and then Kayla's gonna do two in a row, and nobody probably cares about this at all, but I just felt like mentioning it.

81
00:07:32,932 --> 00:07:33,452
Kayla: There you go.

82
00:07:33,516 --> 00:07:46,276
Chris: Okay, there. Super important news out. Anyway, as is so often the case on the show, today's cult, or just weird, has a slight personal connection for us.

83
00:07:46,428 --> 00:07:47,320
Kayla: It does.

84
00:07:47,980 --> 00:07:49,148
Chris: But before I tell you what it.

85
00:07:49,164 --> 00:07:50,660
Kayla: Is, Kayla, and it's not Star Trek.

86
00:07:50,740 --> 00:08:04,824
Chris: It's not Star Trek. I mean, despite, like, really wanting to veer hard in that direction. But I'm gonna ask you instead, and our audience, to dig deeper. Did that trigger any memories for you?

87
00:08:04,952 --> 00:08:07,776
Kayla: No, unless you're my 10th grade English teacher.

88
00:08:07,888 --> 00:08:11,448
Chris: Dig deeper. No.

89
00:08:11,584 --> 00:08:14,032
Kayla: Is it supposed to? Is that Shanti?

90
00:08:14,216 --> 00:08:15,664
Chris: That's Shawn T. Is it?

91
00:08:15,712 --> 00:08:16,416
Kayla: Dig deeper.

92
00:08:16,488 --> 00:08:19,744
Chris: Dig deeper. Yeah. He always would say on the insanity workout.

93
00:08:19,832 --> 00:08:20,304
Kayla: He did.

94
00:08:20,352 --> 00:08:21,968
Chris: Dig deeper. Yeah.

95
00:08:22,144 --> 00:08:24,392
Kayla: That's a blast from the past, man.

96
00:08:24,456 --> 00:08:26,960
Chris: I know. Do you remember the insanity workout?

97
00:08:27,040 --> 00:08:28,704
Kayla: Do I remember the insanity workout?

98
00:08:28,752 --> 00:08:33,980
Chris: Yeah. Well, I mean, I remember it because all I did was, like, sith at my computer playing games while you did it.

99
00:08:34,020 --> 00:08:36,419
Kayla: Yeah, I did the insanity work.

100
00:08:36,460 --> 00:08:39,508
Chris: Yeah. Yeah. And I'm at. That's why I'm asking if you remember it. I don't remember.

101
00:08:39,563 --> 00:08:39,876
Kayla: Yeah.

102
00:08:39,948 --> 00:08:46,004
Chris: I mean, I remember the dig deep. That's probably why I remember the quote. Cause I was actually able to hear things, whereas, like, all you could hear was your own pain.

103
00:08:46,052 --> 00:08:55,080
Kayla: Fucking floor. It was the most intense physical experience of my life. No, that's a lie. It was one of the most intense physical experiences of my life.

104
00:08:55,780 --> 00:08:59,356
Chris: Right. It was pretty awesome, though. Like, it's. I mean, it sounded like it was.

105
00:08:59,388 --> 00:09:31,708
Kayla: Oh, it was extraordinarily effective. Like, in terms of. Because the best part. Okay, I'm definitely in this cult. The best part about it was that at the beginning, you do a fitness test, and you, like, do a whole bunch of moves, and you, like, see how many of each move you can do in, like, a minute or 30 seconds or something. And then you write that down, and then you do it again in the middle, and then you do it again at the end. And holy shit. The amount of progress that you make is stunning. Like, it is a huge kickstart to your, like, cardiovascular system.

106
00:09:31,804 --> 00:09:56,280
Chris: That's awesome. I mean, like, to me, that's the only thing that I feel motivates me about doing workouts is progress. That's, like, to me, it's like. That's the thing, right? It's like, when you can lift more than you did last week or last month, or when you can do better on the fitness test, or. I mean, even, like, when I was, you know, playing basketball a lot more, like, in college, progress is awesome. But did anything feel, like, culty about it?

107
00:09:56,710 --> 00:10:17,926
Kayla: I mean, yes, but mostly. I don't know how to explain this. Well, mostly because. So there's the videos, right? And you're doing these videos, and there's, like, seven videos or whatever. And all the videos are, you know, the hour long workout, and there's a group of people doing the workouts along with Shawn T. Right?

108
00:10:17,958 --> 00:10:23,046
Chris: It's like. It's like. There's just. It's Shawn T. Who's the trip? Do we even say that? We just said Shanti a bunch of times.

109
00:10:23,158 --> 00:10:26,014
Kayla: People would know. Is Shanti the charismatic leader here?

110
00:10:26,142 --> 00:10:30,098
Chris: Sadly, no. Even though he's, like, the most charismatic leader person we have talked about yet on social media.

111
00:10:30,114 --> 00:10:58,474
Kayla: Oh, my God. And it's. Unfortunately, his name is Sean, and his last name is something that starts with t. So he's Sean T. He started, I believe he was a backup dancer. I mean, this is me saying this, but I have not researched it in years. I think he was one of Britney's backup dancers. He's a backup dancer. Maybe he was jam. I don't know. He is a backup dancer, and he has a banging bod, and he does a whole bunch of different, like, workout videos. Workout systems.

112
00:10:58,602 --> 00:11:00,866
Chris: Yeah. He doesn't have a six pack. He has, like, an 18 pack.

113
00:11:00,898 --> 00:11:02,154
Kayla: He's got a 27 pack.

114
00:11:02,202 --> 00:11:02,498
Chris: Yeah.

115
00:11:02,554 --> 00:11:15,330
Kayla: There's, like, an extra, like, a spare one for a rainy day. And so the workout videos where he's doing the workout and he's doing the workout, and he has all these people around him doing the workout. Some of the people are the same people in each video, and.

116
00:11:15,370 --> 00:11:17,018
Chris: Oh, I remember that now. Yeah.

117
00:11:17,074 --> 00:11:19,330
Kayla: And then there's one girl.

118
00:11:19,450 --> 00:11:20,474
Chris: What was her name again?

119
00:11:20,562 --> 00:11:21,154
Kayla: Tanya.

120
00:11:21,242 --> 00:11:24,410
Chris: Tanya. That's right. I forgot about Tanya.

121
00:11:24,450 --> 00:11:51,820
Kayla: You can clearly tell that, like, she's the chosen one, and other people are jealous. I mean, like, I looked it up later, and they were, like, friends before this. She's also a dancer, that bitch. But it definitely has, it just smacks of, like, this is the cult of Shanti. This is the cult of Shanti. People are like, she's the ma Adnan Sheila of this situation. People are, like, jockeying for position and also, like, the workout is insane.

122
00:11:52,240 --> 00:11:53,272
Chris: Is it insanity?

123
00:11:53,376 --> 00:12:07,760
Kayla: It is insanity. It has. There is almost, like, a cult like thing there breaking down the body every single day. It's every single day for 60 days.

124
00:12:07,800 --> 00:12:09,240
Chris: I think it was a long time.

125
00:12:09,320 --> 00:12:11,000
Kayla: I think it's every single day for 60 days.

126
00:12:11,040 --> 00:12:12,800
Chris: That's no breaks at all.

127
00:12:12,880 --> 00:12:38,590
Kayla: No, no. Even when there's a rest day, there's a workout every single day. And at the end of each workout, they kind of, like, try to sell you some other stuff. Like, it kind of has this whole thing going on with it. And then there's, like, a Reddit community where it's, like, people do who do insanity all the time. Like, it's not a Workout that you can do in your normal Life. It's like, the only reason I did it was to manage anxiety. Like, that's what it was because, like, I did.

128
00:12:38,630 --> 00:12:39,742
Chris: Was it, like an hour of.

129
00:12:39,806 --> 00:12:42,556
Kayla: It's like an hour at least every day. Sometimes you have two a days.

130
00:12:42,678 --> 00:12:43,408
Chris: Oh, geez.

131
00:12:43,464 --> 00:12:54,344
Kayla: Yeah. And it's like, it's truly the most punishing workout I've ever experienced. And the only reason I did it was because I had just quit a really, really stressful job.

132
00:12:54,472 --> 00:12:55,448
Chris: It's three really's.

133
00:12:55,504 --> 00:13:06,312
Kayla: And were planning our wedding, and so I had a lot of anxiety going and kind of having this to focus on. I think it really helped.

134
00:13:06,416 --> 00:13:08,670
Chris: Shoot, maybe you should do that again. Maybe help your dreams.

135
00:13:08,800 --> 00:13:14,986
Kayla: Maybe. But I will. I will never do it again. There's people who do this multiple times. I will never do it again.

136
00:13:15,058 --> 00:13:16,670
Chris: It's kind of tempting. I kind of want to.

137
00:13:17,210 --> 00:13:34,110
Kayla: The joke, like, there's a million memes about it, but the running joke is that somebody who does insanity, their warm up is your workout. And it's true. Like, you do the warm up and you want to die, and then you're like, I have 45 minutes more of actual workout. Now.

138
00:13:34,540 --> 00:13:35,308
Chris: That's crazy.

139
00:13:35,364 --> 00:13:38,540
Kayla: Yeah, I mean, try it if you want to. It's a lot of fun.

140
00:13:38,700 --> 00:13:48,340
Chris: Well, insanity isn't the cult. Now. This is, like, twice today that we've been like, let's talk about something. It's not that. And, yeah, sadly, Shanti's not our charismatic.

141
00:13:48,380 --> 00:13:49,532
Kayla: Leader, but he could be.

142
00:13:49,596 --> 00:13:52,196
Chris: He has the highest charisma score of any human being ever.

143
00:13:52,268 --> 00:14:09,024
Kayla: Although I do take a little bit of issue with Shanti, because he is. He might not be anymore, but at the time, he was a fruit denier. Fruit denier. He's one of those people who's like, you can eat fruit, but, like, have a piece in the morning. And that's all.

144
00:14:09,072 --> 00:14:10,536
Chris: You should listen to our clean eating episode.

145
00:14:10,568 --> 00:14:14,260
Kayla: Yeah. So I don't know if that's still that way, but it was at the time, probably.

146
00:14:15,480 --> 00:14:25,904
Chris: But it is, like, cult adjacent. So let's follow the trail up one level, from the insanity workout itself to the parent company, which I think you probably remember.

147
00:14:26,032 --> 00:14:29,140
Kayla: Okay. Because they would always do it. Then they'd go, beach body.

148
00:14:29,610 --> 00:15:00,676
Chris: Beachbody. That's right. According to Beachbody's Wikipedia entry, which, of course, is always our favorite starting point, since their articles have great introductory definitions. Beachbody, LLC is a privately held american company that uses direct response infomercials, e commerce, and individual sales consultants to sell home exercise videos and dietary supplements. Their company was founded in 1998 in Santa Monica, California, and their products include things like p 90 x and insanity.

149
00:15:00,788 --> 00:15:01,964
Kayla: Remember p 90 x?

150
00:15:02,012 --> 00:15:05,564
Chris: I remember p 90 x being advertised on that. That videotape.

151
00:15:05,732 --> 00:15:06,436
Kayla: Oh, yeah.

152
00:15:06,508 --> 00:15:08,740
Chris: Yeah. There's a few others I remember, too, but we'll get to that.

153
00:15:08,780 --> 00:15:14,508
Kayla: I tried p 90 x. It didn't stick. It's not as fun. Tony whatever his name is. Not as scarce.

154
00:15:14,564 --> 00:15:15,212
Chris: No. Shanti?

155
00:15:15,276 --> 00:15:15,716
Kayla: Nope.

156
00:15:15,788 --> 00:15:44,406
Chris: Yeah. Since I spent some time on their website, they have a few more products. I said we would get to that, but we're getting to that right now. Just to list a few morning meltdown 100. Something called. I don't really know how to pronounce this, but it's like the letter l two, capital I's, like, maybe like a roman two or something, and then an f and a t. So it's like lift, but, like lift. It's like lift. And then the number four. So it's like lift four.

157
00:15:44,478 --> 00:15:45,198
Kayla: Lift four.

158
00:15:45,294 --> 00:15:46,070
Chris: Lift four.

159
00:15:46,150 --> 00:15:47,358
Kayla: L two four.

160
00:15:47,534 --> 00:15:54,030
Chris: Oh, maybe it's l two. L two li. I don't know. Anyway, and then do you remember hip hop abs?

161
00:15:54,770 --> 00:16:09,226
Kayla: The best commercials in the world are for hip hop abs, because they keep putting these women in these ugliest outfits to demonstrate how good their abs are now. But also, I wanted to do hip hop abs. I just was not gonna drop money on it.

162
00:16:09,338 --> 00:16:29,508
Chris: And then there was my personal favorite, country heat, which has the ad for that one. The little tile on their website has, like, a sexy lady wearing a plaid crop top and jeans. Very country. You know, this is just a total country girl, you know, just dressed in the costume. Oh, wait, actually, sorry. My personal favorite was Brazil butt lift.

163
00:16:29,644 --> 00:16:32,924
Kayla: Oh, that's them. It's Brazil butt lift. Not brazilian.

164
00:16:33,012 --> 00:16:37,160
Chris: Brazil butt lift, because it has a funny word in the name Lyft.

165
00:16:38,180 --> 00:16:43,908
Kayla: Oh, my God. Get out. Do you know what the main motion in hip hop abs is? Do you want to show you?

166
00:16:44,084 --> 00:16:45,212
Chris: Is it sexual?

167
00:16:45,316 --> 00:16:45,628
Kayla: No.

168
00:16:45,684 --> 00:16:55,070
Chris: It's like, oh, we're doing a podcast. And you're like. Cause you're like, Kayla's convulsing in the studio right now.

169
00:16:55,370 --> 00:17:03,310
Kayla: But that's like, dance like this. You're just basically doing crunches with standing up. And so all the dancing is like this.

170
00:17:04,250 --> 00:17:09,914
Chris: That's possibly worse than the Elaine dance. Oh, my God. Please stop. Please stop.

171
00:17:09,962 --> 00:17:11,114
Kayla: I mean, I'm doing it poorly.

172
00:17:11,162 --> 00:17:12,810
Chris: I'm embarrassed. Well, you're also seated.

173
00:17:12,890 --> 00:17:13,130
Alanda Carter: Yeah.

174
00:17:13,170 --> 00:17:15,506
Kayla: Shanti obviously did a much better job, and that was.

175
00:17:15,538 --> 00:17:17,521
Chris: Wait, did he do hip hop abs, or was it somebody else?

176
00:17:17,586 --> 00:17:19,400
Kayla: I'm pretty sure Shanti was hip hop abs.

177
00:17:19,490 --> 00:17:21,140
Chris: Okay. Because they have, like, a whole.

178
00:17:21,220 --> 00:17:23,236
Kayla: I think he started with hip hop abs, maybe.

179
00:17:23,308 --> 00:17:24,200
Chris: No shit.

180
00:17:24,619 --> 00:17:25,612
Kayla: I could be wrong.

181
00:17:25,756 --> 00:17:30,172
Chris: Anyway, yeah, beachbody. They're a fitness company, allegedly.

182
00:17:30,276 --> 00:17:33,004
Kayla: Oh, that's how they said it at the end of the video. Beach body.

183
00:17:33,132 --> 00:17:33,788
Chris: Beach body.

184
00:17:33,844 --> 00:17:35,080
Kayla: Yeah. Do you remember that now?

185
00:17:35,540 --> 00:17:41,880
Chris: Vaguely. The only thing I remember, really, is hip hop abs. Shawn T. And then you dredged up that memory of tanya.

186
00:17:42,500 --> 00:17:44,320
Kayla: Tanya was very hot.

187
00:17:45,180 --> 00:17:51,418
Chris: Everybody on that video was pretty hot. But I guess tanya did. I mean, I don't know if she was hotter than shanti, but she was.

188
00:17:51,474 --> 00:17:52,578
Kayla: No one's hotter than shanti.

189
00:17:52,634 --> 00:18:07,626
Chris: Maybe nobody in the entire world. Yeah. Anyway, Kayla, since you are a savvy individual who knows things, and let's face it, even if you didn't know this already, you might be able to predict where we're headed, because we're talking about a business on the show today.

190
00:18:07,778 --> 00:18:11,090
Kayla: So either we're talking about how capitalism is a cult, or you're about.

191
00:18:11,170 --> 00:18:11,754
Chris: Not yet.

192
00:18:11,842 --> 00:18:15,934
Kayla: You're about to tell me something very sad and bad about my beloved.

193
00:18:16,122 --> 00:18:20,770
Chris: I've got three letters for you, and they rhyme with bem. Bell bem.

194
00:18:21,270 --> 00:18:23,290
Kayla: I'm trying to figure out something else it could be.

195
00:18:23,710 --> 00:18:26,126
Chris: It's not schlem flell flim.

196
00:18:26,198 --> 00:18:27,662
Kayla: Yes. Is it that?

197
00:18:27,726 --> 00:18:29,810
Chris: It's that. Oh, no.

198
00:18:30,230 --> 00:18:32,302
Kayla: Is shawn t an MLM leader?

199
00:18:32,406 --> 00:18:47,540
Chris: We here on culture, just weird. Are finally about to talk about another multi level marketing company or direct sales, or, as some critics might say, pyramid scheme. But let's not get ahead of ourselves. Did you know that beachbody was an MLM company?

200
00:18:47,620 --> 00:19:24,002
Kayla: I did not know Beachbody was an MLM company. I will say, however, that I think that I could sense some level of bullshit because I never. Something didn't quite smell right because I was very unwilling to ever give them money. Like, we borrowed a friend's insanity. It's like, I'm not gonna spend money on this. I'll do it if I have it. So we, like, borrowed insanity, and we borrowed p 90 x from a friend. And there. Because there was also, like, you could tell that they were trying to sell something because, you know, Shanti would talk about the shakes and the water bottles and the meal plan.

201
00:19:24,066 --> 00:19:27,350
Chris: Did he say what the name of the shake was? Does it have, like, a name?

202
00:19:27,970 --> 00:19:29,482
Kayla: I don't remember. Beachbody.

203
00:19:29,546 --> 00:19:30,602
Chris: We'll get to that.

204
00:19:30,786 --> 00:19:40,270
Kayla: So I feel like I could tell that there was something, not something weird about it, especially because, like, how many different a little sales they had. Yeah, yeah.

205
00:19:40,870 --> 00:19:55,958
Chris: The reason you may not have known that it's an MLM company is because it's not. At least part of it isn't. You did the insanity program just by borrowing a DVD for it. People just buy the DVD's. But, you know, you never went through any sort of, like, sales associate or anything?

206
00:19:56,014 --> 00:19:56,398
Kayla: No.

207
00:19:56,494 --> 00:20:25,386
Chris: And neither did the person that lent us the CD, did he? From my research, a lot of people seem to encounter beachbody products without actually ever realizing that there's an MLM side to it. And to be fair, a good chunk of their business today is just the workout programs. They're pretty big into direct streaming, for example. But another good chunk of their business falls under a separate division with a slightly altered name, and that's Team Beachbody.

208
00:20:25,418 --> 00:20:26,514
Kayla: Oh, I've heard that before.

209
00:20:26,642 --> 00:20:32,250
Chris: Team Beachbody is the arm of their business that uses the MLM business model.

210
00:20:32,330 --> 00:20:34,298
Kayla: It's so weird because, like, they have.

211
00:20:34,314 --> 00:20:35,314
Chris: Two websites and everything.

212
00:20:35,402 --> 00:20:46,474
Kayla: That's so weird. Like, you. The only reason people know Beachbody is like, beachbody is ubiquitous, and it's from like, late night infomercials, you know what I mean?

213
00:20:46,642 --> 00:21:03,554
Chris: In some circles, though, it's very ubiquitous from like, the same way that Doterra or, you know, young living or whatever it is. Like, people see, people get inundated with it from friends on social media the same way they do with other mlms. It's just we don't happen to have a lot of friends that do that kind of stuff.

214
00:21:03,602 --> 00:21:04,248
Kayla: Right.

215
00:21:04,434 --> 00:21:42,810
Chris: But yeah, it is weird. You're right. And it seems like a lot of people do have that as their first exposure to it and then don't realize that there's this whole other thing. In any case, that's the team beachbody is the arm of their business that uses the MLM business model, and it should be a familiar business model to veteran listeners of our show. But here's a quick refresher. In an MLM, you are the, quote, independent business owner, and you're pretty conflated with being, like, a customer. It's not really clear where one ends and the other begins. You sign up, essentially, to be a salesman for this company's products that you like, maybe into yourself, and that may be how you got into it.

216
00:21:43,150 --> 00:22:29,958
Chris: But a lot of your sales commission and bonus comes not just from selling the product itself, but from recruiting others to sell and also recruiting others to themselves, recruit, etcetera, at infinitum. So you recruit, and then they recruit, and that's called your downline, a scam. That's good. And if everyone in that recruiting chain recruits at least two people, although most mlms heavily incentivize much more than that, this is where that pyramidal shape comes from. The chain of folks that recruited you are called your upline. So that's like, whoever said, like, hey, Kayla, you should sell team beachbody. It's a great opportunity. That's your upline. And the chain of folks that you recruit are called your downline. So if you recruit someone and then they recruit somebody else, that's your downline.

217
00:22:30,054 --> 00:22:31,254
Kayla: Who did I recruit?

218
00:22:31,422 --> 00:22:32,374
Chris: Who did you recruit?

219
00:22:32,422 --> 00:22:33,010
Kayla: Yeah.

220
00:22:33,390 --> 00:22:39,414
Chris: Me. I don't know. Nobody. I didn't. You didn't. You weren't selling their product. You never signed up for it.

221
00:22:39,422 --> 00:22:44,406
Kayla: I mean, I definitely joined the insanity Reddit and, like, sang its praises.

222
00:22:44,558 --> 00:22:52,310
Chris: Okay, well, then you were, like, adjacent to the cult. And actually, let's come back to that in a second, because that's apparently, you are not alone.

223
00:22:52,390 --> 00:22:54,078
Kayla: Aw, that's good, I guess.

224
00:22:54,174 --> 00:23:23,536
Chris: Typically, an IBO, which is slang in the industry for independent business owner, are given some clever on brand title by their MLM companies. If you remember, in the case of Mary Kay, it was a beauty consultant. In the case of Team beachbody, you are a coach. And before you ask, nope, you do not need any sort of, like, special standardized training or certification yourself to become a coach and advise other human beings on what is essentially a healthcare value proposition.

225
00:23:23,608 --> 00:23:24,792
Kayla: That sounds good.

226
00:23:24,936 --> 00:23:25,448
Chris: Yeah.

227
00:23:25,544 --> 00:23:27,380
Kayla: That sounds like a good system.

228
00:23:27,680 --> 00:23:36,080
Chris: It's wonderful. But they call you a coach anyway because even though you are essentially a salesperson, they call you a coach.

229
00:23:36,160 --> 00:23:38,020
Kayla: No conflict of interest there.

230
00:23:40,240 --> 00:24:05,952
Chris: Yeah. You don't need to be trained. You just need to be able to sell beachbody's fitness packages. And I know your exposure to Beachbody with Shawn tee's insanity program, you had a really good experience with it, and I think it's important to note that. But, of course, the fitness packages that team beachbody coaches sell include much more than just a dvd. In fact, the biggest part of their business, according to Forbes, their, quote, flagship product is something called shakeology.

231
00:24:06,136 --> 00:24:09,680
Kayla: Oh. Oh, yeah. Oh, I remember that. Yeah, yeah. The shakeology shakes.

232
00:24:09,760 --> 00:24:10,120
Chris: Okay.

233
00:24:10,160 --> 00:24:10,520
Kayla: Yes.

234
00:24:10,600 --> 00:24:22,570
Chris: So that. So their MLM sales stuff was, like, bleached. So I guess, actually, what it is Shanti tried to sell you product that the team beachbody side of the business also tries to sell.

235
00:24:22,650 --> 00:24:27,706
Kayla: Is shawn t an IBO? Does shawn t have an upline and a downline?

236
00:24:27,818 --> 00:24:31,082
Chris: I don't know.

237
00:24:31,146 --> 00:24:39,002
Kayla: Is insanity. The ob Garbo tapes of our universe. That was a. That was a. I don't remember the name of the show. That was a.

238
00:24:39,066 --> 00:24:39,834
Chris: Becoming a God in central Florida.

239
00:24:39,842 --> 00:24:41,830
Kayla: I'm becoming a God in central Florida reference.

240
00:24:43,690 --> 00:24:46,122
Chris: It could be. I don't think he is an ibo.

241
00:24:46,186 --> 00:24:51,242
Kayla: But I'm not sure please don't destroy my life. That's what you're doing right now.

242
00:24:51,346 --> 00:25:15,990
Chris: I don't know. I don't know. By the way, I wanted to take a tangent here. This is totally unintentional that we sort of have this fitness or wellness theme going this season. It did not mean for us to do that. Oh, yeah, did not mean that. My intent wasn't to follow up your intermittent fasting episode with an episode about a fitness MLM. It just sort of happened. I actually intended to do an episode about a different MLM, herbalife.

243
00:25:16,150 --> 00:25:16,958
Kayla: Oh.

244
00:25:17,134 --> 00:25:34,374
Chris: But I switched to team beachbody for reasons that will become apparent here shortly. We'll get to that. That being said, of course, herbalife also makes a tidy penny getting their ibos to sell fitness shakes. So I guess, regardless, it would have been about fitness anyway. I don't know. All this stuff really tends to run together.

245
00:25:34,502 --> 00:25:39,736
Kayla: But wear shakes. You guys, like, literally, shakes can be a red flag.

246
00:25:39,928 --> 00:25:43,296
Chris: Yeah, shakes. That's true. Yeah. Or at least a yellow flag.

247
00:25:43,368 --> 00:25:43,640
Kayla: Yeah.

248
00:25:43,680 --> 00:25:46,368
Chris: Depends on the shake. It's a mango shake. It's a yellow flag.

249
00:25:46,424 --> 00:25:47,060
Kayla: Ew.

250
00:25:47,400 --> 00:25:49,712
Chris: If it's like a strawberry shake.

251
00:25:49,776 --> 00:25:51,260
Kayla: Mango shake.

252
00:25:51,760 --> 00:25:57,176
Chris: Well, you're talking about maybe a smoothie. Yeah, I guess that's different. No, you could totally have a mango flavored shake. Couldn't.

253
00:25:57,208 --> 00:26:01,740
Kayla: I don't want it, though. I love a mango, and I don't want a mango flavored shake. I'm gonna throw up.

254
00:26:03,150 --> 00:26:06,710
Chris: Speaking of products, do you want to see what their product lineup looks like?

255
00:26:06,790 --> 00:26:07,142
Kayla: Yeah.

256
00:26:07,206 --> 00:26:15,214
Chris: And by product lineup, I mean both. Like, how the company makes money on recruiting distributors and also what the distributors themselves are selling.

257
00:26:15,262 --> 00:26:27,694
Kayla: Yeah, I want to see the shakes because I love. I love a shake. That's why shakes are a red flag. If something has a shake, I'm like, ooh, too tasty. Yeah, this is boring. I thought it was gonna be pretty pictures of shakes.

258
00:26:27,742 --> 00:26:34,944
Chris: No, no. Sorry. This is just a list of what they say. I just wanted to show you. We'll link this in the show notes and on our Instagram and everything.

259
00:26:34,992 --> 00:26:40,340
Kayla: I thought you were gonna show me, like, a cool, like a periodic table of their shake products.

260
00:26:40,880 --> 00:27:06,182
Chris: Yeah, no, unfortunately not. So they have you buy a starter kit, which, as of the time of this thing that I'm reading here was dollar 40. It may have changed by now. Has a coach welcome book. It has a 30 day access to your coach online office. Not sure what that means exactly. Personalized coach website support tools. Now, as you can see, they have a monthly coach fee, so that's access to your online office as a.

261
00:27:06,206 --> 00:27:08,662
Kayla: Wait, so this isn't what people pay you? You pay $16.

262
00:27:08,686 --> 00:27:36,922
Chris: That's what the independent business owner has to pay $16 a month for the opportunity to sell their products. And then there's, like, some weekly club fees, and this is all the stuff they want you to sell. Challenge packs fitness program Shakeology boosts three day Refresh Beachbody performance Ultimate Reset Team Beachbody Club trainer men's apparel Dermas. I guess I don't have to read all this stuff, but you can see there's a parallel here. There's supplements on here, gear, coach products, and tools.

263
00:27:37,106 --> 00:27:39,098
Kayla: Isn't that what that. All of that is?

264
00:27:39,234 --> 00:27:39,950
Chris: Yeah.

265
00:27:40,610 --> 00:27:42,042
Kayla: Why is that a separate.

266
00:27:42,186 --> 00:27:59,480
Chris: Because you're selling them to people, like, underneath. So if you recruit a coach, you can sell them coach training tools, even though yourself are also a coach. That's the weirdness of mlms, is that, like, the person under you is selling the same stuff that you are, but you're also.

267
00:27:59,650 --> 00:28:00,172
Kayla: They're code.

268
00:28:00,196 --> 00:28:04,100
Chris: They're sort of like, reporting to you, but not really. It's interesting.

269
00:28:04,220 --> 00:28:07,044
Kayla: You know what? I could go for a shakeology shake right now. I'm not gonna lie.

270
00:28:07,092 --> 00:28:13,228
Chris: I know I kind of want to get a shake after this, but you can see some of the other stats down here. I won't go into this too much because I just wanted to show you the products.

271
00:28:13,404 --> 00:28:16,836
Kayla: Wait, go back, please. Let me read this sentence.

272
00:28:17,028 --> 00:28:27,898
Chris: Hold on. Well, let me contextualize it first below the product list on this article that we will definitely link you guys. KaYla found the income disclosure stuff that this guy is reporting on.

273
00:28:28,004 --> 00:28:32,678
Kayla: Team beachbody is a great way to make less than part time minimum wage.

274
00:28:32,774 --> 00:28:38,118
Chris: I mean, the stats here say 44% of beachbody coaches do not even receive a bonus or commission.

275
00:28:38,214 --> 00:28:39,422
Kayla: That seems low to me.

276
00:28:39,486 --> 00:28:52,382
Chris: 69% make $500 on average per year, and 91% of coaches make $3,400 or less on average per year. And again, this article is a couple years out of date, but I don't think it's changed that much.

277
00:28:52,446 --> 00:28:55,410
Kayla: No, it's an MLM, so we know they don't make money.

278
00:28:55,590 --> 00:29:16,442
Chris: Right. Back to coaches. So, team beachbody mlmers are called coaches. And according to their own executives, the way beachbody decided to get into the multi level marketing gig is that they discovered their customers were actually some of their best advocates. So you remember when you were just talking about how you got all gung ho and obsessed and went on the Reddit and talked about insanity and how great it was.

279
00:29:16,506 --> 00:29:17,490
Kayla: Oh, no.

280
00:29:17,650 --> 00:29:21,364
Chris: So they leaned into that. Don't worry, they already leaned into that before you were doing it.

281
00:29:21,442 --> 00:29:23,856
Kayla: Okay, here's a quote. You're saying, it's not my fault.

282
00:29:23,888 --> 00:29:46,694
Chris: It's not your fault. You were just a participant. Here's a quote from a cosmopolitan article that illustrates this. Back in the pre Facebook early aughts, Deichler, who is the CEO and president of Beachbody, created a virtual gym at the beachbody website called wow Workout with you, where customers doing Beachbody DVD's could befriend each other.

283
00:29:46,792 --> 00:29:47,898
Kayla: Oh, that's really sweet.

284
00:29:47,954 --> 00:30:07,870
Chris: It is. On message boards, one person would say, I started p 90 x and I'm sore. It's only day three. I don't think I can do it anymore. And somebody else would come on and say, you got to push through, man. By the time you get to day 17, you're going to start to feel better. Dichler again. The CEO soon realized that the customers were the best brand ambassadors that we could ask for, end quote.

285
00:30:08,610 --> 00:30:12,314
Kayla: Love to take advantage and exploit your customers.

286
00:30:12,482 --> 00:30:18,862
Chris: But it's pretty savvy too, right? Like, you know, if you have a good product, then, yeah, your customers are pretty good advocates for.

287
00:30:18,986 --> 00:30:19,650
Kayla: Right.

288
00:30:19,950 --> 00:30:24,798
Chris: The problem comes when you push it further than that and try to turn them into something that maybe they shouldn't be.

289
00:30:24,854 --> 00:30:25,470
Kayla: Yeah.

290
00:30:25,630 --> 00:30:28,450
Chris: By the way, you want to know the title of that Cosmo article?

291
00:30:29,110 --> 00:30:32,030
Kayla: Mlms are a cult. The cult of team beachbody.

292
00:30:32,110 --> 00:30:35,870
Chris: This cultish workout is all over your social media feeds. But is it legit?

293
00:30:36,030 --> 00:30:42,182
Kayla: What? Which workout was it specifically talking about? Do you know? Was it p 90 x? I bet it was p 90 x there.

294
00:30:42,366 --> 00:30:47,184
Chris: It was a few different ones there. Oh, for that one. Yeah, it was p 90 x. Yeah, p 90 x. It was p 90 x. I feel.

295
00:30:47,192 --> 00:30:52,776
Kayla: Like p 90 x was even more culty than insanity. Like, remember how, like, Paul Ryan made it?

296
00:30:52,888 --> 00:30:53,424
Chris: Oh, yeah.

297
00:30:53,472 --> 00:30:55,392
Kayla: People were like, Paul Ryan is p 90.

298
00:30:55,536 --> 00:31:04,860
Chris: I read about that, how he was like, a bunch of people picked it up after he said that. Yeah. But, yeah, I like that the cosmopolitan used the c word there, so that's cool.

299
00:31:05,280 --> 00:31:07,296
Kayla: They said cunt, right?

300
00:31:07,328 --> 00:31:10,696
Chris: That's the word I meant, yeah. Good.

301
00:31:10,768 --> 00:31:11,256
Kayla: Sorry.

302
00:31:11,368 --> 00:31:25,136
Chris: Thanks, kayla. That's the k word. But I think also this quote is best appreciated next to another one from that Forbes article I was mentioning earlier, which was entitled, Inside Beachbody's billion dollar fat Burning Empire.

303
00:31:25,248 --> 00:31:26,256
Kayla: Billion with a b.

304
00:31:26,288 --> 00:31:58,244
Chris: That's billion with a b. That's right. Here is the quote. As co founder and CEO, of Beachbody, Carl Dieckler is at the top of a modern day, multi level marketing machine with more than 340,000 independent coaches, by the way, that's in quotes, who sell workout videos, shakes, and supplements to weight loss hopefuls via social media. The playbook goes something like, lose weight with Beachbody by doing the at home workouts and drinking the shakes. Share it on social media. Use your story to sell products and recruit new customers and coaches.

305
00:31:58,332 --> 00:32:07,786
Kayla: Repeat, end quote, 340,000. Yeah, that's an. It's insane.

306
00:32:07,978 --> 00:32:13,466
Chris: It's. But again, it's. That's not the company, though, right? I know, but the coaches, that's the whole thing.

307
00:32:13,498 --> 00:32:14,858
Kayla: That's what I'm saying.

308
00:32:15,034 --> 00:32:27,162
Chris: Remember that the numbers were similar with Mary Kay, I think was even more insane. Yeah, that's the thing. Like, you could never, if you think about, like, a normal company supporting that many salesmen for their product.

309
00:32:27,266 --> 00:32:27,698
Kayla: Can't.

310
00:32:27,754 --> 00:32:30,090
Chris: There's no way. No, it's impossible.

311
00:32:30,170 --> 00:32:31,190
Kayla: Oh, my God.

312
00:32:32,070 --> 00:33:21,430
Chris: Anyway, so I really feel like, taken together, that these two excerpts really paint a good picture in my mind of how team beachbody does business. And, man, is it. It's just right in line with how other MLM companies function, too. You take a person, someone who's motivated, loves your product, and rather than just make them a customer or customer advocate or whatever, you make them a salesman. You dangle that carrot of the american dream in front of them. Be your own boss, make your own hours, blah. You've heard all this before, and voila. This person is now part of your cult. Sorry, scheme. Sorry, downline. Pretty soon, you, the company, are taking advantage of all the social capital this newly recruited team beachbody coach has built up over the years, squeezing that valuable social network dry. Discard the human husk and move on.

313
00:33:21,810 --> 00:33:24,108
Kayla: That is very.

314
00:33:24,164 --> 00:34:04,050
Chris: MLM is fucked. But again, I have to highlight here, the name coach is extremely misleading. The word coach carries a lot of contextual weight. That doesn't apply at all in this case. I mean, it does in some cases. Like, I don't want to, like, speak for anybody that's an actual coach. That is also being a beachbody coach. But it doesn't necessarily apply in this case. You don't have to have any experience or education in athletics or physical training to become a team beachbody coach. You just need to buy their starter kit and sign on the dotted line. In this respect, it feels like maybe more disingenuous to me than many or most MLM consultant titles. For example, like going back to Mary Kay's beauty consultant title.

315
00:34:04,090 --> 00:34:18,985
Chris: Like, at least that's not implying something that it isn't like they're not being called certified esthetician or something. They're just saying, I'm gonna help you look beautiful. At least they're doing that. Whereas this is. I don't know, the word coach just carries a lot of contextual weight with it.

316
00:34:19,018 --> 00:34:31,538
Kayla: The nutritionist thing where it's like, nutritionist sounds like there's training involved. There's certification, there's education, there's weight behind it, when really there's no weight behind it in this context.

317
00:34:31,634 --> 00:34:39,034
Chris: And if I hire a coach, if I have somebody that's coaching me, my expectation is that they have some qualifications to be a coach.

318
00:34:39,081 --> 00:34:40,914
Kayla: You're not going after a rando to coach you.

319
00:34:41,002 --> 00:35:13,820
Chris: Yeah. In any case, Team Beach Buddy has the exact same swirling wake of poop around it that most mlms do. Same sort of like complaints, criticisms, a whole ecosystem of discouraged ex ibos. They have the same issue with only a tiny fraction of their sales force actually able to make a profit, which we talked about just a second ago when were looking at that blog post. They also have customer complaints filed with the Better Business Bureau, although I wasn't able to determine if they, like, had more complaints than your average business of that size or not.

320
00:35:13,860 --> 00:35:14,372
Kayla: Right.

321
00:35:14,516 --> 00:35:25,624
Chris: Just that they do. Oh, and the other hilarious thing that they have going on that a lot of mlms do is the obtuse, labyrinthine, insane compensation structure.

322
00:35:25,672 --> 00:35:26,488
Kayla: Oh, God.

323
00:35:26,624 --> 00:35:28,208
Chris: You want to take a look at it real quick?

324
00:35:28,304 --> 00:35:30,368
Kayla: You're at yellow triangle level.

325
00:35:30,504 --> 00:35:31,900
Chris: Let's take a look at it.

326
00:35:32,240 --> 00:35:34,048
Kayla: No, please. I'm already stressed out.

327
00:35:34,104 --> 00:35:34,536
Chris: Highlights.

328
00:35:34,568 --> 00:35:36,912
Kayla: I'm already stressed out. Also. Are you going to talk about their logo at all?

329
00:35:36,976 --> 00:35:39,560
Chris: Definitely, yeah. Their logo is a little.

330
00:35:39,600 --> 00:35:41,406
Kayla: Well, I mean, it's a bdez.

331
00:35:41,508 --> 00:35:45,066
Chris: Yeah. And it's. But it. Oh, I never noticed that. It was a bee and a wave.

332
00:35:45,138 --> 00:35:45,790
Kayla: Yeah.

333
00:35:46,090 --> 00:35:50,186
Chris: Oh, that's clever. I like it. I like their logo.

334
00:35:50,218 --> 00:35:51,762
Kayla: It's also hot tits.

335
00:35:51,906 --> 00:35:53,910
Chris: I don't think that those are hot.

336
00:35:54,890 --> 00:35:58,418
Kayla: No, it's. If you're looking at it, like, from the.

337
00:35:58,434 --> 00:35:59,810
Chris: So, like, kind of at angle.

338
00:35:59,850 --> 00:36:02,162
Kayla: And they're, like, resting, like in water.

339
00:36:02,266 --> 00:36:05,110
Chris: Are we keeping this part. Oh, Jesus Christ.

340
00:36:05,690 --> 00:36:08,802
Kayla: I mean, like, water gently up over the tits. Sorry.

341
00:36:08,866 --> 00:36:24,442
Chris: Look, logos tend to evoke a sense of cultiness that'll probably come up, like in our. Is capitalism a cult episode that we're never gonna do. But I don't think they're any more culty than any other company's logo. In any case, I hate this.

342
00:36:24,506 --> 00:36:25,378
Kayla: I hate looking at this.

343
00:36:25,394 --> 00:36:42,126
Chris: We will definitely link you guys. This compensation plan highlights. And this is from them, right? Obviously, it has their logo. It's from them. But I don't even, like. I can't even really explain it. But diamond coach, there's this whole thing. So there's like. I'm just trying to explain what we have here.

344
00:36:42,238 --> 00:36:43,814
Kayla: Right leg, left leg.

345
00:36:43,942 --> 00:36:58,238
Chris: There are dots and they are connected. It's clearly. It's even set up in a pyramid shape. So there's u. Then there's your left leg and your right leg, which I think refers to, like, different halves of your downline.

346
00:36:58,334 --> 00:37:01,250
Kayla: Well, strong leg, weak leg.

347
00:37:01,750 --> 00:37:30,530
Chris: But don't forget that one cycle equals 300 balanced volume points. And that means 200 strong leg, 100 weak leg. Does that make sense? Do you get that? Team cycle bonus earn from the sales of your entire downline organization, parentheses, binary plan cycle. Whenever you have 300 balance volume points, earn between 14 and 18 bonus points each cycle, and up to 12,000 bonus points each week, depending on rank.

348
00:37:32,900 --> 00:37:47,760
Kayla: Here's my question. Whose job is it to do this part? Because it's like, this is literally like time cube. This is the ravings of an unwell person.

349
00:37:48,060 --> 00:37:49,452
Chris: We'll get to that.

350
00:37:49,636 --> 00:37:54,612
Kayla: Is Team beach body just a figment of my psychotic break?

351
00:37:54,756 --> 00:37:57,836
Chris: No, but I almost guarantee that they didn't come up with that.

352
00:37:58,028 --> 00:38:01,686
Kayla: Oh, that's ominous.

353
00:38:01,838 --> 00:38:11,422
Chris: Yeah, I did some research, y'all, and they actually also have, like, a whole training program just dedicated to explaining their compensation plan to red flag.

354
00:38:11,526 --> 00:38:13,690
Kayla: That's the biggest red flag I've ever heard.

355
00:38:14,110 --> 00:38:31,530
Chris: But, yeah, we will definitely post this stuff on our socials after the show. That's cult or just weird on Twitter and then on instagram, it's cult or just weirdos. We'll definitely post the comp plan. Anyway. That's your quick primer on Team beachbody. It is the MLM arm of the beachbody empire. Do you have any questions?

356
00:38:32,230 --> 00:38:33,678
Kayla: Yes, all of them.

357
00:38:33,814 --> 00:38:45,158
Chris: Okay, hold then, because I still have questions, too. And you know, how we do here on cult are just weird. When we have questions, we like to go seek out experts and expand our knowledge.

358
00:38:45,214 --> 00:38:46,062
Kayla: Oh, shit.

359
00:38:46,166 --> 00:39:12,470
Chris: So I did just that. I got in touch with one of the Facebook groups that we got involved with a little bit after the Mary Kay episode. It's called the anti MLM Coalition, and they're a great resource generally, but in this case, their moderators were actually able to hook us up with a youtuber whose channel is all about mlms. And she is an ex team beachbody coach, so. Remember before when I said I had planned on doing Herbalife for this episode, but then I changed course? Yeah, that's why.

360
00:39:12,550 --> 00:39:17,230
Kayla: Okay, well, that's, like, the most credentialed person ever. I'm so excited.

361
00:39:17,310 --> 00:39:23,250
Chris: So, her name is Alonda Carter, and her YouTube channel is called the recovering Hunbotan. You excited?

362
00:39:23,750 --> 00:39:24,570
Kayla: Yes.

363
00:39:24,910 --> 00:39:34,090
Chris: Let's do this. Thank you so much for joining us.

364
00:39:34,470 --> 00:39:35,650
Alanda Carter: My pleasure.

365
00:39:36,310 --> 00:39:37,610
Kayla: How are you guys doing?

366
00:39:38,230 --> 00:39:39,090
Alanda Carter: You, too?

367
00:39:39,430 --> 00:39:46,610
Chris: Hanging in there, staying safe and sane and in our houses and as sane as possible anyway, right?

368
00:39:47,030 --> 00:39:49,250
Alanda Carter: Social distancing, all that stuff.

369
00:39:49,690 --> 00:39:51,230
Chris: Yeah. How about yourself?

370
00:39:52,050 --> 00:40:05,610
Alanda Carter: Yeah, pretty much the same thing. I think the excitement of our day is walking the dogs and doing the bear hunt. I always see the same bears, but I pretend like I see them for the first time each and every time I go out.

371
00:40:05,770 --> 00:40:08,394
Chris: Yeah, that's cool that you guys do the bear hunt. That's awesome.

372
00:40:08,522 --> 00:40:14,070
Kayla: Our neighborhood tried to do that, and I don't think it really took, but I love that it's actually happening elsewhere.

373
00:40:14,410 --> 00:40:20,720
Alanda Carter: There's a couple of houses that have, like, a bazillion bears, and then there's. The rest of them is, like, not a damn bear to be seen.

374
00:40:22,980 --> 00:40:35,372
Chris: Well, it makes the hunt easy, I guess, right? If they're all in one place. Okay, so if you're ready to go ahead and get started, if you can tell us who you are and a little bit about yourself and your background to just kind of set the table for our audience.

375
00:40:35,556 --> 00:41:25,378
Alanda Carter: Okay. My name is Alonda Carter. I'm also known as the recovering hunbot on YouTube. And my background, I am a former beachbody hun botanical, hence the name recovering Hunbut. I live in Houston, married, have two dogs, two stepsons, and, you know, I never really thought about joining an MLM. I don't think most people do. But I had gone through breast cancer, and then I was subsequently laid off the day that I went back, and were also moving. And at that point, I was like, you know what? I really don't like this corporate thing. I don't like how I was treated, because my manager treated me horribly when I was going through all of that. And so I was at a very vulnerable state, and I met someone who was my neighbor, lived on the same floor as me. We. And she.

376
00:41:25,474 --> 00:41:31,630
Alanda Carter: She seemed very successful. So I thought, you know what? If she can do what I can, and I was wrong.

377
00:41:34,930 --> 00:41:37,830
Kayla: Feels like it usually works out that way.

378
00:41:38,570 --> 00:42:09,780
Alanda Carter: What I know, like, looking back, it's like, I don't think she was ever truthful. And that's the whole thing is I thought she was. You know, I honestly, I thought she was. And so I just trusted. I never looked up anything. I didn't do anything. I just trusted. And I. One that does a ton of research, right. I have two different advanced degrees, so it's like I know how to find stuff and look it up. But this, no, I didn't. There you go. So ask away.

379
00:42:09,940 --> 00:42:30,916
Kayla: So insidious. It's so insidious. Speaking of your YouTube channel name, you mentioned it, recovering hunbot. Something that we haven't really talked about on the show yet is how there's this whole, like, shared vocabulary in the anti MLM movement, so our listeners might not know what a hun or a hunbot is. Would you mind sharing the significance of your YouTube?

380
00:42:31,028 --> 00:43:02,940
Alanda Carter: I will be happy to. Okay. Yeah. I didn't know what it was either. Typically when you join an MLM, because you're going to be showing to your family and friends and you're going to be trying to make friends on social media, and your listeners may have received a message that says, hey, girl, hey, hon. Something like that. So there's the Hun. And because you're copying and pasting everything, there's the robotic nature. So hun, bot. So you are just. That's where that comes from.

381
00:43:03,810 --> 00:43:19,330
Chris: So I had heard the Hun part. I hadn't heard the bot part. I hadn't heard about that. That makes sense. You know, actually, the first time I saw that word, I was like, are they. Because it's all over. Like the anti MLM Facebook group and a few other Facebook groups I belong to and Reddit.

382
00:43:19,410 --> 00:43:20,506
Kayla: And that's where I've seen it.

383
00:43:20,578 --> 00:43:30,146
Chris: Yeah, yeah. On the Reddit and the Subreddit. And at first when I saw it, I thought it was like Attila the Hun. Until I read into it, I was like, man, that's harsh, but fair.

384
00:43:30,258 --> 00:43:30,990
Alanda Carter: Maybe.

385
00:43:31,650 --> 00:43:42,230
Chris: So, first question about our Topic du Jour about beachbody. Why is there a beachbody and also a Team beachbody? What is the difference there?

386
00:43:43,130 --> 00:44:31,898
Alanda Carter: The company started out as Beachbody. And if you go back in the day and maybe you guys saw some of the Infomercials, I think they still run them for, like, Insanity Pio, just, you know, different programs that they have. And so people were getting the cds and all of that, and they had Message boards. And so people were going There and supporting each other and helping each other. That is not MLM. And then they created Team beachbody. Because they wanted to help people, help other people. Because shouldn't these people be making money since they're already helping people? I mean, that's the spiel that they give you. What they don't tell you, and that I will tell you, is that Beachbody is a client of a company called the Sheffield Group. The Sheffield group will teach you how to create an MLM.

387
00:44:32,074 --> 00:44:36,830
Chris: What? Oh, I need to add some interview questions here. Hang on.

388
00:44:37,330 --> 00:44:38,210
Kayla: It's terrifying.

389
00:44:38,250 --> 00:44:39,750
Chris: Tell me a little bit more about that.

390
00:44:41,850 --> 00:44:57,050
Alanda Carter: I did a whole video on that one, too. Yeah, you can go to a conference and learn how to do it. And one of the things that they teach you is how to recruit people who know how to recruit people so that you can build your business quickly.

391
00:44:57,990 --> 00:45:05,126
Chris: Oh, my gosh. I'm so glad that we talked to you because I had not run across the Sheffield group thing in my research yet. That is okay.

392
00:45:05,198 --> 00:45:06,454
Kayla: Like, talk about insidious.

393
00:45:06,542 --> 00:45:09,134
Chris: It's very interesting.

394
00:45:09,302 --> 00:45:35,764
Alanda Carter: It works. I don't remember all the different companies, but, you know, beachbody is. There's a lot of. Now, not every MLM is one of their clients, but a lot are. And so hence, you know, they have, like, basically done for you MLM. Just, you know, here's the different modules you can purchase, but a boom, bada bing. And you can also attend our conference where we're going to teach you about all kinds of stuff. Sound familiar? You know?

395
00:45:35,932 --> 00:45:39,680
Chris: I know, right? It's like. It's, like, meta. That's so weird. Oh, my God.

396
00:45:40,380 --> 00:46:32,486
Alanda Carter: Wow. So this is how beachbody and team beachbody work because there also used to beachbody live, which just shut down in March. Beachbody live was when you got certified to teach some of the beachbody programs, like Pio insanity. I was certified in country heat and in size. But, you know, I have theories as to why that doesn't exist anymore, but that. I will digress from this question. So there was that branch. Now, what happens is, because when you're a coach, you join through team Beachbody and you have a coach. That's just what you're called. That's just their word for your distributor. And people get their panties in a twist over the word coach. They get really twisted about that because they think of, you know, personal trainers and all of this. It's just like with Lularoe. It's retailer with unique. It's presenter. It's nothing.

397
00:46:32,678 --> 00:47:26,870
Alanda Carter: It's, you know, it's a fancy word. So anyway, what happens is that as you, I'm using my air quotes move up. In the team beachbody ranking system, you can get leads. Well, where do you get those leads from? Well, there's people that go to Beachbody.com and buy products. And when they do that, they're assigned a coach from Team Beachbody. Only if you're at a certain rank, and then that coach can contact them. They don't get a commission off of their initial sale, but if they buy anything else after that, they will get a commission. So the two are kind of like married, but Beachbody itself is not MLM. Team Beachbody is. And then there's also beachbody on demand, which is a streaming service, but they have another one called open fit, which is not MLM that competes against beachbody on demand.

398
00:47:27,170 --> 00:47:28,226
Chris: It's like a maze.

399
00:47:28,298 --> 00:47:42,270
Kayla: Yeah. This is like. It is convoluted and complex. Our next question was kind of like, how did you first get into beachbody? And you kind of touched on that. So do you mind expanding a little bit more on that? Like, what was it like to be recruited to coach?

400
00:47:42,990 --> 00:47:43,662
Alanda Carter: Sure. Okay.

401
00:47:43,686 --> 00:47:43,894
Chris: I.

402
00:47:43,942 --> 00:48:19,928
Alanda Carter: You know what's so funny is she never really was, like, hard on recruiting. Like, I never felt like I was being recruited now to also set the stage. My husband is a Somalia, so we always, you know, have some kind of nice wine at home. And since she lived on the same floor as me, she'd come over, so we would just, like, you know, chit chat, and it was all about drinking the wine, and we would just talk about stuff. And I think. And she would, like, go with me to take the dogs out, and we take them to the little dog park. And then one day, just randomly, because I remembered, she said she was a beachbody coach.

403
00:48:19,984 --> 00:48:48,370
Alanda Carter: I hit up Google, and then I had questions about products, and I asked her about it, and he just gave me some information, so I just ordered something. And then I kept thinking, you know, she says she's making six figures at this. Oh, and she's, you know, she's always in yoga pants and stuff and working from home. And because of what my husband does, I want to have freedom to be able to go anywhere at any time. Like when he goes to a vineyard, I don't want to have to sit at home.

404
00:48:48,490 --> 00:48:48,842
Kayla: Right.

405
00:48:48,906 --> 00:49:15,150
Alanda Carter: So this sounds good. So I was just like, okay, I, you know, I'll just join up underneath you. And that's how I got involved, literally. No, she didn't do anything other than, you know, she would answer questions that I would ask on occasion. What it was like. What it was like I was then thrown into some groups and she didn't do anything with me. It was basically, you're on your own.

406
00:49:15,970 --> 00:49:20,390
Kayla: Is that typical or was that just this, just the way that she operated?

407
00:49:22,450 --> 00:50:02,420
Alanda Carter: It depends. It depends on who you with. But I will say this, one of the things I think this goes across all mlms, is that if it appears as if you're successful, meaning you're able to rank up quickly, you know, you, like, you reach that first level, then, you know, they're love bombing you and thinking, oh, everything's, you know, fabulous. And so you get, you know, further indoctrinated into all of this and then they will help you. But if you're not getting any traction, you know, you're upline, they're not going to do anything because she ended up leaving for direct sellers, which was a wine MLM. And you can imagine how many people tried to recruit me for that.

408
00:50:02,540 --> 00:50:03,036
Kayla: Sure.

409
00:50:03,148 --> 00:50:03,564
Chris: Right.

410
00:50:03,652 --> 00:50:04,280
Kayla: Sure.

411
00:50:05,820 --> 00:50:53,680
Alanda Carter: And then I moved up underneath who was her coach, and her coach was basically the person at the tippy tippy top of everything, who was nice to me, had a call with me. If I would, if I would reach out to her, you know, she would answer something. But the thing is, I had been in it for so long on my own, meaning I'm going all over the Internet trying to find things, I'm buying different things, trying to crack the MLM nut, right? And not having success and wondering, what am I doing wrong? So that, what, because I'm just the kind of person, like, I'm going to take the ball and run with it. I'm going to figure this out. And so by the time moved up underneath this person who is, you know, successful and has a massive team, I knew the basics.

412
00:50:53,720 --> 00:51:37,180
Alanda Carter: The basics hadn't changed and I'm going, but I'm doing all of these things. So I did something like, I joined, well, initially I joined ubly. Nobody should ever do that because that was like $4,000 down the drain, put on the credit card. Yeah, that's just one thing. I joined social team builders and at the time they were targeting just beachbody coaches. So I thought, oh, well, they'll be able to teach me how to do this. And so that's why I created a Facebook page and then paid for ads to get likes and then I was to market to those people. But you have to realize, and I didn't at this time, you're competing against all these other people depending on how you do your targeting of the ads. But if you don't have a big budget on ads.

413
00:51:37,340 --> 00:51:58,634
Alanda Carter: You're just one in a million people trying to do that because it really depends on some of that stuff, too. So did I. Some things, yes. Did it work? Absolutely not. Because the stack is set up against you to begin with, but you think you're moving forward because you're taking action, because you're thinking you're learning systems that are actually going to work and then they don't.

414
00:51:58,802 --> 00:52:19,038
Chris: Right. It's really interesting. I don't have a question about this, but you just sort of prompted one from me here, is that it sounds like there's this whole little, like, or maybe big ecosystem around helping MLM distributors buy their trade. Like, I forget what that you said. Social, what was it called? Social network. Social net.

415
00:52:19,134 --> 00:52:21,166
Alanda Carter: Social team. Social team builders.

416
00:52:21,278 --> 00:52:23,690
Chris: Got it. So can you tell me about that just a little bit?

417
00:52:24,470 --> 00:53:05,590
Alanda Carter: I can tell you about what that ecosystem is like, because what happens is when some people who are, like, successful or they had somewhat of success, they will start doing their own coaching thing. John and Nadia Melton, I was in their group for a while, like, following their system and all of this. Ray Higdon is another one, Fraser Brooks isn't. There's a ton of them, but there's all these people that have systems that are going to lead you to reach success. But the thing is, those systems really are to put money in their pocket. And the problem that I really have, because my background, I hadn't told you this, one of my degrees is instructional design. So that means design and develop training.

418
00:53:05,710 --> 00:53:38,740
Alanda Carter: And so when I would take their courses, I know how to put together a well constructed course because of my background. And I'm like, I'm just seeing holes all over the place. So they teach you something that's very surface, and that's basically it. So it's a, that's a little bit about, like, there's a bunch of people. I mean, I cannot tell you all the different things, probably because I don't remember them all, but I tried to join and, you know, I did join, not just try to join, I joined and kept thinking, if I just learned the right things from the right person.

419
00:53:39,080 --> 00:53:42,092
Kayla: Right, this is all gonna work, right.

420
00:53:42,116 --> 00:53:45,964
Alanda Carter: Because they tell you that I spent thousands of dollars, right.

421
00:53:46,092 --> 00:53:59,148
Chris: And they tell you that if you don't, if you're not successful, then it's your own fault. So therefore, I just need to find the right information. Yeah, that's really interesting. Side note, do you have, you happen to have watched becoming a God in central Florida show?

422
00:53:59,324 --> 00:53:59,956
Alanda Carter: Oh, yeah.

423
00:54:00,028 --> 00:54:03,600
Chris: Oh, yeah. Because you just reminded me of the Garbo system.

424
00:54:04,420 --> 00:54:13,506
Alanda Carter: Oh, yeah. Oh, that's. All of that is so on target now. That, to me, really looks like it's a take off of the Amway tool scam. Have you heard about that?

425
00:54:13,658 --> 00:54:14,866
Chris: The tool scam?

426
00:54:15,018 --> 00:54:16,522
Alanda Carter: The Amway tools scam?

427
00:54:16,666 --> 00:54:20,350
Kayla: No, we've heard about Amway, but I don't know if we've heard about that specifically.

428
00:54:20,810 --> 00:54:53,282
Alanda Carter: Okay. Not most mlms do. Not this. But I'm going to tell you about another one that does. That's kind of a take off of the amway thing. So. And this goes back into, like, the seventies. So what happened was at the time, like, in the sixties and seventies, there was a lot of personal development. That's why you see mlms infused with that type of stuff, you know, becoming the best person you can be. Well, the Amway distributors were like, huh, I can make me some money selling some books now. Okay. Like, have you ever heard of Esther Hicks?

429
00:54:53,426 --> 00:54:53,818
Kayla: Yes.

430
00:54:53,874 --> 00:54:54,746
Alanda Carter: Abraham Hicks.

431
00:54:54,818 --> 00:54:55,210
Kayla: Yeah.

432
00:54:55,290 --> 00:55:00,026
Alanda Carter: Okay. Her husband Jerry, was an Amway distributor.

433
00:55:00,178 --> 00:55:02,578
Kayla: Oh, of course.

434
00:55:02,754 --> 00:55:03,258
Chris: Right.

435
00:55:03,354 --> 00:55:07,756
Alanda Carter: Okay. I did a video on that, too. Does that all kind of like, go click, click, click.

436
00:55:07,858 --> 00:55:08,144
Kayla: Right.

437
00:55:08,192 --> 00:55:52,312
Alanda Carter: Because you know what? Mlm people aren't, too the log of attraction on all of that, you know, and then you just have to reset your mind. But anyway, and Jerry was going around doing some of these presentations, and, you know, he had risen to, like, the highest level that you could in Amway. So this was a thing before the FTC came down on Amway and was like, put the kibosh on that, and then people broke away. And now you have things like worldwide dream builders, where you join worldwide dream builders, which is its own company, but they don't tell you that what you're going to do is then join Amway. So you can sell that. But there's another one. And magic. And magic is a water filtration. MLM started in Japan.

438
00:55:52,496 --> 00:55:53,256
Kayla: Oh, my God.

439
00:55:53,328 --> 00:55:57,896
Alanda Carter: Yes. It's a $5,000 water filtration system.

440
00:55:58,048 --> 00:55:59,460
Chris: Holy shit.

441
00:56:00,190 --> 00:56:45,456
Alanda Carter: Yes, exactly. I have a playlist on them, and then I broke down all of their training. I showed how the entire scam that they're doing, how it goes, and they've come after me, so nobody come after me. Nobody come after me. But I've gone through them. The ace initiative, the breakaway movement. There's a CEO movement, but all of these, like, higher tier funds, they all have their own kind of training thing and their own thing that they get people to come in that way to make money. But the end goal is to get them to buy a $5,000 water filtration system so that they can then sell that, too. And the affiliate opportunity that they came in with. I know this is not spotty, but it's all part of it.

442
00:56:45,488 --> 00:56:46,160
Chris: It's mind blowing.

443
00:56:46,200 --> 00:56:48,096
Kayla: Yeah. It's all connected.

444
00:56:48,288 --> 00:57:00,130
Chris: Yeah. I do want to ask, on the beachbody front, you talked a little bit about how you got in and what it was like. What was it like to leave? Like, what finally got you to say, this is, I'm done.

445
00:57:00,710 --> 00:57:40,770
Alanda Carter: God, okay. I'm so embarrassed to talk about this. Okay. So when I had joined social team builders, and I'm still friends with a good, with somebody that I met in there, and we talk very frequently and trying to crack the nut, and she had joined before me and she had made it to the right. She couldn't hold it, just like I couldn't hold my first rank, which was emerald. We were both like, you know what? We've learned a lot about social media. Maybe we could be social media coaches. And so I started along that path, but also because I was connecting with some people that were kind of like the spiritual law of attraction coaches, I started infusing some of that, too.

446
00:57:41,630 --> 00:58:21,100
Alanda Carter: Well during all of this, eventually I started because I had been doing some independent contract work as an instructional designer, and that shut down. Like, suddenly. I mean, this has happened to me ever since, like, the cancer thing. It's like nothing has been really stable in that front. And as I was doing that, I'm like, huh? I just, you know, I just, things were feeling weird and I thought, you know what? I can teach people how to make courses because I'm having fake gurus come at me wanting me to create courses for them. And it's not. No, it's hell no, because I'm not doing that. And if I did, they wouldn't pay me for what it would cost for me to do all of that.

447
00:58:21,520 --> 00:58:22,168
Chris: Right, right.

448
00:58:22,224 --> 00:58:25,256
Alanda Carter: And I was watching a lot more YouTube.

449
00:58:25,408 --> 00:58:25,768
Kayla: Sure.

450
00:58:25,824 --> 00:59:19,256
Alanda Carter: And I want to say probably another XYz. I think he probably came into my bubble, and that's where he was taking posts from Reddit and talking about the Huns. And I started seeing what people were thinking about what I used to, and that's when I realized what I had been. Meanwhile, I'm still paying my coaching fee. I'm not getting my monthly shipment of shakeology because we couldn't afford that anymore. And I just kind of went, huh. And because of my nature, that now that I had been away from all of the people that I had surrounded myself with. I started researching about multilevel marketing, and my nature is I want to understand things, and I want to understand why people are doing things. So I wanted to know the psychology behind it, all of this type of stuff. And so I started finding names.

451
00:59:19,288 --> 00:59:29,824
Alanda Carter: Who had. I have found Doug. I found Robert Fitzpatrick, David Brehr. Connected with all of them because I wanted to get, like, people on my side, so to speak, that I can go to and ask questions.

452
00:59:29,912 --> 00:59:30,280
Kayla: Sure.

453
00:59:30,360 --> 00:59:37,572
Alanda Carter: That weren't just, like, people on YouTube, not saying, people on YouTube don't know anything, but I wanted to talk to, you know, boots on the ground, people who had been in it.

454
00:59:37,676 --> 00:59:38,276
Kayla: Right.

455
00:59:38,428 --> 00:59:57,100
Alanda Carter: And so I did. I did. And I started realizing, oh, my gosh, I've got to untangle this, but I've also got to share my story, but I also can't support this, even if it's just paying my coaching fee. So I just, like, canceled it, and nobody said a word to me. Now, here's the thing. I'm still in a lot of the beachbody groups.

456
00:59:57,220 --> 00:59:57,880
Kayla: Sure.

457
00:59:58,900 --> 01:00:06,566
Alanda Carter: And that's where I get some of my content, because it's insider information. Right. I just. I quietly grab things.

458
01:00:06,678 --> 01:00:07,886
Kayla: Secret agent.

459
01:00:08,078 --> 01:00:08,686
Chris: Yeah.

460
01:00:08,798 --> 01:00:15,326
Alanda Carter: You know, but literally, I. So I didn't have that repercussion that some people do where they're treated like crap.

461
01:00:15,438 --> 01:00:16,166
Kayla: Right.

462
01:00:16,358 --> 01:00:24,654
Alanda Carter: I just kind of. But. But I am dealing with the psychological aftermath of all of that. Because you are traumatized by all that. You don't know it.

463
01:00:24,782 --> 01:00:25,070
Kayla: Right.

464
01:00:25,110 --> 01:00:30,260
Alanda Carter: You don't know you're being traumatized. And yesterday when I was talking to somebody, it's like you're mentally raped.

465
01:00:30,420 --> 01:00:30,932
Kayla: Right.

466
01:00:31,036 --> 01:00:34,148
Alanda Carter: That's the best way I can put it, because you are.

467
01:00:34,324 --> 01:00:34,804
Kayla: Right.

468
01:00:34,892 --> 01:00:40,796
Alanda Carter: And then it's like, how do you put yourself back together? That's kind of the long story of all that.

469
01:00:40,948 --> 01:00:49,400
Kayla: Are there resources for anyone who's coming out of these mlms and feeling that way that you know of? Or is that kind of like a blind spot we have?

470
01:00:49,940 --> 01:01:37,304
Alanda Carter: It's a huge blind spot. There's not really. I really think that there is a psychological disorder that, you know, people could be labeled with because of the damage that mlms do to you. Let me see. What's his name? Because I interviewed him. Because there's. Because they were our members of the International Cultic Association Institute, or I can't remember what it's called exactly, but Stephen Hassen is a member of it. And this guy that I interviewed, Doug, and I can't think of his last name. His wife is Wendy. They were both in cults themselves, religious cults. And so he's familiar with basically what it's like to be in a cult since he was in it. And he does, you know, counsel for that. But there's very few people that counsel for cults.

471
01:01:37,432 --> 01:02:20,046
Alanda Carter: There's no one that I know of that counsels people about how to recover from multilevel marketing. And that is something desperately needed, because right now, what I see is what I would classify as a lot of revenge of people attacking people who are currently in multilevel marketing and exposing them by showing their faces, going and sending them DM's, going on their social media and be like, that's a pyramid scheme. It is. Like, that is not going to do any good. That's just going to, that cognitive dissonance that's going to reinforce what their belief system is for the emblem, and they're going to dig their heels in more and go harder at it.

472
01:02:20,198 --> 01:02:31,134
Alanda Carter: And I always say you've got to come at it from a place of, you know, a soft spot, love and kindness, as opposed to aggression and attacking, because no one likes that. Right. Right.

473
01:02:31,182 --> 01:02:32,134
Kayla: Yeah. Like you said, it.

474
01:02:32,222 --> 01:02:32,494
Chris: Yeah.

475
01:02:32,542 --> 01:02:33,870
Kayla: Makes people dig their heels in.

476
01:02:33,950 --> 01:03:14,386
Chris: Yeah. It's funny. Actually, our very next question was like, you know, we did a bunch of watching of your videos, and actually, one thing I really like about your channel, like, how positive you are, and you always start by thanking your audience, and you had this whole thing about how, like, when you want to, you know, talk to somebody, talk sense to an MLM distributor, you make it a point to say that you can't have that confrontational approach. You have to be kind and understanding. And it's interesting because, like, we just did an episode two on cult deprogramming, and it feels like it feels a little bit similar to that. Right. Cult deprogramming can, you know, is there's good aspects and bad aspects to it. And the bad aspects are when it's this sort of confrontational approach that doesn't seem to work.

477
01:03:14,458 --> 01:03:26,234
Chris: So it's interesting that you. That you sort of have this. It's more powerful to be kind and understanding and use that approach. So I don't know if you want to talk a little bit more about that. And I know you just kind of did.

478
01:03:26,282 --> 01:03:55,828
Alanda Carter: But yesterday I did a live stream, and I'll kind of tell the story of my rationalization behind this, which is nothing to do with MLM, but I think it paints a good picture as to what somebody actually needs because what they don't need is somebody coming at them hard. When they're in something that's destructive, they're in a destructive group. So if you come at them hard, that's just going to be more damaging to them. And how are they going to open up and change when somebody is attacking them?

479
01:03:55,964 --> 01:03:56,308
Kayla: Right.

480
01:03:56,364 --> 01:04:19,184
Alanda Carter: Not likely. So the story goes, my friend Michelle, her husband, were in Lagrange, Texas, where her sister married. And Michelle found out that day, and she's no longer with us. She died of brain cancer, and I miss her so very much. But she found out that day at her sister's wedding that her husband had cheated on her and wanted a divorce.

481
01:04:19,312 --> 01:04:19,980
Kayla: Right.

482
01:04:20,400 --> 01:04:24,180
Alanda Carter: So she, you can imagine the mess she was in.

483
01:04:24,600 --> 01:04:25,128
Chris: Sure.

484
01:04:25,224 --> 01:05:05,016
Alanda Carter: And so I was there for her. We were at her mom's house after the wedding, and Michelle is just like sobbing, and so she's like on my shoulder and literally I became a snot rag. That's what I was. I was just a snot rag for her. That's what she needed. She didn't need me going, what would that have done when she was in the state that she was in? It's the same thing when somebody is in an MLM and they have been put through this mental trauma. How are we going to help them if we do not offer a helping hand and love and kindness?

485
01:05:05,128 --> 01:05:05,664
Kayla: Right.

486
01:05:05,792 --> 01:05:30,100
Alanda Carter: I just don't think that people will respond to something being harsh because that is hurtful. So that's basically, I just go back to something like that. I know, give them what they need at that time, and that is be a friend, do what you would want someone to do for you. Would you want someone attacking you?

487
01:05:30,640 --> 01:05:31,216
Chris: Right.

488
01:05:31,328 --> 01:05:32,112
Alanda Carter: Probably not.

489
01:05:32,176 --> 01:05:36,940
Kayla: Yeah. That really, that's like so logical almost.

490
01:05:37,320 --> 01:06:17,382
Chris: Yeah, yeah. Changing gears a little bit. Another point that you made. So this is just like along theme of stuff I saw in your videos. Right. So another point that you made that really stuck with me and it's because I feel like I see this over and over with other mlms is how the really successful beachbody coaches were folks that already had like an established fitness or wellness business, and Beachbody was just like another piece of their puzzle. Can you talk more about that? And was this made clear to you when you were, got into it or were you sort of told, like, anybody can do this. It's, you know, just always told.

491
01:06:17,446 --> 01:06:38,136
Alanda Carter: Anyone can do it. Anyone can do it. Most of the people that I know who are at the top of beachbody, they didn't have a fitness background. They just, you know, someone that is no longer in it. She had been a spanish actress in novellas. So do you think that she, you know, got a downline?

492
01:06:38,328 --> 01:06:38,800
Chris: Right?

493
01:06:38,880 --> 01:06:39,392
Kayla: Yeah.

494
01:06:39,496 --> 01:06:40,140
Chris: Right.

495
01:06:40,600 --> 01:06:49,024
Alanda Carter: Shailene Johnson. Shailene created turbo kick, turbo jam Pio. Her sister is in it. Do you think her sister got a downline?

496
01:06:49,192 --> 01:06:50,016
Kayla: Probably.

497
01:06:50,168 --> 01:06:50,672
Chris: Right?

498
01:06:50,776 --> 01:06:51,460
Alanda Carter: Yeah.

499
01:06:51,760 --> 01:06:53,208
Kayla: I sense a pattern here.

500
01:06:53,304 --> 01:07:08,096
Alanda Carter: Yeah. But go back. This goes back to Sheffield group. Okay. Because they will teach people how to recruit, people who can recruit. Oh, there was another person that was in it that her husband's a professional baseball player. Do you think that made a difference?

501
01:07:08,288 --> 01:07:11,540
Chris: Right, right. Yes. Yeah.

502
01:07:11,850 --> 01:07:15,122
Alanda Carter: Do you think being a lingerie model would help you?

503
01:07:15,306 --> 01:07:18,230
Kayla: That's. Yeah, that sounds like a great recruiting technique.

504
01:07:18,930 --> 01:07:41,148
Alanda Carter: You know, I mean, so there's a lot of these things that you. Because they just look like regular women now. You have no idea that there's any of this stuff really going on. Right. So the Sheffield group, what they. Okay, what will happen? Because I'm going to give the example of direct sellers. When direct sellers came on the market in 2017, and that's what my coach left to join a brand new MLM. Okay.

505
01:07:41,204 --> 01:07:41,780
Kayla: Right.

506
01:07:41,940 --> 01:08:12,902
Alanda Carter: You want people in that know how to recruit. So they're looking for people who are already in an MLM, and maybe that MLM is going through kind of like a downturn. Maybe those people aren't making the money that they made at one time, but they already have a team. They already know how to recruit. They've already established themselves in some way. And so then they'll be offered something to bring them on, and then they'll bring people with them.

507
01:08:13,006 --> 01:08:13,350
Kayla: Okay.

508
01:08:13,390 --> 01:08:13,918
Chris: I see.

509
01:08:14,014 --> 01:08:52,099
Alanda Carter: Sometimes that can happen. You know, it's like they're getting people intentionally, and those are those first people come in, and then the person who was my coach, she's no longer with. Well, even when direct sellers were still around, she left and she went to hempworks, and now I think she's even with something else now. And one of the people who was a beachbody coach, he's now doing that whole, I'll teach you how to be successful in multilevel marketing. He's not doing that anymore. So, you know, there's these different offshoots. So basically, the answer is, you don't have to have a background in fitness. Most people do. Not even those at the top.

510
01:08:52,439 --> 01:08:59,060
Chris: Wow. But it seems like they do have a background in something that gives them a leg up, though, if they're at the top, is what you're saying. Right.

511
01:08:59,600 --> 01:09:12,872
Alanda Carter: They have influence in some way. For instance, there's another one who was a pharmaceutical salesperson. And so she can talk about the ingredients and really sound like she knows what she's talking about. And she's already been in sales.

512
01:09:13,015 --> 01:09:13,416
Kayla: Right.

513
01:09:13,488 --> 01:09:27,367
Alanda Carter: So guess what she knows how to do. So see, there's all these, there's just this little hidden stuff. Somebody else who had worked for NBNBC, right. She had worked there in marketing. Do you think she knows how to market herself?

514
01:09:27,542 --> 01:09:28,299
Kayla: You know?

515
01:09:29,078 --> 01:09:29,819
Chris: Right.

516
01:09:31,479 --> 01:09:39,738
Alanda Carter: But anybody can do this. We're all on an even playing field and you're not, you know, that's the bottom line. You're really not.

517
01:09:40,639 --> 01:09:50,215
Kayla: Could you, would you mind explaining for us and for our listeners something else that you've talked about? The quote, three vital behaviors, four vital behaviors.

518
01:09:50,247 --> 01:10:10,657
Alanda Carter: I'll be happy to do that. It started out as three transformed into four. Yeah, the first, this is very, I mean, I'm going to may not do them in the right order. First one is be a product of the product. And that's always thrown at you that way. And this goes into, you know, into the bite model or you guys are familiar with the bite model, right?

519
01:10:10,753 --> 01:10:11,905
Chris: That's the Steve Hassan thing.

520
01:10:11,937 --> 01:11:03,640
Alanda Carter: Yeah, yeah. Behavior control, information control, thought control, emotional control, saying that will quit for your listeners. And so being a product of the product really is behavior control because there you are buying the shakeology because, you know, you get that on auto ship so you can get the personal volume that you need. You're doing the workout program. You're doing all the things that you're told to do. So you're a product of the product. Another one is recognition. Recognition is kind of like love bombing, too. So if somebody has reach the first rank, there's a big to do about, oh, congratulate such and so and so for reaching this. Another thing they do on the national wake up call, which happens every Monday. And I won one time. I was so proud. Oh, my God, I was so proud I won the trivia question.

521
01:11:04,740 --> 01:11:50,616
Alanda Carter: I mean, was I not it? You know, I got a little tote bag and a cookbook, you know, 21 day fixed cookbook. So recognition is another one. Another one is personal development. Where I talked about that earlier about the tool scam and how personal development was big in the sixties and seventies and how it's infused. Personal development is part of all of this because it goes back to, you got to get your mind right. You're the problem. If it's not working, you're not working hard enough. So now you got to do more personal development. Okay. And the fourth one is invite the one that nobody ever likes. The invite. That's where it goes back to hey, Honda. Hey, girl. Because you always have to be inviting them to a free group, to a challenge group, to become a coach.

522
01:11:50,808 --> 01:11:51,576
Chris: Interesting.

523
01:11:51,688 --> 01:11:53,656
Alanda Carter: Those are the four vital behaviors.

524
01:11:53,808 --> 01:12:20,580
Chris: Yeah. And it's interesting that you related that back to the. To the bite model, and you've talked about love bombing and you talked about the cultic studies group. So I'll just kind of get into it. That's what our show is, right, is about cults or cult adjacent groups. In your mind, the cult metaphor is obviously a key component to this whole thing based on all of that. So why is that, like, what. What makes you keep coming back to that comparison? What makes you bring that up?

525
01:12:21,320 --> 01:12:35,666
Alanda Carter: Well, you know, it's interesting because for myself, what has really helped me is I started listening to a lot of Chris Sheffield. I don't know if you guys watch his channel or not. He's a former Scientologist, and. Oh, yeah.

526
01:12:35,698 --> 01:12:35,970
Kayla: He's.

527
01:12:36,010 --> 01:13:23,038
Alanda Carter: He's amazing. And just listening to a lot of that, I was seeing myself as, you know, Chris was deconstructing things and having other people on. I think there was a particular episode where he had Andy fellows on. Andy was involved in an Internet cult, and I'm like, wow. It just. It just, like, all started clicking, and I already kind of had a feeling. But just hearing it over and over again, it was helping me recognize. Recognize what was going on. Now, the reason I specifically say that beachbody is a cult is, and I think they changed what the name of this document is. But back when I was a beachbody hunt, but it was called the business activity tracker. The business activity tracker. And I've done a video on this.

528
01:13:23,094 --> 01:13:54,224
Alanda Carter: When you go through what you're supposed to do throughout the day, it covers all of the bite model. It's, like, all infused with that. And so I'm like, I'm getting it now. That's why. And I just also, I have a master's in anthropology, too. So I've been able to look at things from that perspective as well. And so when I'm able, now that I'm outside of it, I can pull back and I can actually examine it critically. I couldn't when I was in the middle of it.

529
01:13:54,352 --> 01:14:17,888
Chris: Right. Business activity tracker is a very sort of, like, ominously sounding simple name. Yeah, so you say. But it. It has all the bite model in it. So I assume that what you'll find in there is things that are controlling your behavior or at least prescribing behaviors, prescribing things for, you know, emotional control, whatever. Is that, is that accurate?

530
01:14:17,984 --> 01:14:49,922
Alanda Carter: Yeah, it is. I mean, I'm not going to be able to hit all of it because I don't have a document up. But, for instance, you're tracking the invites that you do. You're tracking the shakeology, you're tracking your workouts, you're tracking that. Have you done your prep for your meals for the week? You're tracking your personal development. You're writing affirmations. I mean, there's, like, all of this stuff you're doing, the personal development. You're going to the national wake up call. All of these different things. Oh, you. And you must surround yourself with like minded people.

531
01:14:50,066 --> 01:14:50,370
Kayla: Right.

532
01:14:50,410 --> 01:15:36,316
Alanda Carter: And if someone isn't like minded, you don't need them in your life. You have a success partner. Your success partner is your buddy. That keeps you on track. And so that's another form of control. You go into these different groups. Everything about the bite model when it comes to multilevel marketing and specifically to beachbody, when it comes to religious cults, I think it's really easy for people to see everything about the bite model when people start discussing it. When it comes to a business opportunity cult, meaning a multilevel marketing company, it's harder because it's kind of, like, under the surface. And until you're, like, out from it and start deconstructing what happened to you're not going to make those connections because it's just not as evident.

533
01:15:36,508 --> 01:16:08,296
Alanda Carter: It's because the nature of the person that I am now that I've woken up from this dream that was, you know, actually a nightmare, I can look at this, you know, from a distance and go, like, oh, I see this wear. This fits in this. Now, I can start putting that all together, but when you're in the middle of it, you can't. You just don't see anything. Your critical thinking has gone out the window. Cog in the machine by design, right?

534
01:16:08,368 --> 01:16:08,696
Kayla: Right.

535
01:16:08,768 --> 01:16:25,332
Alanda Carter: Yeah, absolutely. And again, it goes back to the Sheffield group because it was funny when I was talking to Chris one time, he was like, well, there's not like, there's this, you know, dark school of arts. I'm like, oh, but there's a Sheffield group. He's like, oh, you have a dark school of art. I'm like, yes, there is one. There is one.

536
01:16:25,476 --> 01:16:28,644
Chris: Oh, my gosh. That is so creepy.

537
01:16:28,812 --> 01:17:05,122
Kayla: Something that we like to do with our episodes is kind of like, try to find angle for the group or, like, a theme behind the story. So what do you think is the angle for beachbody? Like, what is. What is it about them as a company that makes them different from other mlMs? Like, I should come clean. I did insanity, like, six or seven years ago, and I had Shanti, baby. Oh, Shanti. I had no idea that they were an MLM until basically, until you started doing the research for this. Like, I had no idea there was an MLM component. Do you think that's part of the DNA that makes them different, or what are your thoughts on that?

538
01:17:05,306 --> 01:17:55,364
Alanda Carter: For me, I really see all mlms as so similar. So saying, like, how it's, like, so different, you know, it's really hard for me to see that. But Shawn T. He's a man. I just love me some Shawn. Love him. I want. I want to snuggle up with him and watch movies, and I just. I love him. But I recently saw him, and I can't remember what it was, but it was basically the big, huge webinar for multilevel marketers to go to. But I don't think everybody always knows. I know, I know. It kills me, but I don't think everybody always knows. Okay. When somebody joins an MLM, and let's just say they do have influence, I don't think they know what an MLM is in terms of how destructive it is to other people.

539
01:17:55,532 --> 01:18:12,918
Alanda Carter: And then over time, because of cognitive dissonance, they're not going to be able to see it because it's working for them. So they're. Again, they're being traumatized mentally and have no idea. I think it's the same thing for super trainers like Shawn T. I'm sure he had no idea what a multi level marketing company was when he got involved with all of this.

540
01:18:13,014 --> 01:18:13,294
Kayla: Right.

541
01:18:13,342 --> 01:18:19,398
Alanda Carter: And now there he is, and he's not going to see it for what it is because of what his involvement has been.

542
01:18:19,534 --> 01:18:20,530
Kayla: Right, right.

543
01:18:21,110 --> 01:18:24,850
Alanda Carter: Which also hurts my heart, because I just. I just love.

544
01:18:25,390 --> 01:18:29,520
Kayla: I want to, like, shrink him down and carry him in my pocket everywhere. I. I love him.

545
01:18:30,420 --> 01:18:40,428
Alanda Carter: I know, but now I just can't get behind him because of the multi level. I just want to sit down and go like, Sean, dude, here's the deal. Step away. You know, you need to get him.

546
01:18:40,444 --> 01:18:41,356
Chris: To watch your channel.

547
01:18:41,468 --> 01:18:45,720
Kayla: Yes, yes. Hash Saveshonte.

548
01:18:46,820 --> 01:18:51,680
Alanda Carter: Sort of hashtag, right? That would be great. Please, Sean, leave.

549
01:18:52,060 --> 01:18:54,004
Kayla: Sean, if you're listening, we're here to.

550
01:18:54,012 --> 01:19:15,384
Alanda Carter: Help, but in terms of how they're different. One of the things that, what hit me and hits a lot of women in this way is that sense of community, of thinking you're going to have community and support. And think about this, when you get out of high school, when you get out of college, when you get in the real world where you're married, you don't have time go around meeting people.

551
01:19:15,552 --> 01:19:16,024
Kayla: Right.

552
01:19:16,112 --> 01:19:31,322
Alanda Carter: And this just kind of slides right in and starts, you know, it makes you feel good. You have that quote, sisterhood, right. Even though it's all fake, you know, again. So I'm sorry, I can't tell. I can't tell you how they're different because I just see them all so eerily similar, right?

553
01:19:31,346 --> 01:19:56,912
Chris: Oh, no, that's its own answer, right? Is that they're all so similar. Yeah, it's interesting you say that, too. Just back about like, oh, I'm not sure if people like shawn t know or people that join know. I mean, I didn't know until I started doing research on this for our show last year just how deep this rabbit hole goes and just how destructive it can be. Kind of like what you said we're saying before about it being a little bit of a blind spot, like just in our society.

554
01:19:57,056 --> 01:19:57,696
Kayla: Right.

555
01:19:57,848 --> 01:20:10,060
Chris: Okay. So since we are almost at the end of our questions, I have a tough one. I really want you to dig deep here. What are some positive or good aspects about team beachbody, if any? If any.

556
01:20:13,080 --> 01:20:42,910
Alanda Carter: Well, okay. Their workout programs are really good. I mean, I enjoyed their workout programs, I will say that. But now, because it's associated with MLM, no way in hell, you know, but yes, you know, the super trainers, they put together something good. So that's, and that's pretty much what I'm going to say was the only thing that's positive because everything else would be the same crap as any other MLM. Oh, the community. But the community is fake.

557
01:20:43,040 --> 01:20:43,402
Kayla: Right.

558
01:20:43,466 --> 01:21:31,950
Alanda Carter: The opportunity. Well, there's really not much of one. I mean, you know, so it goes back to. Because I think the good thing is that it appears as if it's going to give you answer. It looks good. It sounds like it's easy. All of them. Make them. Make it sound easy. You just have to do the four vital behaviors. That's all you really have to do. Just do the four vital behaviors. Keep at it, don't stop, you know, keep going. Consistency and you'll have success because they want you to stay hooked in. So really the programs is about it. And it, the appearance, which again, is an illusion.

559
01:21:32,110 --> 01:21:33,502
Kayla: Right. Right.

560
01:21:33,686 --> 01:21:43,650
Chris: Okay, so final question that I just like to ask all of our guests on the show, totally optional. Up to you. Is there anything we haven't talked about today that you would just like to tell to our listeners?

561
01:21:45,070 --> 01:22:43,814
Alanda Carter: If somebody that, you know, is in a multilevel marketing company, don't go, that's a pyramid scheme. That's a scam. Don't approach it that way. Just listen to them politely decline, build arsenal to be able to have so that when they realize and wake up, you can be there because you don't want to cut off relationships with them because they will cut relationships with you because you will be perceived as the enemy. Like, right now, I'm perceived as. You're like, I'm just a big fat loser. You know, I just didn't try hard. You know, it's, I'm the problem, not the structure of multilevel marketing. So it's going to be educate yourself with what you can do. And a lot of it goes back to, you know, the stuff that people use to help people in cults. So it's like, really start finding your information.

562
01:22:43,982 --> 01:23:32,326
Alanda Carter: And, you know, resources that I can recommend would also be pyramidschemalert.org. David Breyer's MLm the American dream made nightmare. Robert Fitzpatrick of Pyramid scheme alert. He's coming out with the book Ponzi nomics, which I'm not sure when it's going to be out this year, but it's is supposed to be out this year. He goes through the history of mlms. There's a paper out online by doctor John Taylor where he analyzed over 400 compensation plans. Get that. I mean, just. And then listen to some different people. You know, listen to people who are putting out content that's educational and not just like MLM drama and kind of, you know, like, you know, going after people and exposing them and that kind of stuff, really, you know, get the education about the psychology that's used.

563
01:23:32,518 --> 01:23:38,310
Alanda Carter: A book that I can recommend, which I have right here, is influence, the psychology of persuasion.

564
01:23:38,430 --> 01:23:42,126
Chris: I love that book. I read that book. That's such a good one.

565
01:23:42,158 --> 01:23:52,998
Alanda Carter: You know, learn about cults, learn about authoritarian control. You know, just learn about all of those things because it's all part of multilevel marketing. So that's basically what I can say.

566
01:23:53,174 --> 01:24:14,590
Chris: That's, that's great. It's. Man, it's so unsettling that folks like, you get sort of, like, attacked, portrayed as, like, the problem. I mean, I get it. I get that why they do that but it's. Man, that. That part is really unsettling to me. And just, I guess, thank you for continuing to. To be on the front line anyway, even in the face of that, you know, you.

567
01:24:14,630 --> 01:24:22,198
Alanda Carter: Well, you guys are doing it, too, right? You're going out there. I'm sure you're attacked when anybody who goes speaks out against anything, we get the hate.

568
01:24:22,374 --> 01:24:28,622
Chris: Right? Actually, I'm looking forward to some hate because, what, like, 303 to 400 listeners.

569
01:24:28,646 --> 01:24:31,134
Kayla: An episode at this point, we're like, 430 now.

570
01:24:31,262 --> 01:24:33,326
Chris: Oh, 430 now. That's not bad.

571
01:24:33,398 --> 01:24:35,502
Alanda Carter: Okay, that's good. That's good.

572
01:24:35,566 --> 01:24:40,662
Chris: Welcome. I welcome the hate because it means that we're on the right track. Right.

573
01:24:40,806 --> 01:24:44,326
Kayla: I guess that's a way of looking at it, so. It is.

574
01:24:44,358 --> 01:25:10,064
Alanda Carter: I mean, it's. It's one way to look at myself, what I do on my channel, because I get called all kinds of things, and I'm like, you know what? Not only do I not need that, the people I'm helping, they don't need to see that. And I have. There's just stuff that I'm like by sis. Go away, Karen. Go. Go away, Ken. I mean, I don't. You know, nobody needs what you're selling because it's just a bunch of crap, and. And I'm just not going tolerate it in my backyard.

575
01:25:10,192 --> 01:25:11,100
Kayla: Love that.

576
01:25:12,160 --> 01:25:25,986
Chris: Well, thank you so much for your time and expertise here. This has been a really good chat and just for our listeners. If you guys want to know more about mlms and beachbody, make sure you go watch and subscribe to the recovering hunbot on YouTube.

577
01:25:26,178 --> 01:25:30,482
Alanda Carter: My playlist on Beachbody is well over 30 videos on just Beachbot.

578
01:25:30,506 --> 01:25:34,466
Chris: Wow. And you've given me some other good leads here, too. We've been taking some notes.

579
01:25:34,498 --> 01:25:43,668
Alanda Carter: So if you guys have any questions, if I could help you in any way, just please, you know, reach out to me, and I'd love to have you come on my channel sometime on, too.

580
01:25:43,764 --> 01:25:45,588
Kayla: Be amazing if you'd be interested in.

581
01:25:45,604 --> 01:25:47,420
Alanda Carter: Doing that, you know, let's set that up.

582
01:25:47,500 --> 01:25:50,404
Chris: Yeah, please, for sure. Yeah, let's stay in touch. Yeah.

583
01:25:50,572 --> 01:25:51,476
Alanda Carter: Talk to you later.

584
01:25:51,588 --> 01:25:52,880
Kayla: Thanks for talking.

585
01:25:53,420 --> 01:25:53,884
Chris: You, too.

586
01:25:53,932 --> 01:25:54,600
Alanda Carter: Bye.

587
01:26:00,060 --> 01:26:10,022
Chris: So she was super fun to talk to, and, man, I did not realize beforehand how much I still had to learn about the Mihden ecosystem.

588
01:26:10,206 --> 01:26:17,670
Kayla: It's insane. It's like the rabbit hole that. It's not just a rabbit hole, it's a bottomless rabbit pit.

589
01:26:17,750 --> 01:26:34,010
Chris: Yeah, I mean, I did a lot of research on this episode, and also on the Mary Kay episode, and, I mean, there's just so many things that I've dug into on this, and then I still learned some stuff from that interview. What are some things that you thought were. What are your takeaways?

590
01:26:34,480 --> 01:26:36,300
Kayla: She's really cute, and I like her.

591
01:26:36,600 --> 01:26:38,224
Chris: That's your takeaway, that she's cute?

592
01:26:38,272 --> 01:27:06,482
Kayla: I really like her. This isn't for the episode. This is me. It's just the thing that I can't stop thinking about. I'll never be able to stop thinking about is just how insidious and vicious and damaging these. This structure of a business can be. Like, really a harsh language that she. She used to describe the emotional experience and, like, even unconsciously what she was experiencing.

593
01:27:06,586 --> 01:27:07,138
Chris: Right.

594
01:27:07,274 --> 01:27:24,586
Kayla: And I think that's kind of something that, when you come out of it, that's a universal experience. If you were as in it as. As she was, it's just. It's so. It's evil. Like, it's. It's what is done to people. It's such a cult.

595
01:27:24,778 --> 01:27:35,674
Chris: Yeah. But then again, the counterpoint of Nancy Carlson of my mom's involvement in Mary Kay seemed to leave her with a positive.

596
01:27:35,802 --> 01:27:42,710
Kayla: Absolutely. I think that. I don't think the mlms of 1980 are the mlms of 2020.

597
01:27:45,130 --> 01:27:47,190
Chris: We did contend that on that episode.

598
01:27:47,570 --> 01:28:12,382
Kayla: It's something that, because I don't think the way Emma mlms started or a lot of these mlms started, they didn't necessarily start to be exploitive, but I think the more modern ones and mlms that have lasted a very long time pivot that way or start that way. Start with the intention of getting money, not making money.

599
01:28:12,446 --> 01:28:12,926
Chris: Yeah.

600
01:28:13,038 --> 01:28:14,254
Kayla: Exploiting people for that.

601
01:28:14,342 --> 01:28:39,936
Chris: Right. And remember what we said on that show, too, on that episode that was, like, right around the time that the FTC versus Amway decision happened, and so it feels like there's a case to be made that once that decision was made, the brakes were off, and after that, you potentially. You have these companies maybe feeling like they can be more and more pyramid shaped.

602
01:28:40,008 --> 01:28:40,816
Kayla: Right, right.

603
01:28:40,888 --> 01:28:46,338
Chris: Since they don't have to worry about that prosecutorially from the FTC as much anymore.

604
01:28:46,394 --> 01:28:46,990
Kayla: Right.

605
01:28:48,290 --> 01:28:54,586
Chris: But, yeah. Do you want to talk a little bit about this one tidbit that she mentioned back towards the. Earlier in the interview, the Sheffield group?

606
01:28:54,738 --> 01:29:06,770
Kayla: I'm terrified to talk about the Sheffield group. I feel like someone's gonna come kick our windows in and, like, take us away. I'm. I'm. That's a fucking scary ass name.

607
01:29:06,890 --> 01:29:09,596
Chris: I love that. It's meta. I love it's like a mlm. I know, right?

608
01:29:09,628 --> 01:29:10,892
Kayla: It's an MLM for mlms.

609
01:29:10,956 --> 01:29:15,764
Chris: It's an MLM for mlms. But it's such. Yeah, it's such, like a. It's such, like a. Yeah. Tv movie name.

610
01:29:15,892 --> 01:29:24,796
Kayla: You get. You feel like you're playing a video game and you feel like you're getting to the end only to realize you're only getting to the midpoint. And there's, like, a way bigger problem coming. And that's the Sheffield group. Yes.

611
01:29:24,868 --> 01:29:36,370
Chris: Yeah. Yeah. And it's like. It's so funny. They didn't cross my radar when I was doing the Mary Kay research or even in the preliminary research that I did for our bit that we did before the interview.

612
01:29:37,150 --> 01:29:38,806
Kayla: That makes it even scarier.

613
01:29:38,958 --> 01:29:59,022
Chris: I know, but I'm glad she brought it up. So after the interview, of course, I did spend a little time digging on them and spent some time on their website. And it's like. It's really weird because as sinister as it sounds, and I think it is, but it's, like, basically just a consulting business.

614
01:29:59,126 --> 01:30:00,344
Kayla: Right. It seems like.

615
01:30:00,502 --> 01:30:44,542
Chris: Like their website is very. Just, like, benign looking. And it seems to mostly revolve around this one guy, Mike Sheffield. And, like, I'm sure he employs people, but I couldn't really get a sense from his website, like, how many or what roles they had or anything like that. The closest I got was that one of their testimonials mentioned, quote, mike Sheffield and his team, their website is mostly dedicated to, like, hard selling their consulting services to MLM startups and even to established MLM companies. So it totally makes sense that they would be the company, the consulting company that beachbody would go to be like, hey, how do we do this? How do we make this happen?

616
01:30:44,726 --> 01:31:19,784
Chris: And you remember all the way back when were doing the pre interview chat, just you and me, earlier in the episode, and were looking at their compensation structure, and you were like, oh, man, that looks crazy. It's almost like you need to be a full time job. Well, guess what one of the things is. Guess what one of these services is that they offer that website. And another one I went to called mLM.com, spend a good amount of time talking about compensation plans. Like, that's something that they spend a lot of effort and resources and design work on.

617
01:31:19,912 --> 01:31:25,460
Kayla: They hire people to build big part of it. Impossible mazes. They hire business.

618
01:31:26,520 --> 01:31:35,168
Chris: Yeah. Although they don't. I don't think, you know, like, a lot of these, you know, cult leader situations. I don't think they see it that way. You know? Like, I don't think that they.

619
01:31:35,264 --> 01:31:36,140
Kayla: You don't?

620
01:31:36,520 --> 01:31:45,314
Chris: I just. I know, like, the impression that I get is that, like, they all think that this is, like, super legit. You know, just. They're doing great work. I mean, you should read some of their.

621
01:31:45,362 --> 01:31:48,882
Kayla: Is it time cube, though? Like, are they all insane? Are they all just.

622
01:31:48,946 --> 01:31:50,898
Chris: I don't know. But, like, here's.

623
01:31:50,914 --> 01:31:55,858
Kayla: The compensation structures are literally decipherable.

624
01:31:55,914 --> 01:32:08,820
Chris: I know. By the way, here's their offices in Scottsdale, Arizona. It's just like, this nondescript building. Yeah, it's just, like, literally. I think it's just some guy and a few other people just.

625
01:32:08,860 --> 01:32:09,812
Kayla: I don't like his logo.

626
01:32:09,876 --> 01:32:10,524
Chris: Insulting.

627
01:32:10,612 --> 01:32:11,492
Kayla: I don't like his logo.

628
01:32:11,516 --> 01:32:13,644
Chris: One way. I know it's very. Oh, the lion.

629
01:32:13,732 --> 01:32:17,276
Kayla: The scary red lion. White letters with the black background.

630
01:32:17,348 --> 01:32:29,132
Chris: No, but when I say I think that they believe their own rhetoric and they're drinking their own Kool aid. Here's this mission that they. So they. There's a mission statement on sheffield.com. Sheffieldnet.com, by the way, is the name.

631
01:32:29,156 --> 01:32:34,500
Kayla: Of their website, sheffieldnet.com. Oh, it's creepy. Oh, I hate it.

632
01:32:34,660 --> 01:33:08,410
Chris: But their mission statement is rather long. Service to mankind is the rent we pay for our space on earth. Our company's success is directly related to the service we render. The needs of each the Sheffield group client are the number one priority of our company. We are committed to the continuing research and analysis of tactics leading to the success of our clients. And then just. I don't want to read the whole thing because it's like, literally another, like ten sentences of the exact same thing. But that whole first bit. Service to mankind is the rent we pay for our space on Earth. Like, they really do feel like they're doing good work.

633
01:33:09,030 --> 01:33:13,094
Kayla: I'm pretty sure I have a very different.

634
01:33:13,262 --> 01:33:16,534
Chris: You have a different reaction to that? Yeah. Look at how, like, hard sell this.

635
01:33:16,582 --> 01:33:21,330
Kayla: Also, it was all in quotes, so clearly they don't actually mean it.

636
01:33:22,550 --> 01:33:24,214
Chris: But, yeah, they're, like, a lot of their stuff.

637
01:33:24,262 --> 01:33:27,408
Kayla: Somebody built this website for him. He did not build this website.

638
01:33:27,504 --> 01:33:28,224
Chris: No, of course not.

639
01:33:28,272 --> 01:33:38,220
Kayla: This is like, who makes the MLM? MLM? Mlm. Like, who's an MLM?

640
01:33:38,600 --> 01:33:43,496
Chris: Are you saying there's, like, a group of, like, web developers that are themselves part of an MLM?

641
01:33:43,568 --> 01:33:46,824
Kayla: I don't know, but, yeah, you can.

642
01:33:46,832 --> 01:33:51,226
Chris: See there's, like, a whole section of their website here dedicated to compensation system.

643
01:33:51,328 --> 01:33:54,054
Kayla: Course, the logo for that is a diamond.

644
01:33:54,142 --> 01:33:59,570
Chris: Diamond. Yeah. Because it's, like, all, like, diamond level person, coach.

645
01:34:00,270 --> 01:34:04,078
Kayla: So much business words like synergy all.

646
01:34:04,094 --> 01:34:15,326
Chris: Up in the wazoo. So as a consulting company, they make a pretty big deal about their current and former client list, and it's a long list.

647
01:34:15,398 --> 01:34:17,126
Kayla: Tell me them. Tell me them. I need to know.

648
01:34:17,158 --> 01:34:22,370
Chris: So here's some of them. Here's some. Some of them. New skin, young living. It works. Marketing.

649
01:34:22,710 --> 01:34:23,502
Kayla: It works.

650
01:34:23,566 --> 01:34:34,398
Chris: It works. Remember, it works. That's that one with a weird commercial. Reader's Digest is on there, which I didn't know is MLM. Or they have some m. I don't know. It's on what? It's on their client list.

651
01:34:34,534 --> 01:34:36,014
Kayla: I have to look that up.

652
01:34:36,142 --> 01:34:39,470
Chris: Something called longevity International, which is creepy.

653
01:34:39,510 --> 01:34:41,730
Kayla: That is definitely, like, cryogenics or something.

654
01:34:43,510 --> 01:34:44,228
Chris: Amway.

655
01:34:44,334 --> 01:34:46,296
Kayla: Oh. Oh, shocked.

656
01:34:46,368 --> 01:34:48,464
Chris: Yeah. And, of course, beach body.

657
01:34:48,552 --> 01:34:52,208
Kayla: And literally. Literally beach body or hundreds more.

658
01:34:52,344 --> 01:34:55,544
Chris: Well, beach body, because that's, like, the parent. Like, that's.

659
01:34:55,592 --> 01:34:57,224
Kayla: Okay. Okay. Okay.

660
01:34:57,312 --> 01:35:04,360
Chris: They took beach body and spun off team Beachbot. I mean, still, you know, reports up to the same corporate structure, but. Yeah.

661
01:35:04,440 --> 01:35:06,312
Kayla: So you said there's hundreds? More than that.

662
01:35:06,376 --> 01:35:09,952
Chris: Hundreds. Let me find their client list.

663
01:35:10,016 --> 01:35:10,192
Kayla: You.

664
01:35:10,216 --> 01:35:13,352
Chris: Real quick here. Here we go. Here's their client list.

665
01:35:13,456 --> 01:35:16,020
Kayla: Oh, are these all mlms?

666
01:35:16,480 --> 01:35:19,256
Chris: I am not sure, but it's a long list. And.

667
01:35:19,288 --> 01:35:21,496
Kayla: Wait. Can you go a little slower so I'll look at some of them? Sorry.

668
01:35:21,648 --> 01:35:25,120
Chris: Most of these I haven't heard wise. I don't know.

669
01:35:25,160 --> 01:35:26,152
Kayla: Slim jevity.

670
01:35:26,296 --> 01:35:26,912
Chris: I don't know.

671
01:35:26,976 --> 01:35:30,020
Kayla: There's a lot of books are fun.

672
01:35:30,880 --> 01:35:38,310
Chris: Like, bon sela, amerilife, master guardhouse. Oh, hey, here's the one we almost talked about. Trek alliance.

673
01:35:41,770 --> 01:35:43,626
Kayla: These are so just.

674
01:35:43,658 --> 01:35:45,186
Chris: The names are so weird.

675
01:35:45,298 --> 01:35:46,138
Kayla: Makeup eraser.

676
01:35:46,194 --> 01:35:46,810
Chris: Mister food.

677
01:35:46,890 --> 01:35:49,458
Kayla: Mister food. Oh, my God.

678
01:35:49,594 --> 01:35:54,042
Chris: I kind of want to do, like, a game where, like, you con air. You have to, like, guess the product.

679
01:35:54,226 --> 01:35:55,890
Kayla: Yeah, I want to do that, too.

680
01:35:55,970 --> 01:35:58,194
Chris: Let's do that on our Patreon with our listeners.

681
01:35:58,242 --> 01:35:59,114
Kayla: Go up a little bit.

682
01:35:59,162 --> 01:36:01,580
Chris: Like, we'll do, like, we'll do, like, a guest quiz.

683
01:36:01,620 --> 01:36:04,720
Kayla: Go down again. National health insurance.

684
01:36:05,300 --> 01:36:07,444
Chris: I don't know. There's. Microsoft's on here, too, so.

685
01:36:07,492 --> 01:36:08,588
Kayla: Time warners.

686
01:36:08,764 --> 01:36:16,156
Chris: MSN TV. Yeah. I don't know. Goofy rankers on here. Anyway, so. A lot. A lot.

687
01:36:16,348 --> 01:36:19,860
Kayla: That's, That's too much, I would say.

688
01:36:20,020 --> 01:36:57,312
Chris: Yeah. So, anyway, the whole thing feels just, like, a little weird. Like, I know there are niche consulting companies out there, like, consulting companies that are devoted to specific industries, and this is clearly one of those. So it's not weird in that sense. But I don't know. I guess it's just like the business model that they're helping to survive and thrive and grow. That that's what really feels gross. It's, you know, the website itself doesn't feel that crazy. Although, like you said, I guess their logo is a little creepy. And clearly you can tell from their client list that their influence is vast. Yeah. But they do seem to be part of this, like, rather small circle of players in the industry.

689
01:36:57,496 --> 01:37:12,712
Chris: So I found in my research that for many years, Mike Sheffield was the head of an organization called the MLMIA, which is not MLMIA, it's MLM. Ia. Not missing an action. Anyway.

690
01:37:12,896 --> 01:37:18,496
Kayla: ML mia, mlmia. What does, what does that stand for?

691
01:37:18,568 --> 01:37:20,992
Chris: Multilevel Marketing International association.

692
01:37:21,096 --> 01:37:21,776
Kayla: Okay.

693
01:37:21,888 --> 01:38:02,834
Chris: According to their site quote, he, Mike Sheffield served as executive vice president from 1985 until elected chairman in 1996. He was also a founder. And Mike became chairman emeritus of MLMIA in 2003. He is now in their hall of fame. I'm not sure what that means, but here's their hall of fame webpage. And by the way, definitely share this with all of our listeners. What? Yeah, it's just a picture of, like a, like a trashy plastic trophy. And then it has, it's got text on it that just like, copy pasted text of hall of Fame MLM people. It's really confusing. I don't know.

694
01:38:02,882 --> 01:38:06,522
Kayla: Also, I feel like I've seen that logo before.

695
01:38:06,626 --> 01:38:11,108
Chris: Well, it's a popular logo style because it's like, it looks like a person.

696
01:38:11,244 --> 01:38:14,280
Kayla: Also, 949 area code.

697
01:38:14,700 --> 01:38:15,812
Chris: Is that us?

698
01:38:15,996 --> 01:38:25,680
Kayla: Isn't that. Yeah, it's. 949 is southern Orange county. It's Irvine or like Irvine.

699
01:38:26,860 --> 01:39:02,830
Chris: It always comes back to one of our episodes. It's amazing. Let's see. Contact us MLMia Worldwide Doris Wood, Chairman 119 Stanford Court Irvine, California 92612 website that's awesome. We should visit there. Like, why? Irvine is like this weird cult nexus. So anyway, along with MLMIA, the Sheffield group is also partnered with mLMlegal.com, which is owned and operated by Babner and Associates, which I found. Unfortunately, Mister Babner himself appears to have passed away in March of this year, sadly.

700
01:39:02,870 --> 01:39:03,534
Kayla: Oh, gosh.

701
01:39:03,662 --> 01:39:34,696
Chris: But it's not the first appearance that mlMlegal.com has made on cult or just weird. We talked about them in the MLM primer episode. We did as well. Yeah, I remember them more accurately. I quoted some bits from their site. But all this, though, really comes back to the point that mlms tend to have to navigate very difficult legal waters to be able to do business. So having a law firm dedicated to it and partnering with them as a consulting company makes a lot of sense. But again, what I'm trying to illustrate here is it's like this like tight knit little group, it seems like.

702
01:39:34,728 --> 01:39:35,456
Kayla: Right? Right.

703
01:39:35,568 --> 01:40:26,360
Chris: Anyway, when I was digging through the Sheffield Group website and mlmlegal.com and mLm.com and mlmia.com, i ran into a couple of interesting arguments about the structure of mlms that I wanted to share here. Just kind of set me down a rabbit hole when we did that interview with Hunbot. So these sites have a bunch of articles just sharing information on the state of the industry, legal frameworks, etcetera, and a few of them caught my eye. The first is an article from mlmia.com called MLMiA Legal Mentoring series what is MLM and what is a pyramid? Written by Gerald Nehra, network marketing attorney and this article essentially attempts to define the difference between direct sales, multilevel marketing, and an illegal pyramid scheme. This is the summary paragraph of what Mister Nara has to say. What is a pyramid?

704
01:40:26,480 --> 01:41:06,080
Chris: By restating what is a single level income opportunity and what is a multi level income opportunity, we get to what is a pyramid when the only way an independent contractor can make money with the company is by personally generating business volume, the company is offered a single level income opportunity. If, however, the company offers two ways to make money, generate business volume and optionally find, which is to sponsor, recruit, or refer other independent contractors who generate business volume, the company is offering a multilevel income opportunity. The key is that the independent contractors are empowered to find and rewarded for finding additional independent contractors. That is the very definition, legally, of multilevel.

705
01:41:06,160 --> 01:41:36,770
Chris: But the rewarded for above can only be an indirect reward based on the business volume of the second independent contractor, the reward can never be an immediate reward for just finding the additional participant. Such an immediate reward is pyramidal and illegal. In an illegal pyramid, the act of finding another participant is rewarded based on the act of recruiting instead of based on the business volume of the recruited person. Another shortcut definition of pyramid, rewarding a participant for bringing in another participant, end quote.

706
01:41:38,270 --> 01:41:40,718
Kayla: That all sounds very suspect.

707
01:41:40,894 --> 01:42:02,392
Chris: Well, yeah, I mean, it's actually, to me it sounded pretty logical in terms of a breakdown anyway. Like you can point to some pretty clear borders in how you define these things using that framework, right? Like you say, okay, single level income opportunity is I sell stuff, multi level is I recruit somebody to sell stuff, and pure is I recruit somebody and I get money for that.

708
01:42:02,456 --> 01:42:02,992
Kayla: Right.

709
01:42:03,136 --> 01:42:17,512
Chris: But those last two things aren't like. Like, one of those things is not like the other. Right. It's like either I sell stuff, I recruit someone to sell stuff, or it's not an or at that point. Like, it's a both. And I think that's where his argument sort of breaks down.

710
01:42:17,576 --> 01:42:18,064
Kayla: Right.

711
01:42:18,192 --> 01:42:31,334
Chris: I can definitely get on board with his definition of a classic pyramid scheme. Like, that makes sense if I recruit somebody and they have to pay me money to get into the pyramid scheme. And then that's where you get that airplane game. Right?

712
01:42:31,462 --> 01:42:32,134
Kayla: Right.

713
01:42:32,302 --> 01:43:06,790
Chris: But he says that a pyramid scheme is one in which you only make money by recruiting others. And as part of that definition, he also says that the money must come from the act of recruiting, not from any further sales down the line. To me, that feels like a technicality. It's an important distinction to have a product that a company is actually selling. Yes. But the thing that these arguments by these people in the MLM industry never seem to take into account is the math. Even if your reward comes from downline sales, not from just when you recruited the person.

714
01:43:06,870 --> 01:43:07,490
Kayla: Right.

715
01:43:07,830 --> 01:43:15,286
Chris: As long as everyone has the same incentive to keep recruiting more downline, eventually you still run out of people either way, right?

716
01:43:15,358 --> 01:43:15,970
Kayla: Right.

717
01:43:16,470 --> 01:43:29,996
Chris: If everyone is an amway or a herbalife or beachbody salesman, then there's nobody to sell product to anymore. Right. Eventually you run out of people. If everybody becomes a recruit, then there's nobody to actually sell to. You're just, everybody is part of the scheme.

718
01:43:30,068 --> 01:43:30,708
Kayla: Right.

719
01:43:30,884 --> 01:44:01,152
Chris: And a lot of the argument in the FTC versus Amway case actually did rest on exactly that, the market saturation argument. And like hell, if you ignore the mathematical impossibility of infinite chain recruiting, then even a classic illegal pyramid scheme would actually work just fine. So ignoring that is just disingenuous. Right. If you say, if you ignore that mathematical impossibility of the chain recruiting, then, like regular pyramid schemes shouldn't even be illegal, right?

720
01:44:01,216 --> 01:44:01,632
Kayla: Right.

721
01:44:01,736 --> 01:44:17,570
Chris: So it's not whether the money comes right now, whether I recruit you, or whether it comes in the future when you generate business volume as my recruit. That's not the problem. The problem is the chain recruiting. It seems that they just willfully ignore that. I don't know.

722
01:44:17,650 --> 01:44:18,882
Kayla: That's so interesting.

723
01:44:18,986 --> 01:44:58,748
Chris: Yeah. But I do understand why he'd want to formulate that argument if your job is network marketing attorney. And I'll add to his nice little platonic ideal definition that most MLM companies do have some sort of buy in or fee system or minimum volume requirements, which at the end of the day, to me, basically constitute the exact thing he is saying that makes a pyramid. It's a recruiting transaction. Most companies have some sort of like, you have to buy in with some starter pack or something. Reading on MLM.com, i also ran into another interesting notion in an article called so you are thinking of starting a company. What you need to know by Sean Smith. And yeah, that's all in caps.

724
01:44:58,844 --> 01:44:59,316
Kayla: Why?

725
01:44:59,428 --> 01:45:00,084
Chris: I don't know.

726
01:45:00,172 --> 01:45:01,052
Kayla: Why is he yelling?

727
01:45:01,116 --> 01:45:41,772
Chris: I don't know. And this article was talking all about what's called the technology innovation cycle, although I don't know if he cited it as such. The technology innovation cycle, which I've also heard referred to as like, customer innovation cycle or technology adoption curve, is something that businessy types love to talk about. You get taught about it at business school. You may have even seen it yourself. Here's a diagram. I'll post this a course on our instagram. You've seen this, where you have, like, you basically have a bell curve, and then they chop it up into bits and they say, here's your innovators. They're like the early people that like, you know, engage with your product right at the beginning when it's still an R and D or whatever, your beta testers, right?

728
01:45:41,796 --> 01:45:49,572
Chris: And then you have early adopters, which is like, you know, your early customers, people that are willing to give something a try, they're like the techies that go out and buy the iPhones right.

729
01:45:49,596 --> 01:45:50,748
Kayla: Off the bat, right?

730
01:45:50,924 --> 01:46:30,452
Chris: Then your early majority, late majority already in laggards. And all you're really talking about is where your customers tend to fall in terms of, like, when they pick up your product, right? Right. So this article on mlM.com took this and applied it to distributors. In this framework, they were saying that you have like, innovator distributors and early adopter distributors, and some distributors discover your product early and love it, and they become superstars. And some pick it up later. You know, they're less super superstars, and some are even laggards, and they're, like, not as good at selling as the early distributors. So do you see what's weird about that? What kind of set wrong with me about that?

731
01:46:30,636 --> 01:46:33,300
Kayla: I don't know if I can articulate it, but yeah, there's something not right.

732
01:46:33,340 --> 01:46:48,814
Chris: It's that the actual innovation curve that most people talk about is about customers adopting a new technology or product, not about your own potential sales force adopting a new technology. Or product.

733
01:46:48,902 --> 01:46:50,182
Kayla: Yeah. Doesn't make any fucking sense.

734
01:46:50,246 --> 01:47:01,710
Chris: So it's very telling to me that someone writing on MLM.com would completely conflate a customer and a distributor. And it tells me exactly where MLM companies heads really are on this.

735
01:47:01,790 --> 01:47:02,446
Kayla: Yeah.

736
01:47:02,598 --> 01:47:43,330
Chris: MLM companies fundamentally view their distributors as customers, as their revenue source, not as tools to generate revenue like an ordinary employee. And this is why, like, quote, unquote, personal use of MLM products is so contested legally. Personal use is actually a whole additional can of worms that we can go into on the show, but we're kind of going along on time. And also, I wanted to hold a few things for the back pocket when we do our next MLM episode, inevitably, or if we just, like, spin off a podcast about MLM or just legal cases or something. But I found some interesting stuff about that, too, that we didn't know about, that we hadn't heard about. Oh, shit, either.

737
01:47:43,450 --> 01:47:51,002
Chris: Actually, Hunbut probably has a, she has a bunch of videos, so recovering Hunbut, I'm sure, probably already knows about this thing, but I'm not even gonna mention it here. I'm just gonna.

738
01:47:51,066 --> 01:47:52,098
Kayla: So you are mentioning it.

739
01:47:52,154 --> 01:47:59,506
Chris: I am mentioning it, but I'm not gonna say what the case. It's a legal case, but I'll just say that in some future episode, we'll get to that.

740
01:47:59,618 --> 01:48:00,430
Kayla: All right.

741
01:48:01,060 --> 01:48:39,326
Chris: Anyway, I'm so very appreciative that recovering Hunbot talked to us, and I want to make a specific point of the fact that she uses empathy and kindness in her messaging. We talked about this a little bit during the interview, but it's really important to remember that in the case of a lot of these mlms and cults in general, that the very people you may be going to intellectual war against are themselves victims. It's extremely difficult to lead with kindness when someone or something is actively trying to do you harm. And while the anti MLM community online is doing great, amazing work, it sometimes comes off a little like, us versus them and judging.

742
01:48:39,398 --> 01:48:41,038
Kayla: Sometimes it can be very angry, it.

743
01:48:41,054 --> 01:49:01,964
Chris: Can be very aggressive, which I super understand because people posting on, like, the anti MLM subreddit are people who have been really hurt by this stuff. So I super get it. And again, that's what makes it so incredibly difficult to lead with kindness. It sort of reminds me of, like, zombie movies or like, the Borg on Star Trek, you know, like, they might be attacking you, but they themselves are, like, the victims of assimilation.

744
01:49:02,052 --> 01:49:03,500
Kayla: Right? Right.

745
01:49:03,620 --> 01:49:08,484
Chris: Man, I had Star Trek in my script before we even bantered about it.

746
01:49:08,612 --> 01:49:10,920
Kayla: Oh, geez, we're time traveling over here.

747
01:49:12,100 --> 01:49:17,894
Chris: Less amusingly, it also reminds me of the life after hate folks that we talked about on the creativity episode.

748
01:49:17,942 --> 01:49:18,294
Kayla: Right.

749
01:49:18,382 --> 01:49:34,390
Chris: The work they do is so amazing because they have to lead with empathy and understanding and kindness, or else what they're doing just won't even work, even though the people they're trying to reach just have some of the most despicable ideologies. Hate filled shit. I don't think I could do that job.

750
01:49:34,470 --> 01:49:39,734
Kayla: No. It takes a very special. A very special understanding, patient person.

751
01:49:39,862 --> 01:49:56,932
Chris: Yeah. But bringing it back, it's so important for their two be people like that. It's so important to have advocates for kindness and empathy, even when it is so difficult to do so. And so I just wanted to say I really, truly appreciate that about recovering Hunbot and her YouTube channel.

752
01:49:57,116 --> 01:49:59,240
Kayla: Same. That makes a lot of sense.

753
01:49:59,660 --> 01:50:17,158
Chris: All right, so finally, or I guess, penultimately, it's time for me to list my sources for this episode, which, yes, I'm still doing at the end of the episode, and I still don't know why switched, but I did. So for this episode, we got, in no particular order, the recovering hunbot and multiple of her videos on YouTube.

754
01:50:17,214 --> 01:50:17,810
Kayla: What?

755
01:50:18,230 --> 01:50:19,598
Chris: I know. Weird, right?

756
01:50:19,694 --> 01:50:20,502
Kayla: Shocked.

757
01:50:20,646 --> 01:50:29,022
Chris: It's actually, this is what's shitty about doing the sources at the end is that I'm just like, here's all the things that I already said. But then if I do it at the beginning, then it's like, spoilers. I don't know.

758
01:50:29,086 --> 01:50:32,678
Kayla: Yeah. Or like, here's a bunch of context list stuff, right?

759
01:50:32,734 --> 01:50:46,240
Chris: Yeah, exactly. Beachbody.com, teambeachbody.com, mlm.com. Multiple articles there. Sheffield net.com, mlmia.com. Michael Sheffield's LinkedIn page.

760
01:50:47,340 --> 01:50:48,108
Kayla: What?

761
01:50:48,284 --> 01:50:49,716
Chris: Oh, yeah. You wanted to see a picture of him.

762
01:50:49,748 --> 01:50:51,240
Kayla: I did want to see a picture of him.

763
01:50:52,420 --> 01:50:54,060
Chris: It's exactly how you would think.

764
01:50:54,180 --> 01:50:59,324
Kayla: Oh, no, he's so cute. Oh, he looks. Oh, he's cute.

765
01:50:59,372 --> 01:51:01,438
Chris: He's like a cute old dude.

766
01:51:01,494 --> 01:51:02,370
Kayla: I love him.

767
01:51:04,510 --> 01:51:36,000
Chris: Mlmtruth.org article called, what about team Beachbody? Mlmtruth.org, comma, by the way, is the anti MLM coalition on Facebook, to whom I owe the gratitude of hooking us up with the interview. Cosmopolitan.com. And I already mentioned the name of that article earlier in the show, but this cultish workout is all over your social media feeds. But is it legit? Yourmoneygeek.com. Why you should avoid beachbody coaching and other MLM schemes. Ethanvanderbilt.com a blog article titled team beachbody scam. Yes, it is, in my opinion.

768
01:51:36,660 --> 01:51:38,680
Kayla: Sorry, I don't want to laugh at that.

769
01:51:39,500 --> 01:51:49,660
Chris: No, I think it's funny. I laughed at it. And actually that was where I got the. He does a lot of details on his post and.

770
01:51:49,740 --> 01:51:50,388
Kayla: Oh, nice.

771
01:51:50,484 --> 01:51:53,102
Chris: And that's where he has like the product in the compensation plan and stuff.

772
01:51:53,126 --> 01:51:53,850
Kayla: Gotcha.

773
01:51:54,750 --> 01:52:27,676
Chris: And then, perfectionhangover.com. Multiple blog posts, including why I quit Beachbody, the truth about multilevel marketing, and I actually really love this website, by the way, this lady's website. I wish I had the space to quote more of her in the episode, but I highly recommend checking it out. Perfectionhangover.com there's lots of cool, like, personal development and finance advice there, built from some hard learned experience on her part. And then finally, good old Forbes magazine, for whom some strange reason we always seem to have an article from Forbes. Yep, it's like every cult or just weird episode we seem to, like, have a Forbes article.

774
01:52:27,748 --> 01:52:30,900
Kayla: I really don't understand why they just have extensive reporting.

775
01:52:30,980 --> 01:52:38,500
Chris: Yeah, I guess so. And we're always like, talking about fucking business on the show, too. So anyway, inside Beachbody's billion dollar fat burning empire was the name of that article.

776
01:52:38,580 --> 01:52:39,440
Kayla: There you go.

777
01:52:40,260 --> 01:52:45,156
Chris: All right, Kayla, it's that paper. Crinkling tongue. You ready?

778
01:52:45,348 --> 01:52:46,740
Kayla: Do I have to crinkle the paper?

779
01:52:46,900 --> 01:52:49,420
Chris: No. There we go.

780
01:52:49,460 --> 01:52:57,116
Kayla: Actually, before we do this, you didn't talk about the worst part about team beachbody.

781
01:52:57,268 --> 01:53:01,244
Chris: There's no I in team. No, there's no Shawn T in team.

782
01:53:01,332 --> 01:53:07,724
Kayla: It's the fact that if you don't say it properly, it sounds like you're saying teen beachbody.

783
01:53:07,812 --> 01:53:11,918
Chris: Oh, teen beachbody. That's what it is. I thought it was what that was this whole time.

784
01:53:11,974 --> 01:53:12,870
Kayla: Teen beach body.

785
01:53:12,950 --> 01:53:15,294
Chris: Teen beach body. That's a different thing.

786
01:53:15,382 --> 01:53:16,770
Kayla: Very different thing.

787
01:53:17,110 --> 01:53:19,542
Chris: Disgusting. Don't google that. Or do, I guess.

788
01:53:19,606 --> 01:53:38,442
Kayla: Don't. All right. Criterion expected harm towards the individual. Is it niche within its society? Antifactuality? Percentage of life consumed? Ritual. Charismatic leader. Do you want to give a gut before we go into this?

789
01:53:38,586 --> 01:53:49,470
Chris: My gut is that it's. Yes. My overall about this is just. I think it's basically Mary Kay minus the charismatic leader. Yeah, we talked about Carl Dichler, the CEO.

790
01:53:51,050 --> 01:53:52,146
Kayla: He ain't Mary Kay.

791
01:53:52,258 --> 01:54:03,574
Chris: Yeah, I mean, I don't know. I read some quotes from him in the Forbes article. I read some statement by him on their own website, but maybe somebody else. I don't know. He just seems like a regular CEO.

792
01:54:03,622 --> 01:54:07,118
Kayla: Is it Shawn T? Is it Paul Ryan? Who is it?

793
01:54:07,254 --> 01:54:07,814
Chris: Both.

794
01:54:07,942 --> 01:54:09,110
Kayla: It's a Sean Ryan.

795
01:54:09,190 --> 01:54:12,062
Chris: Weird Voltron amalgamation of Shawn T and Paul Ryan.

796
01:54:12,126 --> 01:54:15,046
Kayla: Shanti would never be caught dead.

797
01:54:15,198 --> 01:54:20,166
Chris: That's what makes Voltron. So. Yeah, that's. That's my gut.

798
01:54:20,238 --> 01:54:26,806
Kayla: I think we'll have a hard time finding an MLM that we don't kind of give the cult label to, is the thing.

799
01:54:26,918 --> 01:54:27,422
Chris: Yeah.

800
01:54:27,526 --> 01:54:31,792
Kayla: Are we talking about Sheffield group as its own thing in here at all or not? We're just talking about beachbody.

801
01:54:31,816 --> 01:54:41,928
Chris: I think we should. I think the thing on the table is team beachbody, but I think it's totally appropriate to talk about, like, Sheffield group being in that orbit.

802
01:54:41,984 --> 01:54:45,496
Kayla: Right? I mean. Okay. Expected harm. High, because it's an MLM.

803
01:54:45,568 --> 01:54:50,752
Chris: Yeah. Based on what recovering Hunbot told us, it seems like there was definitely some.

804
01:54:50,776 --> 01:55:00,320
Kayla: Harm going on there a lot. Financially, socially, psychologically, emotionally. Is it niche? No.

805
01:55:00,700 --> 01:55:02,284
Chris: Yeah, it seems like it's pretty.

806
01:55:02,412 --> 01:55:03,660
Kayla: It's pretty widespread.

807
01:55:03,700 --> 01:55:08,532
Chris: I mean. I mean, that's like you were exposed to at least the everybody knows insanity.

808
01:55:08,596 --> 01:55:13,048
Kayla: Paul Ryan talked about. P 90 X, hip hop, abs, Piyo. It's all over the place.

809
01:55:13,054 --> 01:55:19,612
Chris: Cosmopolitan says this cultish workout is all over your social media feeds. So it's pretty much all over the place. So not niche.

810
01:55:19,716 --> 01:55:26,326
Kayla: Anti factuality. Very high, because, again, MLM right there, you can't make money on an MLM.

811
01:55:26,438 --> 01:55:26,806
Chris: Right.

812
01:55:26,878 --> 01:55:27,670
Kayla: You just can't.

813
01:55:27,750 --> 01:55:28,062
Chris: Right.

814
01:55:28,126 --> 01:55:32,822
Kayla: At least not in 2020. Percentage of life consumed. What do you think?

815
01:55:32,966 --> 01:55:48,672
Chris: According, again, according to recovering Hunbot, it sounded like she was sinking a lot of time and effort, and they were doing the love bombing thing, and they were really trying to bring her into the fold and spend a lot of time doing this. So it seems like it sucks up a lot of time. I'd say hi.

816
01:55:48,736 --> 01:56:10,336
Kayla: And that's the other thing about mlms, is that it's presented as, like, here's a job for you. You get to be this independent salesperson, but then, like, your entire identity ends up becoming this thing. It's not just, like, your job. It's you are like this. Your entire life is being this brand ambassador. You have to use the products, and you have to constantly be posting about the products. You have to constantly have to be.

817
01:56:10,368 --> 01:56:15,750
Chris: Talking to somebody in line at the grocery store or at least back when, you know, went places, literally.

818
01:56:16,410 --> 01:56:17,350
Kayla: It's a cult.

819
01:56:17,690 --> 01:56:26,802
Chris: Yeah. And not just that, but, like, we talked about this for a hot second on the show today, but the company is exploiting you for your social capital.

820
01:56:26,906 --> 01:56:27,514
Kayla: Right, right.

821
01:56:27,562 --> 01:56:36,550
Chris: So it's like they. They know that you have all of this credential built up with your friend circle, with your social media circle, whatever, and.

822
01:56:36,850 --> 01:56:39,006
Kayla: Oh, God, and they exploit that.

823
01:56:39,038 --> 01:56:39,246
Chris: Yeah.

824
01:56:39,278 --> 01:56:41,358
Kayla: It's literally like a parasite hijacking you.

825
01:56:41,414 --> 01:56:42,614
Chris: Yeah, exactly. Yeah.

826
01:56:42,662 --> 01:56:45,854
Kayla: You do get you. It's a Borg. It is horrible.

827
01:56:45,942 --> 01:56:51,902
Chris: Yeah, I know. That's right. Because you're not just selling to them, you're also trying to get them to join. Yeah, join us.

828
01:56:52,046 --> 01:56:56,334
Kayla: And rituals pretty high up there, in my opinion.

829
01:56:56,422 --> 01:56:56,878
Chris: Yeah.

830
01:56:56,974 --> 01:57:09,384
Kayla: And like we said, hip hop ritual. Hip hop ritual. Might. You do this, you do this, you do crunches. Kayla's and no charismatic leader, but I think we don't really need one here because everything is.

831
01:57:09,432 --> 01:57:15,488
Chris: I'll say the CEO exists, but low. I think if Shanti would just take over.

832
01:57:15,584 --> 01:57:16,232
Kayla: Yeah.

833
01:57:16,376 --> 01:57:21,888
Chris: Then all of a sudden it would become super charismatic. And I think he could go toe toe with Mary Kay.

834
01:57:22,064 --> 01:57:25,832
Kayla: Oh, yeah. But Mary Kay built an empire. Shanti.

835
01:57:25,936 --> 01:57:26,712
Chris: That's true.

836
01:57:26,856 --> 01:57:28,432
Kayla: Shanti is just great at what he does.

837
01:57:28,456 --> 01:57:29,540
Chris: He's just a guru.

838
01:57:29,890 --> 01:57:33,230
Kayla: He is. I would follow Shanti into hell.

839
01:57:33,850 --> 01:57:35,034
Chris: So we're calling it a cult.

840
01:57:35,122 --> 01:57:38,786
Kayla: Yeah, I. Yes, I am. And you did. So it's a cult, guys.

841
01:57:38,898 --> 01:57:39,474
Chris: All right.

842
01:57:39,562 --> 01:57:40,522
Kayla: Don't join a cult.

843
01:57:40,666 --> 01:57:43,114
Chris: Don't. Don't join cults, everybody.

844
01:57:43,242 --> 01:57:45,346
Kayla: That's the takeaway here.

845
01:57:45,378 --> 01:58:12,026
Chris: Don't do it. If I had to say takeaway for this, I think it's approach with kindness, if you can. That's my. My preferred through line for this episode is if you can try to approach somebody that has fallen under influence of things like this with understanding and kindness and try not to be confrontational. And I know I'm talking to myself as much as I am to any listener about that. It's really hard to do.

846
01:58:12,058 --> 01:58:38,106
Kayla: Just make sure you don't get dragged down yourself. And I think, unfortunately, we're probably moving into an era where this thing may become very common. Common because we are experiencing such high levels of unemployment and people are losing their livelihoods, and there's a lot of people are going to be desperate for work and desperate to feel a sense of control and desperate to have all the things that an MLM can provide.

847
01:58:38,298 --> 01:58:39,106
Chris: Can promise.

848
01:58:39,178 --> 01:58:49,030
Kayla: Can promise. Sorry, can't provide. Says they can provide. So it might be incumbent on a lot of us to prevent, combat and be gentle.

849
01:58:49,650 --> 01:58:50,510
Chris: I agree.

850
01:58:50,930 --> 01:58:55,506
Kayla: Thanks so much to Alonda Carter, covering hunbot for talking to us today. That was amazing.

851
01:58:55,578 --> 01:58:57,450
Chris: Yeah. Thanks for deborgifying people.

852
01:58:57,570 --> 01:58:58,218
Kayla: Yes.

853
01:58:58,354 --> 01:59:14,444
Chris: Sorry that you were assimilated by the Borg as well. I'm glad you escaped, but definitely go check out her YouTube channel. And actually, there's a separate reason why you should go check out her YouTube channel. Because we here at Carltage is weird. Are finally going to be interview guests ourselves.

854
01:59:14,572 --> 01:59:15,240
Kayla: What?

855
01:59:15,620 --> 01:59:17,796
Chris: I know. It makes me feel so important and cool.

856
01:59:17,828 --> 01:59:19,436
Kayla: Oh, my God, we are so important and cool.

857
01:59:19,508 --> 01:59:29,668
Chris: So we are going to be making an appearance on her channel. As soon as that is up, we will definitely share and link and all that stuff on social medias.

858
01:59:29,684 --> 01:59:30,828
Kayla: And you better go watch it.

859
01:59:30,884 --> 01:59:40,934
Chris: Yeah, you better watch it. Swear to God. All right, this is Chris, this is Kayla, and this has been cult or just weird?

860
01:59:41,102 --> 01:59:42,838
Kayla: Didn't we say were not gonna do that anymore?

861
01:59:42,974 --> 01:59:45,518
Chris: Yeah, but then you just said cult, so I had to say.

862
01:59:45,534 --> 01:59:47,090
Kayla: Cause you were looking. They didn't want to do.

863
01:59:49,630 --> 01:59:51,750
Chris: We should sort that shit out eventually. Yeah.